Wesley Cover
Our first time trying Piesanos and we absolutely loved it! The selection of food was good and even the bread to start was really delicious! The pizza was phenomenal and the broccoli garlic chicken dish my wife got was amazing. And to top it off, our server Jesse did an excellent job and made sure that our first visit was awesome! They definitely earned our business!
… moreAngel Gonzalez
Piesanos Stone Fire Pizza was a great find during our trip to St. Augustine. The place is large, beautiful, and welcoming. We started with complimentary garlic rolls and ordered the garlic parmesan breadsticks — both fresh, warm, and packed with flavor.
I had a thin-crust Antico pizza topped with fresh mozzarella, mini cup-and-char pepperoni, and fresh basil. The stone-fired crust and toppings were spot-on. My girlfriend went with the Bruschetta Flatbread, made with house-made flatbread, mozzarella, diced tomatoes, garlic, basil, and finished with a balsamic reduction — super fresh and delicious.
Overall, great food, great service, and definitely a spot worth visiting in St. Augustine.
… moreLee Hargitt
We came in for the pizza but ended up ordering the eggplant parmigiano and loved it! Our server was Jesse and he was great, friendly and attentive! The atmosphere was pleasant and comfortable. We’ll be back… and maybe get that pizza that sounds delicious!
… moreKeith Landers
Really enjoyed dinner here tonight . Lasagna was excellent and our friends loved their meals as well. We had 18 people and unanimously everyone loved the food. Jessie and he did a great job even though a party they had the rights to charge us 20% they chose not to. And we tipped appropriately more than that because they deserved it highly recommend the pizzas and lasagnas
… moreGreg Juarez
First time and last time. The knots were good no complaints. But we ordered a 16” inches with pepperoni and when it came out it looked amazing, but don’t let looks deceive you. The toppings fell right off. I mean everything. When the waitress ask if everything was ok and we told her what we thought about the pizza she became defensive after we declined if we wanted anything to kinda make it right. I showed her the pizza topping sliding right off and she said it because they use fresh tomatoes. Also because I was holding the pizza upright. Also the meatballs don’t taste fresh. We order spaghetti.
… moreAlex Fiser
We’re visiting St. Augustine and we always order pizza at least once on beach trips.
We tried PIESANOS and it was very good.
Cupped pepperoni ✅️
Deluxe ✅️
White with spinach and mushrooms ✅️
Wings ☆☆☆☆
My only criticism is the 20″ pizza were a little floppy toward the center…. but they were LOADED with toppings. when we order again, we’ll ask them to cook it a few extra minutes.
We recommend this restaurant
… moreMatt Sullivan
Had the fettuccine with chicken. Definitely not the best I’ve had. Maybe half a chicken breast sliced and dried out. The Alfredo was runny as water with very little taste.
My wife had a personal size pizza, which was “ok.” Service was a bit off, but ok.
The bar area and seating was nice. Very little wait. Nice bar and drink menu. Just not a lot of of knowledge from the server.
… moreDame and Duchess
WORST BIRTHDAY DINNER My daughter & I came here to celebrate my 54th birthday. We aren’t able to go out much as we rescue dogs which causes restrictions on our time and our finances. We were excited to try this place as we have eaten at the Gainesville location a couple of years ago and the pizza was good. She is Celiac and they have a cauliflower SMALL crust. We started with 2 salads. Mine came out without any dressing so I had to wait for a server to check on us and ask for the dressing. We ordered 2 Gluten Free pizzas to share. The Cauliflower Margherita and The Cauliflower Rustica with diced pepperoni. The training server asked me which pizza to add the pepperoni to. I told him the Rustica and pointed to it on the menu. (Important details) Our 2 pizzas come out to table by the original female server and the male trainee who took the order. They did not provide plates, napkins, silverware or a pizza pie server. I asked for plates & napkins then my daughter spoke up and mentioned there was no pepperoni on the Rustica. (In pictures with the ridiculous heap of tomato sauce.) The female server told her to “dig deep it’s probably down below, if not she’d bring some.” Both servers walked away not waiting a second to see if the pepperoni was included. The trainee came back out a few minutes later with refrigerated plates, napkins & pizza server. My daughter told him there was no pepperoni. He said “she put some in”. I wondered which one because no one asked us which one we originally ordered. The Margherita had no flavor and the crust was not baked the way cauliflower crusts require. The Rustica was not at all good either. You wouldn’t put that amount of sauce on pasta let alone a pizza. We also didn’t expect the cheese to buried under it. As if this dinner wasn’t bad enough…both servers approach the table again, she is cupping a small bowl of orange coated pepperoni slices and in a condescending tone she says “just to clarify, did you really order pepperoni?” Shocked by her question, I replied “of course I did. I even pointed to it.” (I forgot then that I had also told the trainee which pizza to put it on.) As she is still holding onto the tiny bowl of the wrong pepperoni, I told them we are done, we didn’t want the pepperoni any more, that the 1 she had was incorrect, we needed 2 boxes and the check. The servers walked away. No apologies. Nothing. The manager comes and told me he’ll take the pepperoni off the bill. I thought how kind of you. Removing the pepperoni from the pizza that wasn’t there to begin with or the wrong one the server brought out that never even landed on the table. I was a bartender/server for 20 years and this type of service would never be acceptable. This bad experience cost $67 plus tip. I did not make a scene or take a video and blast it on social media…but I do believe leaving a review might be a teachable moment for this establishment.
… morePatrick Osteen
Lizzie was awesome! Food was very very good and a very comfortable atmosphere. First time going and I WILL be back. I had the chicken carbonara.
… moreJoel Hancock
What a delightful dinner the family and I had here. We started with the rolls with the house dressing and shared a large Hot Honey pizza. Everything was delicious. Staff were quick and friendly which I was a little surprised given the volume of people coming in and dining. Strongly recommend and will be back.
… more