Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Say good-bye to boring pizza! Serving a rotating menu of uniquely craft pizzas. Made with our scratch-made 100-hour fermented dough, scratch-made marinara sauce, & freshly grated mozzarella… Cooked on a stone deck to a crisp perfection! Also serving a full menu of vegan-friendly, plant-based pizza and breadstick options.
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Pizza Uncommon – Madison | Madison IN – Facebook
Pizza Uncommon – Madison: Online Menu – 101 East Main Street Madison, IN Restaurant | Order now! Online menu for Pizza Uncommon – Madison in Ma.
Menus | Pizza Uncommon in IN
Margherita. Homemade marinara, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil · Crab Rangoon · Shiitake Mushroom Truffle · Hot Honey Pepperoni · Vodka …
Pizza Uncommon – PERMANENTLY CLOSED – Visit Madison
Pizza Uncommon serves uniquely crafted pies, made with our scratch-made & 100-hour fermented dough, scratch-made marinara sauce, & freshly grated mozzarella.
Reviews
Holly
New favorite pizza place!!! They have the most unique pizza topping combinations, and all are delicious. The gluten free crust is also amazing, and there’s a ton of great vegan options as well! Will be eating here every time I visit Madison.
… moreHenry Bowman
Pizza was really good; a different (uncommon) flavor that deviates just a little from other really good pizzas. It’s very tastey and there is a large assortment of options.
Service was pretty good.
Tables were clean, as was everything else. Lighting is pretty good. The historic building is well-renovated and nicely decorated. The only negative is the many obnoxious TVs playing non-stop sports. The TVs ruin an otherwise very nice environment.
… moreService was pretty good.
Tables were clean, as was everything else. Lighting is pretty good. The historic building is well-renovated and nicely decorated. The only negative is the many obnoxious TVs playing non-stop sports. The TVs ruin an otherwise very nice environment.
Maura Hoff
So good that we ate here twice! Many different unique options, all delicious. Most important to us was the gluten free cauliflower crust option, which was thin and crispy and very good. Options for beer and cider for the grownups, games available to entertain kids while you wait. Our favorite was the Mexican street corn pizza.
… moreWinter Travels
An exceptional take on pizza, outstanding crust that is perfect for both bread sticks and the pizza. Great unique flavors that offer plenty of options to try on each visit. Very family friendly and fun to play the available games while your food is being made! A truly uncommon place, will continue to come here.
… moreJesse Byerly
I am not exaggerating when I say this is some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. The crust is the perfect blend of chewy and crunchy, and beautifully flavorful on its own. I would eat it by itself! And WITH the toppings, it is game OVER for me. I got the Sweet Grape Gorgonzola, fully intending to not be able to finish it, and quickly ate the whole thing in one sitting! The creamy, salty gorgonzola, with the peppery arugula, the sweet and juicy grapes, and the HONEY DRIZZLE!?? ❤️✨
Pizza Uncommon…. Thank you. I will definitely be back!
… morePizza Uncommon…. Thank you. I will definitely be back!
Incendio
Fantastic Pizza and Stix. Friendly staff, great beer selection, and games for the kids! I highly recommend for locals and visitors alike. Pictured is the Crab Rangoon (DANGEROUSLY Good ) and Classic Pepperoni. Check that stretch! The Sea Salt breadstick check every box for a great stick. Crispy and crunchy outside and fluffy and hot inside.
… moreLee Adrianson
Was in town for a quick mini vacation and stopped in here for a bite. We chose the chicken bacon ranch pizza and breadsticks. Food was delicious. Definitely homemade not boxed. People were friendly and prices decent. If I were feeling more adventurous,I would have tried one of the uncommon and unique offerings.
… moreJeff Beitz
Very good pizza, we loved the crust. The sauce and ingredients were also very good. The house made fennel sausage is a must. Very pleasant front of house. Huge Vegan menu also, which my daughter was thrilled to find.
… moretori jo boldery
i can’t remember the exact name of the pizza i had (honey habanero something i think) but it was easily the best tasting pizza i have ever had in my life. i’ll never forget it so long as i live. the other pizza we got was a cheesy bacon macaroni one and it wasn’t anything special, just something a picky eater or kids would like. the interesting and unconventional pizza options here though are amazing and i want to come back and try everything.
however it’s (understandably) on the pricy side. $15 for a 10 inch pizza (as of 2022) but it’s worth it if you are going to get toppings that are hard to find/unusual. also had plenty of options for vegetarian, vegan and for those with food allergies. and there was a few classic / typical pizzas on the menu if you are picky, but this isn’t a restaurant for anyone that isn’t willing to make an adventurous order.
… morehowever it’s (understandably) on the pricy side. $15 for a 10 inch pizza (as of 2022) but it’s worth it if you are going to get toppings that are hard to find/unusual. also had plenty of options for vegetarian, vegan and for those with food allergies. and there was a few classic / typical pizzas on the menu if you are picky, but this isn’t a restaurant for anyone that isn’t willing to make an adventurous order.
Scott Russ
One of the best pizzas I have had in a long time… CRUST IS AWESOME. We drove from Louisville to Madison just to eat here… Was worth the nice hr senic drive. We got the Big Mac and a sweet chick…..
… more