Josh Stevens
Excellent service, very friendly woman on the phone that took our pickup order. Price is fair for the area, and quality was excellent. The garlic knots were incredible and the pepperoni pizza and cheese pizza we picked up were great! Appreciated the very friendly and courteous staff members.
… moreSadonia Melson
We called in takeout Saturday night. We were told 45 min. No biggie, went there 45min later, walked in and the place smelled great! However, they hadn’t even started on our pizza yet. We were there for an additional 30+ min. They seemed to have to many people braiding the crust on pizza. Pizzas weren’t making into the oven very fast at all. The big thick braided crust was unnecessary. The pizza itself tasted good, but not worth the wait or cost. The pizza was super expensive. Honestly if your staying up here and have rented a house with an oven, go to lowes grocery store and get one of their Pizzas for $17.99. It will save you soooo much headache, hassle and money.
… moreGrant Fox
Been passing thru Angel Fire for the better part of 20 years. First time at Pizza Stop, what a treat! Great pizza! The family and I will be back, next time we’re in town.
… moreDon B
Even though they have a few tables, as of 7/31/2025, they are offering only takeout, which is what we wanted anyway. I called in the order, which was hot and ready when promised. The salad and pepperoni pizza were good and a decent value, but not outstanding IMHO.
… moreMolly McClellan
I haven’t even picked up my pizza, but just the customer service alone compared to the other local pizza place is really no comparison at all. The lady that took our order over the phone called me buttercup! I mean, come on! Love it!
… moreDanell Karasek
Do not skip on this place!!! The pizza is fresh and delicious… and don’t get me started on the garlic rolls!!! The whole experience was the perfect end to the day.
… moreShane
Absolutely amazing pizza, even friendlier staff. You can tell the owners son gives 110%. Always right there to ask if we needed anything. Expensive but well worth it, you can tell the ingredients are good quality. I will be making this my go to!
Only critique would be adding some honey for dipping on the table for the thick rolled crust! Would be amazing!!
… moreAbraham Flores
First time stopping here and I must say that this pizza was simple amazing. Its location is just absolutely gorgeous.
… moreKimberly Sadat
It’s a cute little joint we like to visit when we come to Angel Fire. Pizza is always hot and fresh. Usually the pizza disappears before anyone can take a photo. The kids meal chicken fingers are good too. Garlic knots are delicious. The pizza we made our own. Two medium pizzas was good for 6 people.
… moreEdna Wong
Our go to place for pizza when we are in the area. Always delicious and fresh. We love the hand tossed crust and the garlic knots
… more