A A
They don’t seem concerned about customer service. They opened late the day we got there we were waiting in the parking lot when they arrived. They didn’t say anything about being late or mention anything about us having to wait for them to open. You seat yourself but they bring the food to your table and you pay up front at the time that you place your order at the counter. It’s very confusing since you tip when you order before you even sit down. The cashier is also the server. She may have been having a bad day? Maybe not maybe she is always the complete opposite of a bundle of joy and a ray of sunshine ♀️. Maybe she was irritated our mere presence or maybe she was irritated that the pizza maker was late and he was her ride? No idea….but they did arrive together. The pizza had a good flavor it’s thicker than my ideal pizza but this pizza would be good for those who like pizza thicker than a real New York style pizza. The fries were burnt….. no way around it they were burnt, a huge basket of them and we ate them anyway. I’d give the pizza a 3/10 on my perfect pizza scale. Good flavor but way to thick for me. I would go back just for another basket of fries that aren’t burnt because that type of crispy battered looking fries are my favorite.
… moreRaye West
Before and after pics…
Do NOT veer away from the pizza!! It’s only “kinda ok” but the rest of their menu is tasteless and low quality. I’ve tried them a few times now, all different items including pizzas, sandwiches, pastas, chicken wings, salads and bread items. I try to give all resteraunts a fair experience, dine in and to-go and delivery into account. My honest opinion… if you want a “just ok” pizza, fine. However, the rest is sad.
See my posted pictures… it’s like that every time. No waste though!! I had to use their bad pasta main dish as a base for… well, something edible. I made baked goulash pasta from it with whatever I had on hand. Not EVER giving them another chance. After 6 tries I’m done and disappointed.
Sorry but goodbye Pizza Amore!!!
… moreDawn Knoepfler (The Dawn)
Mmmmm 16″ Pepperoni, Extra Cheese done perfectly! FRESH dough and sauce, pretty damn close to NY style. Francesca was very sweet and can definitely throw some dough!! Check out this lovely local family owned hideaway when you can. The Calzones are HUGE and the prices are extremely reasonable!! $24 for 16″ 2 topping and 2 fountain drinks. They also make some great looking cheesecakes, tiramisu, cannoli’s, and other desserts.
No they do NOT deliver to the beach. Yes there is inside dining. No they are NOT pet friendly (except REAL service animals) No patio or outdoor seating.
… moreCraig Karch
My wife and I have ordered from Pizza Amore from the day they opened. Usually great pizza. The closest thing to Italy we’ve been able to find since moving back. However, tonight’s pizza was simply God awful. Had a strong garlic taste. I’ve never eaten pizza that tasted like I was chewing on a garlic clove. The cheese was orange? Have no idea what happened with the pizza but it was inedible. Going into the trash. Also ordered a calamari appetizer. Usually great as well. Well not tonight. Strike two. It was just cold. Called with some friendly feedback. Excuses. No responsibility. I left a $9 tip on a $31 purchase and this is what a good customer gets. I’m truly disappointed.
… moreLori Sagehorn
I will not eat pizza anywhere else. The supreme pizza was amazing!! The large was perfect for 4 of us. I loved that the food is freshly made. The tiramasu and cannoli were out of this world.
… moreAustin Lee
Inflation must have hit them hard this is half of the stromboli I just got. Was the smallest most greasist stromboli I have ever had I feel insulted bc it cost me 28$ i though ehh well it better be good! NOPE! First time trying them out never going there again dont waist your money!
… moreJonathan Buchanan
Drove by this place as long as I can remember but I finally stopped in on a Sunday afternoon, it was very quiet and pretty dead inside but the young woman behind the counter was very friendly and personable and made ordering and asking about the items a nice experience.
The pizza we ordered came out very quickly and was extremely good! while it was not the most flavorful pizza I’ve ever had, I have yet to have a pizza that was as well balanced in ingredients as this one. It was a bit thin but thats how I like it, the ingredients tasted very fresh and the put the perfect amount of sauce on it for me(some may think its too little).
My girlfriend and I couldn’t stop talking about how non-greasy the pizza was and how it tasted great without being too “heavy” with toppings and crazy stuff. I’m very picky about pizza crust but they have definitely found the “just right” middle ground between too crispy and too doughy. We will certainly be back and I am exited to try the other things on the menu!
My only complaint would be that I had hoped the garlic knots would have had more garlic on them, honestly I dont think there was any on them at all, though the dough seemed very fresh and well made. Besides that The only suggestion I have would be to liven the place up a bit, the display fridge was completely empty and the place seemed stagnant at first. Play some music, have some fans running, etc.
… moreLyn Beavers
I didn’t know that this evening would be your last until I arrived to pick up my order. I even asked when you might have your new space. I commented how much I loved their pizza. Unfortunately the pizzas I got tonight were completely inedible. If we had had what we got tonight, we would never have gone back.
And now you’re not answering the phone. (Tried to call twice between 7 and 7:30.
I usually love to support local businesses and I can’t believe that on your last night for who knows how long, that you would give a customer such awful food.
Both pizzas are two of the worst I’ve ever had. We asked for light sauce on the double cheese, it came with NO sauce. Both pizzas ate like rubbery cardboard. I even tried just scraping off the toppings on the pepperoni and mushroom but even that was pointless.
If you weren’t going to maintain your standards, then why were you even open for business tonight (Sunday May 22 2022) ?
Quite honestly my purchase should be refunded in full.
… moreAlec Young
Good food, great dessert. We had a cheese calzone that we added pepperoni to for the kids, and a large supreme pizza for us adults. Cost $30 or so with drinks and everything. The crust was really good, The toppings were really good, they only complained about the food I had was it was a lot of moisture from the vegetables. Kids said the calzone was good but too cheesy, was just shows that they don’t know what they’re talking about because there’s no such thing. We had a slice of the Oreo cheesecake for dessert. it did cost $6 but personally I think it was worth it. It tasted phenomenal nice and rich.
… moreLara Braddock
Just finished dinner, we did carry out so it was a bit cold when I got home. We all enjoyed the meat lovers the most. The desserts looked amazing, will try those next time. Good service, decent price. Will definitely go back.
… more