Gary Sessions
I purchased the pie as a gift. The person I gave it to said it was delicious. The staff were extremely helpful and friendly. It wasn’t my first time there and I hope it’s not my last.
… moreLili Silva
Was there for the infamous Raffle Dazzle Pie….no words…best pie and pie filing I have ever had! I have orders to buy more for family living out of state. Small town feel inside the Pie Pantry, families coming and going as they take a break from the water Park (walk around soaking wet, ha, ha…. Just sweet atmosphere. Will definitely return!!!
… moreJeff Stainer (Re/Max Action)
The pumpkin pie and no lower crust and over spiced. The apple pie – the crust was like paste… too expensive… use to be the best of the best… NO longer is that the story unfornuately,
… moreRick Johnson
Used to pretty good place to get a piece of good pie. However, we stopped by last week and was very disappointed. Limited choices of pies. Only offered something called pocket pie. We tried one, not good. Can’t buy pie, except certain days.
I found my shoes sticking to the floor near the pie case. I mentioned it to the person at the counter got, absolutely no concern. We won’t be back!
… moreAnna Panter
Pie pantry not what it should be called first of all. The only way to get a piece of regular pie is to order a whole pie or other wise you get a pie pocket. Not what I expected. Also no cream pie till the weekend. This place is limited on pie. So why call it pie pantry?.. disappointed. I could have went to the store and got a hostess pie in that case and taste just okay. Just as this pie pocket I had. It was okay. Nothing special for sure.
… moreMelissa Willson
My daughter bought 4 mini pies and 5 frozen yogurts. Plan on paying over $70.00 for this. The cake batter frozen yogurts was like milk after 5 minutes. Nothing frozen about it at all. Way overpriced and not that good at all. The pies were ok but not worth the price. Next time we want something sweet we’ll go somewhere else. Highly disappointed
… moreNicole Parker
I have been coming to Pie Pantry for as long as I can remember and I love the pie pockets, but it’s almost impossible to get them. They close at 10:30, but go in after 5 or 6 and good luck getting anything. Went in at 7 today and were completely sold out of all pie pockets, and had only chapple whole pies left. This has been a consistent issue for the past several years, even pre COVID. Just poor planning from a business standpoint. I want to keep supporting them, but it’s not worth the hassle anymore.
… moreHeather Perry
Got a whole cherry pie. Giving it one star because it was pretty. But the crust was so hard and flavorless and the cherry filling was awful. It tasted like maraschino cherries. For a place called the pie pantry, I was expecting really good pie. I make better pie. Shoot, Walmart makes better pie.
… moreBryan
Delicious Apple turnovers!!! Yummy flaky, buttery crust. Plenty in stock. We bought 6 of them and they were all gone in an hour. Yummy!!!
… moreRachel Taylor
Their apple pie is delicious! Worth the price. I suggest buying a whole apple pie that they have cooked. I always get the same thing and my family loves it.
… more