Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4195 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758
Phone: (516) 820-1111
Website: https://www.pizzeriaundici.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizzeria Undici
At Pizza Undici, we take immense pride in our unwavering commitment to crafting the finest pizzas and providing exceptional customer care. Rooted in the values …
Pizzeria Undici | Massapequa NY – Facebook
4195 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758 (516) 820-1111 Free Delivery! Winter Hours ❄️ Sunday – Thursday 10:30AM-9PM Friday 10:30AM-11PM Saturday 11AM-11PM …
Pizzeria Undici (@pizzeria_undici) • Instagram photos and videos
Family Owned & Operated We welcome you to experience the nostalgia of authentic, old-school pizza 4195 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY (516) 820-1111 …
Reviews
Anthony Pilo
This review comes from genuine appreciation and respect for a business that truly shows up for its customers. **Pizzeria Undici** isn’t just a pizza place—it’s the kind of spot that restores faith in great food and even better people.
I live about **15–20 m**minutes away**, and unlike almost every other pizza place around, Pizzeria Undici **doesn’t shut down early or stop taking orders** 15–30 minutes before closing. I work late, and a lot of nights that means missing dinner because places close early. This place goes the extra mile and actually takes care of people who work long hours, which I truly respect.
The food is on another level. Their **El Clásico (L Classico) signature pie** is unreal. The **sauce is out of this world**, the flavor is perfectly balanced, and the quality is consistent every single time. If I could give **10 stars**, I would—because the taste alone deserves it.
I’m also a **business owner myself**, so I pay close attention to how companies treat their customers.
Last week, I was just outside their delivery range and had to order through DoorDash, which I completely understand. The issue was that the El Clásico wasn’t listed on the DoorDash menu. I called the shop directly, explained the situation, and instead of brushing it off, they told me, *“Order a regular pie, tell us what you want, and we’ve got you.”* And they absolutely delivered. They made the exact pie I wanted, **covered the extra cost**, and even **threw in cookies**.
This is the type of ownership, management, and team that deserves loyalty and support. Businesses like this are rare and deserve to be paid forward. Distance doesn’t matter to me—I’ll drive there **no matter the time**. Highly recommended to anyone who appreciates incredible pizza and even better people.
… moreI live about **15–20 m**minutes away**, and unlike almost every other pizza place around, Pizzeria Undici **doesn’t shut down early or stop taking orders** 15–30 minutes before closing. I work late, and a lot of nights that means missing dinner because places close early. This place goes the extra mile and actually takes care of people who work long hours, which I truly respect.
The food is on another level. Their **El Clásico (L Classico) signature pie** is unreal. The **sauce is out of this world**, the flavor is perfectly balanced, and the quality is consistent every single time. If I could give **10 stars**, I would—because the taste alone deserves it.
I’m also a **business owner myself**, so I pay close attention to how companies treat their customers.
Last week, I was just outside their delivery range and had to order through DoorDash, which I completely understand. The issue was that the El Clásico wasn’t listed on the DoorDash menu. I called the shop directly, explained the situation, and instead of brushing it off, they told me, *“Order a regular pie, tell us what you want, and we’ve got you.”* And they absolutely delivered. They made the exact pie I wanted, **covered the extra cost**, and even **threw in cookies**.
This is the type of ownership, management, and team that deserves loyalty and support. Businesses like this are rare and deserve to be paid forward. Distance doesn’t matter to me—I’ll drive there **no matter the time**. Highly recommended to anyone who appreciates incredible pizza and even better people.
Veni, Vidi, Comedi
Pizza Undici – 9.5/10 (legit contender for best slice in the area)
Just demolished a buffalo chicken slice at Pizza Undici and I’m still thinking about it. This place is doing something special: they’re taking classic pizza seriously while throwing modern flavors at it without ever missing the mark. The crust is that perfect thin, leopard-spotted, crackly-but-still-foldable Neapolitan-meets-NY hybrid with zero flop. You pick it up and it holds like it’s got a backbone.
The buffalo slice? Stupid good. Chunks of tender, juicy chicken (actually moist, not the dry shredded stuff you usually get), draped in a buffalo sauce that hits the ideal heat level and somehow stays at the perfect temperature even after sitting in the warmer for a bit. Blue cheese drizzle and a little celery garnish for crunch – it’s the kind of slice you finish and immediately contemplate grabbing another.
Everything else I’ve tried (pepperoni rolls, chicken parm sandwich, garlic knots) is equally on point. They’re cranking out pies nonstop, the place is massive and spotless, and the energy behind the counter is infectious – staff flying around slinging boxes, laughing, joking with customers, but never dropping the ball on service. You feel the love.
Whether you’re sitting in the huge dining area or running in for a quick couple slices to go, it all works. Pizza Undici isn’t playing around – they’re putting out some of the most consistently delicious pizza I’ve had in a long time.
Do yourself a favor and get there. You won’t be disappointed. Thank you, Undici crew – keep killing it!
… moreJust demolished a buffalo chicken slice at Pizza Undici and I’m still thinking about it. This place is doing something special: they’re taking classic pizza seriously while throwing modern flavors at it without ever missing the mark. The crust is that perfect thin, leopard-spotted, crackly-but-still-foldable Neapolitan-meets-NY hybrid with zero flop. You pick it up and it holds like it’s got a backbone.
The buffalo slice? Stupid good. Chunks of tender, juicy chicken (actually moist, not the dry shredded stuff you usually get), draped in a buffalo sauce that hits the ideal heat level and somehow stays at the perfect temperature even after sitting in the warmer for a bit. Blue cheese drizzle and a little celery garnish for crunch – it’s the kind of slice you finish and immediately contemplate grabbing another.
Everything else I’ve tried (pepperoni rolls, chicken parm sandwich, garlic knots) is equally on point. They’re cranking out pies nonstop, the place is massive and spotless, and the energy behind the counter is infectious – staff flying around slinging boxes, laughing, joking with customers, but never dropping the ball on service. You feel the love.
Whether you’re sitting in the huge dining area or running in for a quick couple slices to go, it all works. Pizza Undici isn’t playing around – they’re putting out some of the most consistently delicious pizza I’ve had in a long time.
Do yourself a favor and get there. You won’t be disappointed. Thank you, Undici crew – keep killing it!
Thomas Martinez
Fantastic local pizzeria in Massapequa with its own flair & retro coke diner feel.
The decor alone is amazing as you walk in & are a fan of Coke-Cola products & we haven’t even got to the food yet!
Pizza was great thin crust pizza, Fantastic flavors behind them.. Vodka Pie was great the sauce was nice & creamy, you taste that fresh mozzarella definitely a winner!
MVP pie was phenomenal the flavors of the marinara, vodka & pesto blend together creating this Fantastic bite from start to finish!
Definitely worth a trip if your in the vicinity, cant wait to go back & try other items!
… moreThe decor alone is amazing as you walk in & are a fan of Coke-Cola products & we haven’t even got to the food yet!
Pizza was great thin crust pizza, Fantastic flavors behind them.. Vodka Pie was great the sauce was nice & creamy, you taste that fresh mozzarella definitely a winner!
MVP pie was phenomenal the flavors of the marinara, vodka & pesto blend together creating this Fantastic bite from start to finish!
Definitely worth a trip if your in the vicinity, cant wait to go back & try other items!
Shane Rossi
Place is a solid staple in Massapequa. I remember this used to be a bagel store. Now it’s awesome pizza !
… moreAntonio
I can’t believe I’m saying this, but this was the best regular slice I’ve ever had! Everything was delicious. Great service, too!
… moreM B
Undici pizza is pretty rad. PAPER THIN slices which can be tough to pull off, but I think it works here. Flavors were dynamic and the pizza was perfectly cooked for the style they’re going for. The regular slice was great, but the MVP (marinara, vodka, pesto) was the real winner for me. Well-balanced and is the type of slice I could eat all day long. The staff seemed to love where they worked and seemed to be having a lot of fun. I went close to 8pm and the guy gave me a free slice on the house. Once this place gets beer it’s perfect.
… moreStacey Palazzolo
We had my daughter’s birthday party today, right in the middle of Football Sunday and the breast cancer fundraiser this pizzeria was hosting — and they still absolutely nailed it! The food was delivered to the second and arrived piping hot. We ordered pizzas for the kids (which disappeared instantly!) and the roll platter for the adults — caprese chicken, sausage & pepper, spinach, chicken parm, and eggplant parm. Every single roll was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made.
Every parent at the party asked me where the food came from — it was that good. It’s not easy to impress a room full of hungry parents and excited kids, but they pulled it off effortlessly, even on one of their busiest days. Amazing food, top-notch service, and a team that truly cares about their customers and their community.
Highly, highly recommend
… moreEvery parent at the party asked me where the food came from — it was that good. It’s not easy to impress a room full of hungry parents and excited kids, but they pulled it off effortlessly, even on one of their busiest days. Amazing food, top-notch service, and a team that truly cares about their customers and their community.
Highly, highly recommend
Joseph Lanzarotta
Really good pizza here got to try the upside down Sicilian regular Sicilian white slice vodka Sicilian and vodka regular slice I do have to say the upside down and the white were my favorites! I loved the sauce they make a great one and the white slice was perfectly crispy and great flavor! The regular Sicilian and vodka Sicilian was good as well but for me I like more sauce but that’s just my preference but i definitely need to come back to try the rest of the slices all looked amazing can’t wait to come back!
… moreMike k
One of the best slices on Long Island.
It’s not that thick doughy pizza you find all over Long Island
This is thin. Well done. Perfect pizza.
If you’re a fan of portnoys reviews and have been to the top places he likes in the tristate area this is right up there.
I’ve had every 8.8 or better on the one bite list. There is finally a Long Island pizza place that deserves to be there.
… moreIt’s not that thick doughy pizza you find all over Long Island
This is thin. Well done. Perfect pizza.
If you’re a fan of portnoys reviews and have been to the top places he likes in the tristate area this is right up there.
I’ve had every 8.8 or better on the one bite list. There is finally a Long Island pizza place that deserves to be there.
Manny Karl
Came here for the first time and we ordered a few different items for lunch. Their regular slice is a thin crust and that was real good. We got into their Sicilian, grandma, and buffalo chicken pinwheel did not disappoint either. The service was just as good as the food. Will be back again. Thanks Anthony!
… more