Brenna Mangan
This is by far the best pizza in the area. It’s not only the closest you can come to pizza in Chicago but even competes with my favorite places in Chicago. It’s a sweet sauce which I know some people can either love or dislike so keep that in mind. The sausage is my favorite and I believe they make their own. I don’t love deep dish pizza but theirs is the only one I have ever enjoyed eating. They are always kind and go above and beyond with sharing the deals they have when I call. I really can’t rave about this place enough. It’s a hidden gem and deserves way more praise than it gets.
… moreJosh Wilfong
This has to be the best pizza we’ve had in Crown Point, and it’s not even close! Tony’s enthusiasm for his food was already enough to win me over, but once I took a bite, I was hooked. We had a sausage pizza, and let me say this, you can really tell the difference with it being homemade. I particularly love the way they do their thin crust, perfectly Crispy. It even impressed my Italian wife, and that’s no easy feat . Please keep up the good work, Pizza Cellar! Be prepared for me to become a repeat customer
… moreBill Shapiro
Excellent! Moved out here from the Oak Lawn area and have not found anything I’ve liked. Grew up eating Palermo’s, Phil’s, Nino’s and Papa Joe’s. Finally after being here for 3 years now I’m home. I have my pizza place! Friendly service went out of their way to make our order just right. We picked it up and got a call that they forgot an item in our order. They sent the delivery driver straight to our house and even added some garlic bread. Perfect place that values their customers. We most definitely will be back.
… moreRhonda
Today was my first time trying Pizza Cellar. I read the reviews 4.5 and said why not try it. They did not disappoint. I am a foodie by way of Chicago. The homemade sausage, the sauce was so favorable, the right amount of cheese and additional vegetables perfection. This is my new Pizza place. I highly recommend Pizza Cellar.
… moreJoe Myeress
Best deep dish pizza ever. The sauce, sausage, and crust were excellent. Worth every $.
… moreZgriffin
Ordered for the first time, as a friend swears by it. Overpriced garbage, DO NOT buy the “wings” from this place they literally just heat up chicken nuggets and sets them in sauce they don’t even toss them. The pizza tasted exactly like beggars pizza if you have ever had that, crust was chewy, and the gravy was bland. Highway robbery this place this
… moreJohnny Lackhouse
this was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in the past 20 years the owner really knows how to make a good pizza they butcher and make their own sausage and it’s just a really cool place to go
… moreRick Moro
One of the best pizza joints around!
The owner Tony was friendly and personable. Great location and easy to get to. The pizza was magnificent! The sauce was heavenly and the home made sausage was out of this world.
This is our new pizza spot from now on. 12/10!
… moreAdriano Giovane
This is the hidden gem of crown point. Stumbled across this place of google looking for a new pizza place and I’m glad I found them. Not normally a deep dish fan but these guys do it right. The regular thin crust was amazing too. They had great flavor and they use good ingredients. I’m a pizza fiend and this place puts a lot of other staples to shame. You can tell they really care about what they do. I will be back soon!
… moreAnthony Sineni
Best pizza in NWI, the deep dish and thin are AMAZING ! This is old school homemade Italian pizza and food ! Pasta , and sandwiches are delicious ! MUST TRY!
… more