Pizzaiola Restaurant is a family owned and operated restaurant and has been serving fine Italian cuisine for over 30 years. Our goal is to offer fresh, homemade food daily for the entire family in a friendly atmosphere. We are committed to bringing you the best Pizza and Food in North Babylon. We are conveniently located on Deer Park Avenue in Sunset Plaza Shopping Center.
Stuffed panini bread, calzones & Italian standards served in a spacious, contemporary dining room.
Jaz Khan
We had our first bite of NY pizza this year. We got the MVP slice that consisted of different types of sauces. Unfortunately, I don’t see it listed on their website and I don’t remember the names of the sauces. It was good. And if anyone knows, please do share.
… moreNew Yorkie
This is my new favorite Italian restaurant. The food is consistently delicious, and the Napolitan pizza in particular is absolutely perfect. But I’m leaving this review for the extraordinary customer service (based on more than one experience.)
For my last order, which was through GrubHub, they called to inform me that they accidentally sent me the wrong pizza (while the GrubHub driver was still en route.) Their own driver was at my house shortly afterwards and I ended up with two pies so my neighbors got a free pizza!
To the owners and management team, thank you for conducting your business in such an amazing manner.
… moreJames Green
We had a great experience, the customer service was incredible and truly made us feel like family. We tried a few slices: Sicilian, plain, pepperoni, and white pizza, along with mozzarella sticks and a cannoli. Everything was amazing! Can’t wait to come back.
… moreLoyda Rosario
I recently moved to Long Island and had received a coupon/flyer in the mail for a free large pizza from here. I thought that was such a nice thing to do! It was delicious when I tried it a couple of months ago, so I decided to go back again yesterday for more because it was so good. You earned my business!
Pizza is delicious, the place is clean and there’s plenty of space to sit and eat. Thank you!
… moreProphetgu3
First time there and I wasn’t disappointed. Great friendly cozy atmosphere. It isn’t loud and boisterous even though it was lunchtime. It’s almost as if behavior etiquette is understood in that place. Our waitress Gabriella was extremely pleasant and knowledgeable and asked questions on how we enjoyed the food and asked for feedback on if anything needs to be improved. Nope!
My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza we had half pepperoni and half vegetables which was quite flavorful and tasty. Not overbearing with salt and oil. What I really like is that you can order your food and have a seat. I will definitely be back I really love the relaxing vibe in there. No one was loud and overbearing just a nice casual quiet restaurant where you can enjoy your food.
… moreM&M
The staff was very friendly, helpful, the guys the pizza was delicious, the restaurant was very clean, I loved it!
… moreChristian Milano
My favorite local pizza place! Solid regular slice, solid vodka grandma slice, awesome fried chicken Panini‘s, great chicken masala! The staff is extremely friendly and makes coming even more worthwhile. One gentleman in particular, Moe, is an outstanding gentleman. He always gives the warmest greeting and the most positive vibes.
… moreCAS&ARSC Smile
Peter and his team are fantastic and their pizza is my daughter and her friend’s favorite local spot, we just ordered again tonight. He goes above and beyond to for the community, he even followed up on on a PTA inquiry last month (12/8) when we didn’t answer back quick enough, eager to support the children in any way he can. Thank you all especially Peter, sending good vibes now and always!
-l
… moreDr Christine Antoldi
First time and loved it! The food was delicious and fresh. Very clean, great service. Took home Sicilian pizza to try, it was crazy good. Will definitely be coming often. Thank you, Moe!!
… moreYael W
Love the food here; its our go to Comfort Italian Food. We enjoy dining in and sitting in the back. Penne Ala vodka is too good! Big portions – you’ll have leftovers. Staff is friendly. Wish i could give more than 5 stars.
… more