Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 12013 E Main St, Wolcott, NY 14590
Phone: (315) 594-1507
Website: https://petersnewyorkpizzeria.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Peter’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant – Wolcott
Peter’s New York. Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant · Fresh & Hot! · Eat-in or take out with your hosts Maria, Joe, Sal, and Sue. · Thanks for visiting our Website!
Peter’s New York Pizzeria | Wolcott NY – Facebook
Prters new york pizzeria is open today till 10 pm last order by 930. We will be closed for Christmas . 315 594 1507 .merry Christmas to all my family and …
Peter’s New York Pizzeria, 12013 E Main St, Wolcott, NY 14590, US
Peter’s New York Pizzeria in Wolcott, NY, has been a family-owned and operated establishment since 1991, earning a reputation as the region’s best pizzeria.
Reviews
Elizabeth Bradley
1st time. Ordered large pizza 20 wing special and a steak and cheese sub. Food was delicious and fresh. Hint of sweet sauce which we really liked . Crust was really good too. Wings were meaty with great flavor Sub was delicious with Italian seasoning. Very happy with our order. Price was very reasonable. We will be regular customer’s thank you.
… moreBetty Cavazos
The food was amazing!!! I had the garlic shrimp and omg so good… a Sunday relax day good food and was here in great time.. will order again and again…
… moreAlycia Simonds-Gomez
This is my first time in NY so I had to try NY style pizza and this place did not disappoint! The gentleman and woman behind the counter were so sweet and patient as we figured out what we were all ordering. The pizza was incredible and the garlic knots were 10/10- I wish I could steal their red sauce recipe because it was delicious.
… moreHejus Joshun
Wonderful. Pleasant staff, great food, quality prices.
These folks make fine pies. Excellent.
Best pizza in the area, and it’s not close.
They also have great pasta.
… moreThese folks make fine pies. Excellent.
Best pizza in the area, and it’s not close.
They also have great pasta.
Curtis Beebe
Excellent pizza and wings and super friendly service. Highly recommend this place.
… moreMichelle Bankes
Everything we got was delicious. Our fish and chips portions were huge. Of course we had to have some authentic NY pizza while we were here and Peter’s did not disappoint. The sauce and crust were to perfection, very fresh tasting cheese.
We took our pizza to the bluffs for an anniversary sunset that was just our style
… moreWe took our pizza to the bluffs for an anniversary sunset that was just our style
Angela Krueger
Extremely disappointed!!! I’ve always got amazing pizza and wings from here!!! It was my moms birthday and she wanted pizza and wings…I grabbed a sheet pizza and 30 wings,half garlic parm half mild. Got home and it didnt even taste like pizza. The sauce tasted like it was bad. Something was definitely wrong with the sauce and the dough was super super hard. I had to get a steak knife to cut it!! Not to mention we all got sick a few hours later!! Puking and all the things. The wings seemed like they were double fried and didnt taste like garlic parm or mild at all. I called to just tell them and complain and the response I got was next time we will give you sauce on the side for your wings and when I tried to mention the pizza it was ok thank you and I got hung up on.This will be the last time I get food from there. For the amount of money I paid for that I would think they would of did something to help the situation and rectify it!! Nope!! And its a running thing because one of my friends have ordered a few times and have had the same experience with the wings and the pizza was poop. I never ever write a bad review but wow I just had to!!
… moreDoren Thompson
Amazing pizza, great staff, and the atmosphere reminded me of an old-style NY pizzeria. The pizza was perfect, thin crust, great sauce, and just the right amount of cheese.
… moreRichard Pease
We were looking for a good spot to get dinner on our way from Lake Placid to Rochester. After looking at the reviews we decided this was the place and we were not disappointed. The portions are generous, the prices fair and the atmosphere unbeatable. The owner treated us like we were friends stopping by and we had a great chat about the Yankees. The food tasted just like New York City and if I am ever this way again I will be coming by for more!
… moreSequence In Scenes
Excellent food, excellent people. I was in town from Buffalo for the weekend, and I always struggle trying to find a great New York style pizza near me. I was thrilled to find Peter’s while out here for the weekend. Felt like I was bringing home a pizza straight from any Brooklyn pizzeria. Don’t hesitate to grab a pie from here, and the steak sub is incredible excellent sub rolls
… more