Leslie Alvarez
My 17 year old just went with his 3 friends. My son said the best pizza ever. We are going tomorrow asap. PART 2 We arrived at 1 pm today. I could smell the pizza from outside, which means it’s good. We ordered a large peperoni and sausage pizza. It only took about 15 min. Meanwhile, the waiter came and gave us little garlic breads. The artwork was beautiful, the tables, the whole restaurant was nice. People are smiling and happy. The waiter came 3 times to check on us and the owner. Can’t wait to go back. Oh, and the large pizza had 8 large slices . Delicious !!! Oh, and we had to take 4 slices home in a cool box because the pieces were so big that the 3 of us could not eat the whole pizza. Update we keep ordering pizza. Too bad we did not know about this place before. It’s so so satisfying. Fast delicious I get extra crispy crust.
… moreAshley
This place is amazing! Great pizza and great service! A taste of New York right here in SMA.
… moreBrian Smith
This is the place to find excellent comfort food. My family wants to have it every week. The staff is very friendly and will make you feel welcome. Also, delivery is typically very fast so pizza is hot when it arrives. I recommend everyone to try it for themselves.
… morebrent backman
Food was amazing. No idea why we didn’t try sooner. Owner is very personable
**here tonight for the second time. Pizza is on point.
… moreTiV
Very good pizza, fast free delivery in SMA, willing to do half and half, they can speak English in the phone which is nice since we are learning Spanish and phone conversations are a bit intimidating.
Id love it if they would list what they have for dessert, on the menu.
I also wish they were open more nights of the week! ☺️
… moreErik Meltzer
I really wanted to love this place as the pizza in NY is my favorite. I Ordered a pizza for delivery with extra sauce on the side. I got a pizza with extra sauce on it which made it a soggy mess pizza. Issue was caused by a language barrier. I also ordered 2 coke zeros and received 2 regular cokes. The pizza sauce wasn’t my thing either and the pizza was definitely not a thin crusted pizza. Not the worst pizza I’ve ever had but unfortunately I can’t recommend it. I contacted them and they offered to comp my next order, but unfortunately, we are leaving the area.
… moreAmber Smith
I haven’t had the pizza so I can’t speak to that, but the pepperoni rolls are AMAZING. We are so happy to have found this restaurant in SMA and will be visiting often during our time here. The staff is always friendly and the food is quick but also fresh hand made. The price value is great. Highly recommend the pep rolls. The sauce they come with has great flavor as well!
… moreEithne McBride
An actual NY pie from a pizzeria owned by an actual New Yorker?? In San Miguel de Allende?? STAHHHHP! But it’s true! And it was the perfect balance of flavors and a crisp (but foldable) and flavorful crust. So so good! If you’re craving bona fide New York pizza, Joe’s got you covered!
… moreDavid Paul G
Great pizza with a lot of toppings. I have eaten/ordered pizza at least four times. I have not tried any of the other dishes. I usually order a large and make three meals out of it.
… moreJever Porras
The ambience and aesthetic of the place made me feel very nostalgic; As if I was a child going to a restaurant my Mum after school.
Staff is very kind and made us feel welcome right away.
We weren’t that hungry so we order garlic knots and the Promo they had for the Rolls.
Quick and efficient, those garlic knots are enough to make a grown man want to cry and the rolls are crispy and doughy in every right way.
Will definitely go back for a proper pie.
(Pricing is incredibly good and reasonable.)
… more