Diane Jones
Great Pizza. So glad they have another location in a different part of town == more pizza from Pizza Thief. Super thin crust, but still has a chew and great flavor. Sauce is super delicious too like a tomato jam almost. Had the Hot Tony which delivered a flavor bomb and deliciousness with plenty kick and great medly of cheeses. I have enjoyed many of their pies and always prefer to start with the house made combos, so Meat Sweats – check! The tiramisu is amazing – my husband went on a deep dive of tiramisu from a bunch of different places and Pizza Thief’s was a champ. They have some great beer options on tap and the best lemon soda I’ve ever had. Someday I’d love to try their sandwiches but it is hard faced with such great pizza. Their chocolate hazlenut cookies are definitely delicious. The Division menu is slightly different from the NW Vaughn but, pretty sure I’d always find too many options anyway.
… moreJosie Kressner
Great pizza by the slice and great atmosphere inside. Exactly what you want at a pizza joint.
… moreMaria Hernandez
Muy delicioso! Super clean, nice set up and the pizza slices were perfect. The cesar kale salad is a must!.
… moreLisa macpherson
Best pizza ever! We loved it so much that we took some back home to Canada.
The staff were kind and knowledgeable. We are already planning our visit back.
… moreMason Mccloskey
I tried several different pizzas and was glad I did. Everything was extremely tasty and not just your typical pizza spot. We got a cannoli to go and highly recommend you do the same!!!
… moreKim Roy
The pizza and cookies are just amazing and I love the vibe of the place. I can’t wait to go back! It’s worth the price.
… moreKoda Ferguson
The pizza itself was amazing, the pepperoni was phenomenal, had a great little kick to it that you don’t get from many other pizza places, the cheese was wonderfully stringy, and the crust was soft and wonderfully chewy.
I only had a 10 second interaction with the staff, which was exceptionally off putting. I ordered this as a take out order, and when I arrived to pick it up, one of the staff greeted me with a huge smile and said that someone would be with me in just a moment, and then the individual who did assist me a few seconds later asked if they could help me and looked at me like I was the heated pile of rotten roadkill on the hottest summers day on the bottom of his bare foot. I don’t know if he/they were having a bad day, if they were in a bad mood, or what their issue was, but it was the most uncomfortable, unpleasant, and unwelcome sensation and interaction I’ve had in a long time in a public location.
While the pizza was amazing, just because of that brief instance, I’ll likely never go back in person, and only ever order delivery in the future.
… moreBryan Aalberg
The Cesar salad might be the best salad I have ever had. So damn good. Just a great balance of flavors. Highly recommend. The pizza is good. It’s not my favorite. That’s Ranch. But it’s just a step down for me from that. It’s like a 9 out of 10 for me and that’s pretty damn good.
… morePaul Salcuni
Their pizza is some of the best I’ve had and I’m from New York. We got the meat sweats and the kale caesar. The flavors of the kale caesar are spot on, but they need to massage the kale — it was very tough.
… moreManu Torres
My new favorite pizza! I love the sourdough crust. I had the pepperoni and it was delicious. Can’t wait to work my way through the whole menu!
… more