Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3915 NY-23, West Oneonta, NY 13861
Phone: (607) 432-4222
Website: http://www.pizza23west.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza 23 West | West Oneonta NY – Facebook
Just a friendly reminder we will be open today at 4pm for take out and delivery only for opening day Stay hungry and Stay well. Thank you · Chalya Pudlewski …
Pizza 23 West | West Oneonta, NY 13820 – ILoveNY.com
They decided to bring a little bit of Italy to West Oneonta, with their great Italian pasta dishes, pizza, salads, subs, and desserts. Specialties include …
Pizza 23 West – MapQuest
3915 State Highway 23, West Oneonta, NY, 13861. Pizza, Wings, Salads and Desserts. Dine in, take out, delivery and catering available. Catering offered on …
Product
Reviews
R I
If you’re coming to Oneonta and playing in the Cooperstown tournaments this is one of the few places that you could rent out for the whole team and their family members.
The owners knew exactly what they were doing and have it down to a science. All the food orders were taken ahead of time, placed on their own separate table, and everybody was able to serve themselves. True family style as it should be. At the end of the meals each family is then given their own separate check which certainly helps avoid any conflicts come bill time.
Highly recommend.
… moreThe owners knew exactly what they were doing and have it down to a science. All the food orders were taken ahead of time, placed on their own separate table, and everybody was able to serve themselves. True family style as it should be. At the end of the meals each family is then given their own separate check which certainly helps avoid any conflicts come bill time.
Highly recommend.
Travis Martin
Been here twice and both times dinner was delicious. Garlic knots are the best I’ve ever had. Pizza is perfectly cooked, and even better the second time! Salads are super fresh. Next time we are going to try subs…
… moreJennifer Rocen
Amazing staff, great place for a team party while visiting Cooperstown. Penny was so organized that we ended up doing the pizza party package delivery the night of opening ceremonies too! Would definitely recommend this place!
… moreScott Convis
Very disappointed, first time going their and will be last time. The pizza was so greasy and the dressing for the salad had to much vinegar in it. Good thing I had a towel on the seat in my car or it would have been stained. They have to update their website as we looked on there to see what they had and when we came to the place, the prices were 8 dollars more than what they had put down. Maybe lower your prices down as us local people aren’t rich dreams park city people. It’s says #5 pizzeria in Upstate New York on their website but that was from 2018 and boy have times have changed since they got that reward as you can see. ♂️
… moreYessica Raya
We came here with our baseball team. Pizza was good, great atmosphere and service was friendly.
… moreluis andres
Absolutely best pizza and phenomenal service, hidden jewel that everyone should know about it. Huge portions at a reasonable price. Recommend to all
… moreBruce D.
Nice Italian food in Oneonta. I had a sausage, pepper and onion roll with marinara sauce. Loved the marinara and the combination roll. Seating is closed temporarily for COVID-19 but takeout/pickup is available.
… moreAlbert Quick
The pizza I ordered the other day was nothing short of being perfect. The guy (owner) was busting his butt to make sure my order was hot and ready, a large White Pie with great tasting oil and thick cuts of mozzarella cheese!! This truly is the best place in Oneonta to grab a slice!! A full bar and nice views from inside makes me want to come back and dine in sometime. Happy I found this gem
… moreCortnie Goodrich
I am late writing this review, but a couple of months ago my family ordered the grandma pie from here and we all got extremely sick from it, my 6 year old niece and my 80 year old grandma included…even our dog ended up throwing up and having diarrhea. I have never gotten so sick from food before, it was a total nightmare. To make things worse when I called and spoke to the manager/owner, he did not believe me-told me he would call me back in 30 minutes and I never heard from him again. I have ordered from here many times before and always enjoyed it, but after this I will never order from here again.
… moreBill Vining
I’ve been to the new Pizza 23 three times for takeout and each time the food has been great. I’ve gotten pizza, wings and meat lasagna. All really good and good size portions. The folks running the place are very welcoming and friendly.
… more