Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizza Nerds is a popular take out/delivery (via DoorDash) only pizza restaurant in Gahanna, Ohio, known for its unique Nerds Style thick or thin, airy crust pizza and decadent cookies, offering a nostalgic, casual atmosphere with arcade games. We serve creative pizzas with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, alongside a variety of indulgent 1/4lb stuffed and unstuffed cookies from our Cookie Nerds brand, making it a destination for both savory and sweet cravings.
Hours
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 12–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1376 Cherry Bottom Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230
Phone: (614) 383-9222
Website: https://www.pizzanerdsoh.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Nerds
We are the cheese that holds the pizza community together. A gathering place for friends and family to enjoy the best food made with hand-made local ingredients …
Pizza Nerds | Gahanna OH – Facebook
Pizza Nerds, Gahanna. 10458 likes · 144 talking about this · 374 were here. Take out/Delivery Only! Pizza. Cookies. The coolest of vibes.
Pizza Nerds Gahanna Ohio – Order Online
Pizza Nerds Gahanna Ohio · Garlic Knots. 6 Made From Scratch Knots, Covered in Garlic Butter, Parmesan, A Sprinkle of Oregano and Served with a Side of Red Sauce.
Last Updates
Reviews
Alisha Riley
I placed an order for pick-up and when I arrived I was told they were giving me a second order of cheesy bread because they were not happy with how the first one baked. This is always nice of a business to do! When I arrived home I found that one order of cheesy bread seemed baked slightly longer than the other, but honestly both were delicious!
The Mario pizza was AMAZING. I am typically not a banana pepper person, but the hot honey really balanced and complimented the banana pepper in an unexpected way. I will definitely go back!
… moreThe Mario pizza was AMAZING. I am typically not a banana pepper person, but the hot honey really balanced and complimented the banana pepper in an unexpected way. I will definitely go back!
Jason
Tried Pizza Nerds for the first time today and wow — we’ll definitely be back.
We ordered two medium thick crust pizzas: one extra cheese, and one half mushroom/ground beef and half pepperoni. First bite absolutely did not disappoint. For a thick crust, the dough is somehow still airy and light. I had a couple slices and didn’t feel like I swallowed a brick. Big win.
The sauce has great flavor, and the cheese actually tastes like something (not just melted filler). The pepperoni is the smaller style — my favorite — crispy with those little curled edges, but not swimming in grease. The crust had that perfect crunch on the edge without shredding the roof of your mouth.
The mushroom and ground beef side was just as good. You can tell the ground beef is seasoned in-house — it tastes homemade, not generic.
We also grabbed three of the quarter cookies. The red velvet was fantastic, and the sugar chocolate chip disappeared fast. Slightly doughy in the center, but in a good way — not undercooked, just soft.
The atmosphere inside is really cool too — lots of pop culture stuff around and three arcade games, including the classic Paperboy. Fun touch.
Shoutout to Ben at the front counter — super friendly and welcoming.
Overall, fantastic experience. Glad we tried it. $43 for the pizzas and the cookies. Kids gave everything 10 out of 10 !
… moreWe ordered two medium thick crust pizzas: one extra cheese, and one half mushroom/ground beef and half pepperoni. First bite absolutely did not disappoint. For a thick crust, the dough is somehow still airy and light. I had a couple slices and didn’t feel like I swallowed a brick. Big win.
The sauce has great flavor, and the cheese actually tastes like something (not just melted filler). The pepperoni is the smaller style — my favorite — crispy with those little curled edges, but not swimming in grease. The crust had that perfect crunch on the edge without shredding the roof of your mouth.
The mushroom and ground beef side was just as good. You can tell the ground beef is seasoned in-house — it tastes homemade, not generic.
We also grabbed three of the quarter cookies. The red velvet was fantastic, and the sugar chocolate chip disappeared fast. Slightly doughy in the center, but in a good way — not undercooked, just soft.
The atmosphere inside is really cool too — lots of pop culture stuff around and three arcade games, including the classic Paperboy. Fun touch.
Shoutout to Ben at the front counter — super friendly and welcoming.
Overall, fantastic experience. Glad we tried it. $43 for the pizzas and the cookies. Kids gave everything 10 out of 10 !
E. Rahaman
First off the service was great! The owner and his wife were very friendly and down to earth. Explained the menu for us, and we ordered The Mario and The Captain Planet. The pizza had great flavor and was fresh with fresh ingredients! And then the atmosphere was something straight out of my childhood! Definitely going back.
… moreAmanda Lawrence
Pizza nerds is the ultimate nostalgia pizza joint. From floor to ceiling they are in throwback mode and I LOVE IT.
The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful and every person I have interacted with is amazing.
My favorite is their “Tommy want wingy” which I have tried to convince them repeatedly it should be a full time menu item but they trap me into buying it every time they bring it into rotation.
Try this place!
… moreThe staff is incredibly friendly and helpful and every person I have interacted with is amazing.
My favorite is their “Tommy want wingy” which I have tried to convince them repeatedly it should be a full time menu item but they trap me into buying it every time they bring it into rotation.
Try this place!
tyann amos
I wasn’t a huge fan. The decorations are cute. The pizza lacked flavor and the garlic knots tasted frozen. Visually everything looked stunning including the cookies. I just didn’t find much flavor in the items I had.
… moreDavid
Holy cow! This pizza is absolutely fantastic! I truly don’t have enough words in my vocabulary to describe how good this pizza is. The Tommy Want Wingy aka “buffalo chicken” was perfect with the thicker crust. It was the best ratio with the sauce and toppings and the thick crust to support it all and the crunchy cheese on the outside of the crust was heavenly. We also got The Mario and that was fantastic with the thinner, but still thick, crust. I’m in love with this pizza, and I can’t wait to try even more of the menu!
… moreLawrence Marks
I ordered a large pizza. Nowhere on the website does it say how big it is. The box was 14 inches but the pizza was 12“ x 12“. I was out the door for almost $30 and it was only three toppings. Pizza was decent, but is a total rip off. Outrageously expensive. I’ll never be back.
… moreJulie H
BEST PIZZA PLACE EVER!!!
This pizza place saved my valentines day when everywhere else was booked up or at least a three hour wait. It was not only one of the best pizza places I’ve been to ever they have really yummy cookies too!! the people were so nice, helpful and funny. The wait wasn’t that long even though they were constantly busy. There was also so much cool stuff to look at!!
… moreThis pizza place saved my valentines day when everywhere else was booked up or at least a three hour wait. It was not only one of the best pizza places I’ve been to ever they have really yummy cookies too!! the people were so nice, helpful and funny. The wait wasn’t that long even though they were constantly busy. There was also so much cool stuff to look at!!
Columbus Food Dude
Best specialty pizza in all of Columbus. I absolutely love their Detroit style crust! So for this this week only I ordered. “The Texas Tony” (I like mine well done) Swiss American, Mozzarella, Beef, Bacon, Crispy Onions, and their house-made Nerds Tangy Burger Sauce, straight up ridiculous!
Brent was kind enough to let me try their new Garlic Knots that are Comings soon!
Stuffed Triple Choco Cookie (A must have!)
… moreBrent was kind enough to let me try their new Garlic Knots that are Comings soon!
Stuffed Triple Choco Cookie (A must have!)
Rochelle Davis
Delicious pizza. Crispy airy crust and favorable perfect sauce. Build your own order was correct!.. Friendly staff . Will order from them again!!!
… more