Adam Nobody
Wonderful place. Pizza is one of a kind and cooked to perfection! It is my five year old daughter’s favorite. The staff, from the kitchen to the servers, are the absolute best. Christianna is our favorite. Definitely our go to spot. ❤️
… moreKim Teetzel
This has been a perennial favorite of our family’s for many decades. However, this evenings experience was very poor. Service was pretty good. But the food was the problem. While the apps were good, all 3 of our pizza were burnt on the edges about 1″ all around. And then our wings did not arrive & when we asked about them our sever said “oh they didn’t make them. Do you want them?” That should have been an omen as a tooth was severly chipped on the meat one of the wings.
Very very disappointing. It will be a long time before we return.
… moreKiya White
Always love going here. Food is great, our waitress (yes we have the same one every time) is always so sweet and attentive. Subs are good, pizza is great, the cheesy garlic bread is amazing. Definitely a regular on our restaurant rotation.
… moreErin Hunt
I have always loved their pizza. The pizza sauce is a secret family recipe. It is a sweet sauce and the crust is a thin crust. I crave it from time to time and have to go and get my fix. Since the new ownership has taken place, the decor has changed and it feels more inviting. Definitely recommend.. I only ever really get the pizza there, so don’t have any other recommendations other than the salad. Get the house salad with cheese and the house dressing. It is amazing!
… moreMary Nelson
First time ordering. Pizza was really good! The Italian sub not so much. Meat to sub bun ratio is about 75% bread to 25% meat and vegetables. I get everyone is doing this because a $5 pound of lunch meat is now $15. So I guess the options are to spend $20 for a sub or put the meat and veggies on a hotdog bun!
… moreTrailtracker
For all locals and especially those who grew up in Lancaster, this is a cornerstone pizza place in our town. It’s a great no-frills place to hang out with family and friends. You do not need to dress up to hang out at the bar or order food. T-shirt and jeans!
They have added a handicapped ramp which is great to see but would still be difficult to manage alone with the dble doored vestibule but with an able bodied person, it would not be a problem.
I love the sauce and the thin crust pizza!! They add plenty of sauce and the pretzel bites are excellent and look like buckeyes!! Fries are like those found at the fair! Yum!
Prices have clearly gone up, like everywhere else but I was floored it cost $80 for 3 adults and 2 elementary aged girls. There is now a 3% surcharge for credit cards?! Just FYI
The food was super hot and good as always, so that’s a win! Parking is always a problem. Many use the bank parking lot across the street but I’m not sure if you are at risk of being towed or not. I had to park 1 block away and walk crossing two streets. Just fyi
My ratings are based on the casual nature of this bar/restaurant and NOT to compare it to high end, upgraded chains. So for a relaxed no frills neighborhood “joint” I give it two thumbs up and am grateful they made it thru covid and beyond!!
… moreRachel Wolverton
Great experience for small town eats. Server/bartender was friendly and kind. Appreciate the service!
… moreDawn Bininger (Dawnie72)
Haven’t been here in years but saw a post on FB so I headed in. Got their pizza, wings, salad & husband got the meatball sub. He was not a fan of the sub. But everything else was good. Service was great. Food was super hot. Just needed some seasoning. Pizza is Ohio style with super thin crust. Wings are breaded. Just things to note.
… moreMike Garbrandt
Came in late on a Friday night with a group of 14 and they did such a great job getting everyone’s orders and the food was fantastic! Thanks again for taking care of our group!
… moreRobin Rodgers
Best pizza in the world!! Always have to stop in for one when we make it back to Lancaster. Unfortunately we live in Dayton now so we plan trips just for Cricket pizza.
… more