Social Profile: 
✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Nestled in the heart of Avilla, Pixie Pies is a whimsical bakery renowned for its incredible variety of cheesecakes. With 104 unique flavors in a weekly rotation, there is always a new and delightful treat to discover. While their storefront offers a rotating selection, full-size cheesecakes can be ordered a week in advance for special events. Pixie Pies also caters to various occasions, including corporate events and weddings, and proudly supplies a host of local restaurants and grocery stores with their delectable creations.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–7 PM |
| Friday | 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 201 E Albion St, Avilla, IN 46710
Phone: (260) 242-8645
Website: https://www.facebook.com/PIXIEPIES512
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Pixie Pies (@PIXIEPIES512) – Facebook
Pixie Pies. 6337 likes · 634 talking about this. Open Thursday 4-7PM Friday 4-8PM Saturday 4-8PM 201 E. Albion St. Avilla, IN.
Avilla cheesecake bakery opens storefront with variety of flavors
Pixie Pies officially opened a storefront location Friday after co-owner Ashley Sturdivant spent more than a year making and selling cheesecakes to local …
If you like cheesecake, you need to know about Pixie Pies in Avilla …
If you like cheesecake, you need to know about Pixie Pies in Avilla, IN. They have 104 specialty flavors and they switch up what’s available …
Reviews
K Pulz
We used Pixie Pies as a caterer for the desserts for our wedding in July. We ordered in advance and got several whole new york cheesecakes cut into slices with a few toppings (chocolate syrup, crushed oreos, etc). The toppings were provided in tupperware and the cheesecakes were in cake boxes.
We provided pie servers, plates, and silverware for our guests to diy their own cheesecake slices and it was a hit!
… moreWe provided pie servers, plates, and silverware for our guests to diy their own cheesecake slices and it was a hit!
Cristina Wolf
Absolutely amazing cheesecakes! Not only do they have a small storefront location, they supply cheesecakes to many local restaurants to reach a broader customer base! Talk about a genius business plan! My family has tried so many different flavors and have never been disappointed! We always look forward to our own personal faves, but enjoy the new flavors that get offered all the time. Pixie Pies never disappoints!!!
… moreTaylor Mackenzie
Before picking up my variety of cheesecakes, I was already impressed with the owner’s communication. She responded to my messages quickly, was incredibly kind, and made the entire ordering process feel so smooth and personal. It’s rare to find someone who takes so much pride in both their product and their customer service.
When I arrived, I was immediately struck by how bright, clean, and welcoming the place was. It had such a warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at ease. The owner greeted me right away with a genuine smile and asked how I was doing and how my day was going—it wasn’t just small talk, she truly seemed to care. That level of kindness and attention really stood out and made the experience feel special.
Now onto the cheesecake—absolutely phenomenal. I got a variety of flavors, and each one was rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced in sweetness. You can really tell that everything is made with love and high-quality ingredients. It’s honestly the best cheesecake I’ve ever had—better than any restaurant or bakery I’ve been to. My personal favorite was carrot cake, but every single slice was a hit.
From start to finish, this was an amazing experience. Between the outstanding customer service, the welcoming environment, and the incredible cheesecake, I can confidently say I’ll definitely be coming back—and recommending it to everyone I know!
… moreWhen I arrived, I was immediately struck by how bright, clean, and welcoming the place was. It had such a warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at ease. The owner greeted me right away with a genuine smile and asked how I was doing and how my day was going—it wasn’t just small talk, she truly seemed to care. That level of kindness and attention really stood out and made the experience feel special.
Now onto the cheesecake—absolutely phenomenal. I got a variety of flavors, and each one was rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced in sweetness. You can really tell that everything is made with love and high-quality ingredients. It’s honestly the best cheesecake I’ve ever had—better than any restaurant or bakery I’ve been to. My personal favorite was carrot cake, but every single slice was a hit.
From start to finish, this was an amazing experience. Between the outstanding customer service, the welcoming environment, and the incredible cheesecake, I can confidently say I’ll definitely be coming back—and recommending it to everyone I know!
Laura Kopytek
I just visited for the first time and I can’t wait to go back and try the cheesecake. I got a strawberry ice cream with sprinkles and it was probably the best strawberry ice cream I’ve had in years. Plus, the amount of topping was just perfect. I’ve had quite I few places skimp on the sprinkles but there was enough for every bite. They were also great at explaining the menu and what was available. Love this place!
… moreJonathan Cromie
Shop wasn’t open to service customers yet as from being from out of town I walk inside and I was treated so kind and with compassion. I bought 3 pieces of cheesecake and wow off the charts. Will be stopping before I leave town that’s a guarantee. AMAZING THAT’S ALL I CAN SAY….. ♥️♥️♥️♥️
… moreKourtney Edwards
Always leave with almost the whole menu because we cannot decide! Not complaining! Best cheesecake around! I always look forward to seeing the new menus each week!
… moreHeather Petrie
I know the owner of pixie pies and she is the sweetest person. I’m not a big fan of cheesecake but I gave her’s a shot and I really enjoyed them! I can’t wait to try the ice cream! The staff are so friendly and very polite! I’m glad we have this small business in our home town!
… moreErica Jarman
This is THE BEST CHEESECAKE I’ve ever had!! There are so many flavors to choose from!! The owner is one of the best people I’ve ever met and everyone that works there have such great personalities . I will always be a fan of Pixie Pies ❤️❤️❤️
… moreMonica Smith
Tried my first slice a few years back! The Christmas tree is now and always will be my favorite! If you haven’t stopped and tried a slice or one of the other fabulous and fun dessert it’s a MUST! Best part is everyone has always been friendly when we go! Oh and where else can you go and the owner greets you with a hug?? Best wishes always!
… moreBrittany Shough
The employees are all extremely polite and energetic and you can tell they enjoy what they’re doing. The inside looks clean and yet still cute inside. Ive have got several different flavors on numerous occasions now and they are always delicious and dont last long in our house. Ive met the owner several times and never felt like she was rude. You can tell she loved her shop and was passionate about providing not just amazing treats but amazing customer service. When they do special events they do so well at making it fun and inviting.
… more