Veteran diner supplies generous portions of comfort food & a popular four-course special.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 665-1788
Website: http://peterpandiner.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Peter Pan Diner – Official Website | Order Online Direct | Bay Shore
Peter Pan Diner – Official Website | Order Online Direct – for Faster Service, Daily Specials, Discounts & more! – Pickup & Delivery Available.
GRAND REOPENING: The iconic Peter Pan Diner will welcome …
Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore reopens in October. Gloria R Nash ▻ Dinerville. 40w · Public · The Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore, Long Island, NY …
After 20 months, Peter Pan Diner set to reopen in Bay Shore
Bay Shore’s Peter Pan Diner reopens this coming week after a 20-month closure due to a summer 2024 kitchen fire, featuring renovations, …
Last Updates
Reviews
Lorraine T
The best diner! Clean, efficient, friendly. Has everything you’d expect and more from a diner. Corned beef hash at breakfast was perfect and not greasy at all. Food well prepared and presented. Our server, sorry, I didn’t get her name, but she was excellent. The manager was friendly and professional, and dressed in a crisp tailored shirt. There were two birthdays and they were prepared with a recorded song that everyone sang to. I would definitely recommend this place.
… moreGail Melisa
One of the best diners on the Island. I have been dining here for over 15 years. There are lots of regular customers. Favorites: Belgian waffle with fruit salad, matzoh ball soup, turkey bacon
Runners up: chicken noodle soup, omelettes
Staff is friendly and professional. Highly recommend
… moreRunners up: chicken noodle soup, omelettes
Staff is friendly and professional. Highly recommend
Michael T Calvaruso
Petter Pan Diner was a much more than pleasant surprise. First off that they were open for inside dining was great. Next, the interior was immaculate the decor warm & welcoming & the staff very friendly & top of their game in serving. Now the food? Oh man the food! Both my wife & I had burger deluxe platters. I got mine with sauteed onions added to the burger…YUM. Everything was cooked to perfection, the burger just right aaaand juicy. The sweet potato fries, the onion rings crispy on the outside & delicious on the inside! Even the Cole Slaw & pickle were super fresh & delicious. My wife ordered a slice of Lemon Meringue & I ordered the Chocolate Cream pie. We both were over the moon how fantastic these.two desserts were! When we left we were both thoroughly full & very happy! This diner really delivered two completely wonderful, lip smacking good meals. Go visit them!
… moreRonald Thomas All Rights Reserved (ALL RIGHTS RESERVED)
Great food! Great service! Great experience everytime! Have been coming here for at least 30 years!
… moreFrank M
Had a very pleasant experience. Great dinner food. Had the turkey club panini and the veggie burger. I’d recommend both.
The turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.
… moreThe turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.
Fabby momz
Food was really delicious. Service was great ! Nice inviting atmosphere. Love the birthday celebration style. Overall was a nice place to sit and enjoy my meal .
… moreRick White
Excellent Diner, Delicious food and Spectacular service. Highly recommend!! Roxy is one of their best waitresses.
… moreJune Mccarthy
The waitresses are very friendly. The food is fantastic there portions are oversized I had a grill chicken wrap with chopped tomatoes and chopped lettuce she gave me a dill dressing that was so delicious plus I had onion rings pickle & coleslaw. My mom had a burger and onion rings and a pickle and coleslaw I only can eat half of my grill chicken wrap. My mother only ate half a burger I definitely recommend this place definitely get your money’s worth mother order piece of cheesecake after dinner the slice was so huge sorry I forgot to take a picture of that next time it’s my favorite Diner.
… moreSusan K.L.
Great food and service here. Food was so tasty that I had to wrap it and take it to go!! The onion rings were amazing!
… moreNeeks
Delicious waffles and chocolate chip pancakes. The ice coffee was also very good. The staff is so friendly!. Lots of parking !
… more