Cody Brooks
I would give overall 3.5.
The garlic knots were definitely tasty, but a little too toasted – not burnt by any means, but maybe a minute over-baked. The marinara on the side was really top notch.
The pizza, Good Carma with chicken instead of sausage, was also pretty good. I think it would’ve been even better with red sauce instead of white; if I were to order it again, that’s what I would do. The bottom of the pizza was nicely toasted and crispy, and I usually don’t much like thin crust, so it was a good win.
The vibes are awesome – nine or ten pinball machines, Mothra on one TV and Bob Ross on the other, AC/DC on the radio. Service was outstanding, shout out to Abby. Nailed the balance between checking on the table and giving us space to enjoy the food.
… moreMeri Haitkin
I love this pizza. I love the crust, the sauce and the thoughtful combos. They have great art. A collection of pinball machines. And incredible beer selection and the friendliest most helpful staff to help you choose from too many good options. I can only suggest over-ordering because there’s too many phenomenal pies. Personally – I always go with the Tony Clifton. But there’s usually specials and also … vegan… if that’s your thing….
… moreTravis Cooper
Great atmosphere and good pizza! I loved the wall art and pinball machines.
The folks at our table were thirsty, and the service on refills took some time, as well as the pizza.
All in all, this was a great neighborhood pizza joint and I would most definitely come back.
… moreJoshua
Hands down best pizza in the state. Not even close. And I heard they won 2nd place in a wings contest so I really want to try those. Great place, great food!
… moreJenna Maney
Pizza J is our go-to Friday night pizza spot. The smoked wings are INCREDIBLE and extremely tender. The pizza is phenomenal and hits the spot every time. Vibes are great to hangout and grab a drink by the bar while they keep your to-go food warm. Highly recommend!
… moreSam Knous
Wish I lived closer to prov just for the fact how good your pizza is. Anytime I see you guys on my delivery route I know its gunna end good with some bomb pizza. Thank you guys for looking out when I come in!! Keep up the great work. Craft collect delivery driver Sam appreciates y’all tremendously!!!
… moreMiss Bee
Amazing… Impossibly thin crust, plenty of fresh, slightly sweet sauce. Not too much cheese so it’s not a heavy pizza where the cheese coagulates on you. Went with a cheese pizza, absolutely no notes, no room for improvement. Caesar salad perfectly dressed, nice garlicky croutons.
… moreSamantha Wallace
Service was great. Very polite and thoughtful. The atmosphere is very fun and eclectic.
And their garlic knots might be one of the best things I’ve ever tried. Absolutely drool-worthy.
… moreIan Ferrara
Pizza is solid as always. Huge issues with the wings. They were terrible. So over fried and dry. I am in disbelief the cook thought it was OK to send these out.
… moreAlexandria Bolduc
Our friends have been recommending this place forever. We finally came in for the first time here on a Saturday night. It didn’t disappoint. We tried chx sandwich, pizza, wings, and tiramisu. Garlic fries are fire-just order them!
… more