Carlos Then
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 8.7/10 – Solid Slice That Took Me Back
This pizza brought me straight back to my NYC days — grabbing a slice and a Coke after school. The crust was solid, no flop, held up perfectly, and had that nice chew with a light crisp. The pepperoni and cheese combo hit all the right notes, with just enough of that glorious grease you blot with a napkin but secretly love because it makes it even better.
The Garlic Cheese Sticks were decent — melted cheese game was on point, but I was left wanting more garlic punch. A bit more flavor would’ve taken it over the top.
✅ Classic NYC vibes
✅ Crust game strong
✅ Great cheese/pep ratio
✅ Garlic sticks = decent, but room to grow
Overall? Solid. A great pie that hits that nostalgic craving just right. 8.7/10 – would definitely go back. #PizzaReview #NYStyleVibes #PierPizzaCo #RIeats
… moreDom Valenti
Best pizza ive had in the area im from out of town and the pizza is dang good keep up the good work i will be back when im in the area again the gentleman working today was very nice and provided quick service pizza was also reasonably priced
… moreFrank Iacobbo
Owner take notice please. I ordered a meatball calzone with ricotta. What I discovered I had was a calzone shell filled with cheese and maybe 2 or 3 fragments of meatball. No exaggeration . Literally a tablespoon or so of meatballs. This was on Sunday night 11/16. I’m not a picky guy but this was way beyond the pale. Incredibly bad quality. A couple of kids watching cartoons that couldn’t be bothered .
… moreAlexis Harpin
No matter the time of day or year it’s always a pleasure to be able to stroll in for a simple yet perfect slice of pizza. The gentleman that runs the place is exactly that, really adds to the comfort you feel whether you’re eating in or taking out.
… moreJessica Kottmann
I don’t usually leave reviews, but I had to for this place—this pizza was absolutely DELICIOUS!
Everything from the sauce to the crust to the cheese was on point. You can really taste the quality and care that goes into making it. This is definitely going to be my new go-to spot for pizza. Highly recommend!
… moreDanielle Marie
I’ve gotten Sick the last 2 times I ordered from D>eMoz!, & twisted charges 20$!! For the same ceaser salad that isn’t even cut up.. The pizza wars are OVER! PIER PIZZA HAS THE BEST SLICE HANDS DOWN NO CONTEST!! BRAVO! VELISIMO! END OF STORY! ALWAYS FRESH! ALWAYS THE BEST!!!!
… moreMichael Bell
My pizza was AMAZING! Every flavor included on my Buffalo pizza was even with one another. Nothing was overpowering. It was quick service, too. Would highly recommend giving this place a try!
… moreThomas Greatorex
Have been trying a new pizza place in the Warwick area for a few weekends now and this place is the first place that hit the spot. Very good New York style pizza for an awesome price! Very quickly made and served very hot! Not to greasy but enough to satisfy and cure most hangovers!
… moreMERCEDES FAUST
Bro I Order small stuff here all the time. They didn’t have anything in the system, and when I explained over and over order still not right. One pizza looked like soup on bread and I asked for “extra crispy “ for one slice of pizza
… moreEric Silva
Always love stopping by and getting a slice to go. Very good NY style pizza!
… more