Pines Pizza

by

  3.9 – 36 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Pines Pizza 11782

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Pines Pizza, 39 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville, NY 11782, US – MapQuest

Pines Pizza located in Sayville NY is a beloved local eatery known for its delicious freshly made pizzas and inviting atmosphere.

Best Pizza around Fire Island Pines, NY – Sayville Pizza

We offer pickup and delivery to Fire Island Pines! Get pizza delivered in 45 mins. Featuring. Catering. Delivery. Takeout. Dine in. Serves Happy Hour Food. Has …

Pines Pizza – Fire Island

Home · Sip N Twirl · Pines Bistro · Pines Pizza · How to Get Here · Catering · Home · Sip N Twirl …

Reviews

Sky Thai
Simple pizza joint that hits the spot earlier in the day or late at night! It’s reheated, but even so it’s still actually done well. Super crispy thin crust that just hits right. Located right at the pavilion so hard to miss when going up to high tea!
… more
carmine borrelli
Oh god….. horrific!!!!! First off walk in and the counter guy is just talking and talking to the guy wasted in front of me. I lagit heard him say oh yeah it’s gonna be more expensive every day for slices now. Soooo how much was a slice? 7.50… or I’m sorry 17 something for two….. now let’s talk about how the place is deaddddd w a town fulllll of people at dinner time…. Yeah red flag one…. Lagit running the place w one counter person…. A “boss of some sort comes popping in and throws a rope of register tape under the register looked for .00005 seconds and ran out. No hello nothihghggg not even to his one employee…. Sad…. Then I get two slices and order a white w extra pepperoni and a buffalo slice…..huge mistake and waste of money….. I should have tasted the pepperoni as I got it w extra pepperoni and added salt pepper and garlic and guess what… absolutely not an ounce of flavor at all whatsoever. I’m talking triangle rubber with colored red circles they call pepperoni and I suppose cheese? Yeah no not it never again. Oh wait the buffalo chicken slice was even better. Triangle rubber w chicken substitutes and a bottle of Tabasco sauce on it…..grosssssss!!!!! I’ll never ever again w that food everrrrr! I can feel my stomach turning as we type this. I’ll bet in N hour I will absolutely get sick. Cmonnnnnnn man in the glorious pines no less!!?!
… more
Michelle McConvey
Recently they have started refusing to sell full pies at night even though they clearly have them sitting there on the back counter and in the oven.
… more
Donna Schubert
We love Pines Pizza! It is delicious and at times we order it to bring home and request not to cook fully and they always make out satisfaction! Delicious, courtesy and just a fine place to eat!
… more
E T
The pizza is good. Not great, but good. The prices are extreme, which you might be able
to look past if extremely hungry…but the service is TERRIBLE. Really terrible. If you can avoid, please do. Call me and I’ll make a pizza for you…
… more
Andrew Gutterman
Pizza is fine. They make up new policies as they go. Today they don’t allow you to order a full pizza after 5pm. Can only buy by the slice from 5pm to midnight??
… more
Cyd Zeigler
The only game in town, and it’s still quite good. We stop here at least once a trip. Just relax and enjoy the pizza.
… more
Luke Miller
It’s not the best pizza, and it’s not fairly priced, but it’s there for you when you need it most
… more
Allen Rogers
Very good pizza, excellent Service. Great for a quick snack
… more
AD THOMAS
The cooks are top shelf. The staff are always attentive and always willing to please.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact