Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 72 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: (929) 337-6245
Website: http://www.pizzasecretnyc.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Secret is Temporarily Closed due to renovation
Pizza Secret is a casual gourmet wood burning pizzeria located in Brooklyn, NY and owned by executive chef Rosario Granieri.
Menus | Pizza Secret in Brooklyn, NY
See the menu for Pizza Secret in Brooklyn, NY. Open everyday for dine-in, kerbside pickup and no-contact delivery!
Rosario Granieri® (@pizzasecret) • Instagram photos and videos
… Napoli to NYC Pizzeria & Cucina Napoletana 16th Best Pizzeria by @50toppizza USA 72 5th ave Brooklyn NY 11217 ☎️ 929-337-6245”
Reviews
Aleh Ranchynski
Pizza Secret delivers an authentic Neapolitan experience with charm and warmth. The bright yellow exterior draws you in, but it’s the wood-fired oven and skilled, friendly staff that make the visit memorable. Inside, the space is cozy and stylish, lined with wine shelves, Italian posters, and awards that reflect their dedication to quality. The team prepares each pizza with care, using fresh ingredients and traditional techniques. The outdoor seating adds a relaxed neighborhood vibe, perfect for casual meals. Overall, Pizza Secret is a standout spot for delicious, handcrafted pizza served by a welcoming crew in a vibrant, inviting atmosphere.
… moreChase
Good pizza with a little twist to it — not your usual NYC slice/pie (think more neopolitan style- wood-fired). Flavors were solid and it felt different in a good way. Worth checking out if you’re nearby or want something a bit outside the standard pizza spots.
Ranked to 20 in the US for 2025
… moreRanked to 20 in the US for 2025
PR Cindy
This place was ranked the 16th in the US in 2025 and has consistently dominated the top 20 for the past 3 years, winning multiple national and international pizzeria awards! The PIZZA magic! ❤️
… moreChristian Hoehner
After a full day of exploring Brooklyn on foot we crashed here for a late lunch. The welcoming staff and service couldn’t have been friendlier or better. Fun atmosphere with plenty of breeze inside. Salad was crisp/fresh and the pizza was tasty. Would definitely recommend for a family looking for a nice, but quick, sit down lunch. Great job!
… moreRoberto Luca
Delicious pizza, light dough, tasty, quality ingredients. Quiet atmosphere, friendly and helpful staff. Excellent Neapolitan pizza. Espresso coffee very good, true Italian Thank you…
… moreAleks Brzezinski
This restaurant is of the best in NYC. Try the pizza and pasta you will be blown away. We tried the buffalo, americano, and truffle pizza and the cacio Pepe pasta, perfect. Delicious!! If I could give more stars I would. 5+ out of 5. Thank you to the excellent staff. Limoncello for a perfect end to the meal.
… moreKami
We stopped by for lunch with my partner and tried the Vesuvio pizza and a special artichoke cream pizza. Both were cooked perfectly by Francesco, the pizzaiolo, and tasted amazing.
We even met someone from Gambero Rosso while we were there, who was really impressed and kept saying how authentic and truly Neapolitan the pizza was.
The owner was super friendly, the staff were welcoming, the vibe was great, and the place itself is beautiful. Really good food and a lovely atmosphere — would definitely recommend
… moreWe even met someone from Gambero Rosso while we were there, who was really impressed and kept saying how authentic and truly Neapolitan the pizza was.
The owner was super friendly, the staff were welcoming, the vibe was great, and the place itself is beautiful. Really good food and a lovely atmosphere — would definitely recommend
Joanni Rodriguez
Pizza Secret has really good food with a great team. Everyone was happy to see us and treated us well. We had cacio e Pepe pizza which we devoured. Cacio e Pepe pasta and a different pasta which I didnt try. We all enjoyed everything we ordered but the biggest star was the Secret Salad. Simple, yet elegant, small but BIG flavor. It was so good we ordered another one so we wouldn’t have to share. Despite the intense heat outside and the trek to Brooklyn I will go there again… and again.
… moreKrystalye Legario
Me and my friends were craving for this pizza for a very long time and finally we had a time to hang out and eat here! The best pizza in NYC! Got the espresso martini by coleen and it was the best as ever❤️. The atmosphere and the ambience is very cozy all the server are very kind and attentive. Especially Coleen! We will definitely come back here
… moredave I
1/9/26 back for dinner with the guys.
We had a margarita pizza for the table, asked to have it crispy, it was not done crispy! Thin and wet, not great.
This seems to be the only way they know how to make it. No more pizza for me.
For my main meal i had the ziti with short rib, it was ok, not much flavor. The temperature of the dish was inconsistent, parts hot and parts luke warm. Not good either.
How can this happen?
Service is great, that’s the main thing they got going. HH specials are only $10 drinks, no food specials.
11/19/24 first time here as Pizza Secret.
Good decor, good service. Electronic menus.
I had a glass of Red, fine. Some bread. One of the guys ordered a HH pizza, i got one slice, it was ok, a bit thin, with wide crust.
For my meal i had the Pappardelle Bolognese. It was good, I’d get it again but will try other dishes first.
We will be back.
… moreWe had a margarita pizza for the table, asked to have it crispy, it was not done crispy! Thin and wet, not great.
This seems to be the only way they know how to make it. No more pizza for me.
For my main meal i had the ziti with short rib, it was ok, not much flavor. The temperature of the dish was inconsistent, parts hot and parts luke warm. Not good either.
How can this happen?
Service is great, that’s the main thing they got going. HH specials are only $10 drinks, no food specials.
11/19/24 first time here as Pizza Secret.
Good decor, good service. Electronic menus.
I had a glass of Red, fine. Some bread. One of the guys ordered a HH pizza, i got one slice, it was ok, a bit thin, with wide crust.
For my meal i had the Pappardelle Bolognese. It was good, I’d get it again but will try other dishes first.
We will be back.