Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 105 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350
Phone: (717) 624-7965
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Pizza-Garden-Italian-Family-Restaurant-1706068279675936/?rf=102234986486431
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant – New Oxford, PA
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant in New Oxford, PA is a haven for pizza lovers. Offering Neapolitan, White, and Pan Pizza options, this restaurant also provides …
Pizza Garden Italian Family Restaurant | New Oxford PA – Facebook
Pizza Garden Italian Family Restaurant, New Oxford. 1726 likes · 2 talking about this · 248 were here. Only the BEST pizza, subs and Italian dinners in…
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant – Pizza restaurant in Pennsylvania …
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant stands as a cherished gem in New Oxford, known for its exceptional menu and warm atmosphere. This family-owned establishment …
Reviews
Robert Ebersole
Finally, a really good pizza! I heard this place is “meh” from one person. And “the best” from another. I like trying new pizza spots, and I gave this a shot.
From the outside, you wouldn’t think it was great. On a bumpy route 30, I wouldn’t want to try and find a place to park if I was just passing through. But this is a hidden gem. A diamond across from a jewelry store.
This pizza was near perfect. White mozzarella. It’s not that yellow greasy color I’ve been having at other places. The crust was even great. Like a gourmet bread. And only $2 per topping!
Inside was neat and clean. Waitress was awesome and attentive.
… moreFrom the outside, you wouldn’t think it was great. On a bumpy route 30, I wouldn’t want to try and find a place to park if I was just passing through. But this is a hidden gem. A diamond across from a jewelry store.
This pizza was near perfect. White mozzarella. It’s not that yellow greasy color I’ve been having at other places. The crust was even great. Like a gourmet bread. And only $2 per topping!
Inside was neat and clean. Waitress was awesome and attentive.
Heydi Garay
Great service, clean place, the food is super delicious!!! I recommend to go to this place!!
… moreKenneth
We enjoyed a lovely lunch here after a busy day of shopping at the local antique shops. My wife and I enjoyed our Cheese Steaks, mine was a Cheese Steak Hoagie that was just great . Our waitress was wonderful as were the cooks here. They make their own bread!
… moreTy
A definite great place to grab a bite. Delicious food. Clean, comfort environment. Super staff. Welcomed my Service Dog (not companion…real Service Dog). Will be coming here often.
… moreKathy Diehl
Nice place, I got take out so I can’t say much about the atmosphere, the food was good though.
… morelindsay hill
This is not your normal pizzeria. As you walk in, you can feel the friendly atmosphere, everybody is welcoming, there are smiles on everyone’s faces. It’s right off the main road so it’s easily accessible. It’s also handicap friendly. There was Italian news on the TV and the gentlemen who helped me order and who made my food was really friendly. He made me a handful of grilled chicken for my dog and I got the super Italian sub-cold. All the way minus onions.
To the owner, I’m sorry I didn’t catch your name but grazie! So che la mia visita è stata breve, ma mi è piaciuta la buona compagnia.
… moreTo the owner, I’m sorry I didn’t catch your name but grazie! So che la mia visita è stata breve, ma mi è piaciuta la buona compagnia.
Elvis Presley
the food here is always good when i come here and the service is always great and friendly they let me play my music whenever i do show up i’ve been going here since i was born the only bad thing i can say is that they’re closed monday and tuesday but that’s about it
… moreLaurel R
Pizza Garden is a culinary paradox. The pizza whispers sweet nothings to your soul, while the bacon cheeseburger sub is a monument to delicious excess. Forget your diet, abandon your inhibitions, and dive into the beautiful chaos. Just try not to make eye contact with the cook.
… moreJ Fiery
A great little pizza place that took my wife and I stumbled across on a visit to Gettysburg. Being there was like a time portal back to our youth. The staff is excellent and the pizza sauce is superb. Add the ambiance of the building and you have a gem. Thankfully we live in Maryland so we will be making this spot a date place for us going forward.
… more