Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizza Amore is an authentic Italian restaurant specializing in wood-fired brick oven pizza. We proudly offer a diverse menu featuring delicious baked wings, savory subs, fresh salads, and tempting desserts, all crafted with the finest ingredients. In addition to our extensive a la carte menu, we also provide convenient catering services, including options for food trucks to bring our delicious offerings to your next event.
Relaxed, family-run place offering brick-oven pizzas with specialty toppings, plus subs & hot wings.
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2024 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, NY 14072
Phone: (716) 775-5975
Website: http://www.pizzaamorewoodfire.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
pizzaamorewoodfiremenu.square.site
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tannon Montea
My wife and I have been wondering about this place for awhile. Hearing better reviews than not; tonight we tried their Detroit Pizza and their award winning Galbani Amore’.
Overall the pizza taste itself was good. Friendly service, neat and tidy establishment.
However, The Galbani Amore’ was burnt to a char half way around the pizza. Picking the burnt parts off, seeing if it was edible underneath didn’t result in success.
So, I gave the number of stars that I did because, being a business owner myself, I don’t and would never serve a finished product to my clients that I myself wouldn’t want.
I also think that I too should have taken a look at the pizza prior to assuming we’d be getting a product we’d actually want.
Also, navigating through their website to order isn’t all that flexible. Options are restricted to a firm guideline of what they will create and make.
This is another reason why “tipping” these days has lost the value of why a service is granted gratuity in the first place. It shouldn’t be an option prior to the service being completed.
So, because of these things I have rated Pizza Amore’ a below average rating because I think most everything from this experience could have been better.
Mildly disappointed and probably won’t go back.
… moreOverall the pizza taste itself was good. Friendly service, neat and tidy establishment.
However, The Galbani Amore’ was burnt to a char half way around the pizza. Picking the burnt parts off, seeing if it was edible underneath didn’t result in success.
So, I gave the number of stars that I did because, being a business owner myself, I don’t and would never serve a finished product to my clients that I myself wouldn’t want.
I also think that I too should have taken a look at the pizza prior to assuming we’d be getting a product we’d actually want.
Also, navigating through their website to order isn’t all that flexible. Options are restricted to a firm guideline of what they will create and make.
This is another reason why “tipping” these days has lost the value of why a service is granted gratuity in the first place. It shouldn’t be an option prior to the service being completed.
So, because of these things I have rated Pizza Amore’ a below average rating because I think most everything from this experience could have been better.
Mildly disappointed and probably won’t go back.
Joycee Williams
Twice a year my company hires food trucks for an lol employee event and we decided to have Pizza Amore back.
They showed up early to get the preorders for our customer service staff taken care of first and they did an excellent job with entertaining us and great conversation to our staff. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. We were impressed that they had the pizza coming out of the oven so fast and down to perfection.
I recommend everyone try them out. My favorite was the calzone pizza!
… moreThey showed up early to get the preorders for our customer service staff taken care of first and they did an excellent job with entertaining us and great conversation to our staff. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. We were impressed that they had the pizza coming out of the oven so fast and down to perfection.
I recommend everyone try them out. My favorite was the calzone pizza!
Jessica Male
We had an issue with the Uber Eats driver (they left our food at the wrong house snd on the ground in the rain!). I called to advise of the issue in case the driver caused problems with other orders and said I would be fine just reheating the pizza we found down the street at a neighbors home. But Pizza Amore made it right! They immediately remade our entire order and delivered it to our door!
We ALWAYS love the pizza. Its the best on the island for sure. Different flavors like Dill Pickle with ranch are amazing. But today was proof it’s the service and pride that keep us coming back!
… moreWe ALWAYS love the pizza. Its the best on the island for sure. Different flavors like Dill Pickle with ranch are amazing. But today was proof it’s the service and pride that keep us coming back!
Laura L. Wootton
Updated review June 2025: We went to the physical location today. It’s a take-out place in a gas station, not a restaurant. We didn’t realize that and were caught off-guard, but the pizza was still delicious! I’ll be on the lookout for their pizza trucks at events but likely won’t return to the physical location again.
Original review August 2024: My mom and I tried their pizza at the Lewiston Jazz Festival today. It was delicious! Love the crust and wood-fired char flavor. We tried the White Broccoli pie and the Regular White pie. Both were delicious. They had a great system in order at their tent and were getting the pizzas out quickly to everyone.
… moreOriginal review August 2024: My mom and I tried their pizza at the Lewiston Jazz Festival today. It was delicious! Love the crust and wood-fired char flavor. We tried the White Broccoli pie and the Regular White pie. Both were delicious. They had a great system in order at their tent and were getting the pizzas out quickly to everyone.
Dine In Buffalo
Good quality pizza, I would recommend to a friend. Ask to get the pie well done. Garlic knots are amazing.
… moreChris Petros
We were pleasantly surprised with an incredible menu, friendly staff and very clean restaurant. This is done it the absolute best pizza I’ve ever had and we definitely plan on coming back. The Italian stallion, barbeque chicken, and 716 were perfectly cooked and left us wishing we had more. I cant wait to eat here again.
Edit: 2 years later and we finally made it back here on a family trip. Same great quality of food. We weren’t disappointed in the least! This pizza is amazing, you won’t regret it. Try the s’more log. It is as delicious as it is messy, the kids loved it!
… moreEdit: 2 years later and we finally made it back here on a family trip. Same great quality of food. We weren’t disappointed in the least! This pizza is amazing, you won’t regret it. Try the s’more log. It is as delicious as it is messy, the kids loved it!
James Riley
Good food. Takeout order should be reviewed before you leave as it has most often been wrong or incomplete. It’s located in a petrol station so atmosphere is non-existent. The photo is from a recent order where the normal menu salad had half a pound, or more, of feta on it. I thought maybe I was being pranked when I saw all the cheese on a normal Greek salad.
… moreVincent Michael
Be sure to give them a buffer as the food is never ready when they say it will be. The food itself was good though!
… morePaul B
The owners and staff are always professional and friendly. My favorite pizza in WNY hands down. Perfectly crispy along the edges. You will not be disappointed. Every pie I’ve gotten has looked and tasted fantastic.
… moreMaldivian American Whitmore
The pizza was delicious! Cinnamon knots were ok, I would have loved it if it was baked a little bit more.
… more