Sarah Whealon
Had an awesome time last week at Pizza Pi. This isn’t just your average pizza – it was awesome!!! We didn’t expect so many choices. Great pizza, yummy drinks, combined with a fun and unique experience = win/win. Highly recommend!
… moreJanice Newberry
Fun boat stop for pizza. Call ahead to order can be backed up. Great drinks. Cute Wisconsin theme
… moreRiley Marie L
Such a unique and unforgettable experience! Enjoying delicious pizza in the middle of the water, surrounded by stunning islands and crystal clear views, was absolutely surreal. The pizza was tasty, the frozen drinks were refreshing, and the whole vibe was just perfect. 10/10 recommend adding this spot to your bucket list, it’s a must do!
… moreRyan Willis
Excellent pizza, great margaritas!
We snorkeled right up into our “booth” the minute they opened, and were greeted by friendly staff. They warned us right away they were working on a 20-pizza order and might have a bit of a wait. We waited an hour but it was worth it.
They apparently have large excursion boats that pull up and order ~20 pizzas Monday, Wednesday, Friday morning and afternoon. That’s worth consideration, but didn’t ultimately seem to be a problem for us
… moreTaylor Nicole
What a cool spot for pizza and drinks! We visited after a shark diving experience and it was the best pizza I’ve had on island. The boat is colorful, staff is so friendly, and the seating is so cool, with floats right in the beautiful water. My only complaint is that I don’t own my own boat to go enjoy it more often!
… moreEric Heidemann
Best pizza ww have ever eaten! We had the peachy goat pizza. So good!
… moreLogan Kirschner
10 STARS to Pizza Pi.
Fantastic view on the water while eating incredible pizza that can also be made with dietary restrictions all while creating unforgettable memories with alcohol? It doesn’t even stop there… Rare to find, their customer service is beyond exceptional and deserves a globally recognized award.
Do yourself a favor and make this place a goal to visit. You deserve it, and Pizza Pi deserves it more 🙂
Can’t even describe how satisfied I am with this experience.
… moreJohn Whealon
The pizzas are delicious! Not premade. The rafts were great to relax on. What a great experience! Highly recommend!
… moreKathey Pesce
While on a charter trip we came across Pizza Pi at Christmas Cove. Wow! Who would have thought of making fresh pizzas on the water. So fresh the dough is made daily on the boat!! If you havent ran across this sweet little gem…it is a must do on your bucket list!! We had the Sunburnt Tourist and the Castaway. Both hot, flavorful, and delicious!! One of our friends had a stromboli. Im not a big fan of strombolis because I have always felt it was too much thick dough. I was able to try it and it was delicious. Not too much dough nor was it thick. It was perfect! So just remember if you are on a boat and in the area of Christmas Cove do not worry about packing your lunch. Google Pizza Pi, pull up their menu, and order your pizza. They can deliver it to your boat, pull your boat up to them, or enjoy your pizza/stromboli on their floats that are tied to the Pizza Pi boat. You will definitely not be disappointed!! Oh before I forget…they have non alcoholic beverages, a bar, and frozen drinks!!
All to be enjoyed while swimming and basking in the cool clear waters and soaking of the sun rays while making memories.
… moreAndrea Grossman
Stopped here for lunch while out on a boat for the day. This was such a highlight. The pizza is delicious and so were the drinks. They make the dough and sauce every morning on the boat. Incredible! The floating tables were so fun! You do not want to miss this!!
… more