Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pirate-themed Italian spot for pies & pasta with large, rustic dining area, salad bar & game room.
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 72 Solano Square, Benicia, CA 94510
Phone: (707) 745-1667
Website: http://www.mypizzapirate.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Pirate – Benicia, CA
Located in Benicia, Pizza Pirate is a community cornerstone serving the highest quality pizza, pasta, and more for over 50 years.
Pizza Pirate | Benicia CA – Facebook
Pizza Pirate ; Details. . 90% recommend (796 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 72 Solano Sq, Benicia, CA, United States, 94510 ; Links. . mypizzapirate.com …
Order Pizza Pirate – Benicia, CA Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Pizza Pirate at 72 Solano Sq in Benicia. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Kimberly Riggs
Love this place. We have heard about this place for years and finally went. So worth it. The food is amazing. Prices were reasonable and the atmosphere reminds me of what pizza places SHOULD BE. This brings back the fun family feel that we used to have when I was a kid in the 80’s. This will be our go-to place for family fun night.
… moreTomas Michaud
We ordered a vegetarian pizza for delivery and got the wrong one at first, which was frustrating after waiting a while and being hungry. When I called, there was some confusion, and I did have to push a bit to have the correct pizza delivered that night.
But they really made it right. The person who brought the replacement was very apologetic, and the pizza was excellent—fresh and delicious. The next morning, they even refunded the entire order and followed up with an apology, which I didn’t expect.
Mistakes happen. What matters is that they stood behind their service. I appreciate the effort and will order from Pizza Pirate again.
… moreBut they really made it right. The person who brought the replacement was very apologetic, and the pizza was excellent—fresh and delicious. The next morning, they even refunded the entire order and followed up with an apology, which I didn’t expect.
Mistakes happen. What matters is that they stood behind their service. I appreciate the effort and will order from Pizza Pirate again.
Scotty Hehehe
I live in Vallejo, so the Pirate is a bit out of the way for me. But I like to support independent and small business whenever I can. Pizza Pirate has a great looking restaurant and very thoughtful and cute “pirate” and high seas theme throughout, even with the naming schemes of their food. Because it’s out of the way, I only been here about 3 or 4 times. But 2 orders they forgot toppings I asked for and 1 time there was hardly any sauce on the pizza. I called and mentioned the sauce issue, but I was not looking for discounts or free pizza, just wanted to let them know about it. My latest order, I asked for olives with my pepperoni half, they noted it on the receipt and charged me, but there was no olives. Also, to me, the pepperoni seemed a bit skimpy, reminding me of Little Caesars or something. I didn’t think to take a pic until after we plated our slices. The combo half seemed fine. Somebody is not keeping tabs on quality control at the Pirate. I am disappointed. May not come back. You need to teach the employees to be accurate with orders and to make the pizza with enough toppings to make it worth the $$$. It is mostly bread, after all.
… moreLoreal Slofkosky
If you looked at my other posts, you can see I’m all about food. Also I’m not about $100+meals, rather I’m all about great food in a casual environment.
Pirate Pizza doesn’t disappoint. We had a regular garden salad which came with 2 fresh bread twists and cheese ravioli with pesto which came with 4 bread twists. Who would have thought a pizza place would have such great pasta?
Also as you can guess this place is kid friendly.
… morePirate Pizza doesn’t disappoint. We had a regular garden salad which came with 2 fresh bread twists and cheese ravioli with pesto which came with 4 bread twists. Who would have thought a pizza place would have such great pasta?
Also as you can guess this place is kid friendly.
Irene Mercure
Pizza Pirate in Benicia has a great salad bar & good pizza. Chad the owner is doing a great job keep this place going. It’s a Pirate theme pizza parole very cool, big restaurant with a game room & huge T.V. for sports games. Thank you again for the pizza & salad bar.
… moreJeremy Wong
Pizza pirate has always been great in benicia but especially now with the new ownership group! Chad and his team have really cleaned the place up and continue to provide the great pizza and pasta quality you would expect!
… moreTyara Walker
Honestly, I get better pizza at Costco and Sam’s Club and for way better price. I got the 8 inch pizza and it literally had less than 12 tiny chunks of chicken on it, my salad had more croutons and the croutons were bigger chunks. I only came here because of my sister‘s birthday. Way overpriced and definitely not worth it. Also the bread twist that came with a salad were super overcooked. If you look at the picture, I attached, these were the last slices of my pizza and there’s barely anything on it. Literally felt like I was eating bread with barely anything on it, but I didn’t want it going to waste.
… moreWide Open
Pizza is still delicious but the loss of salad bar and desire to help customers from the kids behind the counter is a real disappointment. Every pie and bread stick that came out of the oven while we waited over a half hour for a personal salad, two bread sticks, and a small pizza had huge air bubbles that were destroying the items piling up as they came out of the oven while all the employees were standing around hiding in the back. After waiting 20 minutes when I was told it would only take 10 minutes to get food we went back to the counter only to have the employees tell us they had no idea about the order we’re talking about. Finally after going through all the employees we were given part of our order and had to remind them about the rest. Upon arriving home 45 minutes later we found these so called bread sticks that resembled piles of dough bubbles. Sad to see a great pizza place go so far downhill.
… moreRaybies Flynn
Good stuff! I ordered the weekly lunch special that included a salad, slice of pepperoni and a small drink. The pizza had a thick crust. I went in at 11:30. There was plenty of seating and the food was fresh!
… moreMohita Traveler
The pizza wasn’t very impressive and felt overpriced. It was mostly thick bread with a lot of cheese, but lacked flavorful sauces or spices. Compared to places like Pieology, MOD, or Blaze, it just didn’t have as much taste or variety. Otherwise, the place was clean and the staff were friendly.
… more