Pepperoni’s Pizza: Home
At Pepperoni’s & Co in Simsbury, we serve delicious Food such as Pasta, Calzones, Pizza, Salads and more! We are located in Holloway Plaza, in front of …
Anthony Schiappa
I had high hopes for Pepperoni’s Pizza after hearing some good things, but unfortunately the pizza didn’t live up to the hype. The dough was undercooked, which gave it a really strange texture, and the pizza itself just had zero flavor. Maybe they were just having an off night, but based on this experience and with so many other great options in the area, I won’t be returning.
… moreKyle Caisse
New Owner.
Been eating here for years. Same great pizza.
Prices have increased.
Restaurant needs to be cleaned and then Refreshed! New Owner is sitting on a great pizza but not having a clean place to sell from hurts. I really hope to see success here!
… moreKatie Aponte
We do takeout/ delivery about 1x a week and the food is always consistently great. We usually order calzones, meatball and spaghetti meals, occasionally pizza, and salads. Portions are great and usually have leftovers for lunch the next day. My husband finds almost all restaurant food disappointing, but he is the first to suggest we order here. Wait time is minimal, whether picking or delivery. Very friendly staff and service.
… moreFred Moore
Coming from the New Haven area, we were spoiled a little with the pizza selections. We have tried quite a few pizzas in the area and Peperoni’s is one that we tend to frequent. Always fresh, nice crust and the extras are always good too – salads, chicken tenders, fries, ect
… moreJeremy Brisebois
Catered a huge pizza order for a party. Delivered a bit earlier than expected but I imagine coordinating a very large order doesn’t always end up exact. Pizzas came as ordered and everyone enjoyed them.
… moreTHIRTYSIXRED2001
This was extremely disappointing. Tried to use my AARP coupon promotion but nobody working there understands what AARP is
How they were ever offering coupons through AARP website and then won’t honor them is beyond my understanding
Place is small. Maybe 3 tables and a Television mounted from the ceiling
Food…never even got to try it as they would not honor the promotion
With all the competition for pizza and dining options…don’t waste your efforts with this place in Simsbury
There are better options available…just wanted to try a new place I’d never been to
… moreSean Kerstetter
Wife and I got a supreme pizza, a margarita pizza, and a side of garlic cheese bread. Food seemed to be hit or miss depending on what you got. My supreme was pretty good, but the margarita wasn’t as tasty and the cheese bread fell so short of standards that we never finished it. Overall, it was decent pizza, though not fantastic. I don’t see myself going back.
On a separate note, we were surprised when we paid the bill. The prices in the google maps listing are dramatically different than what Pepperoni’s and Co is charging. Our bill came out to be nearly $5 more than anticipated. If you order, be sure you use their actual website to get the updated pricing.
… moreTina Staino
Knew the original owner was retiring, but yikes… food has gone down hill. We have eaten here for several years and food has been great. Unfortunately, we ordered on 8/28/2025 and my husband paid online. We live about 15 minutes away mind you. My husband shows up, we got stuffed shells and pizza. The manger says to my husband: “ I’m sorry, we didn’t press start on THE MICROWAVE for your stuffed shells”. Absolutely baffled. Stuffed shells are NOT meant to be cooked in a microwave, but an oven. Are you even making authentic food or buying from stop and shop and putting it in the microwave? GROSS. Will never order here again. So sad to see it go down hill. OH and the “side salad” didn’t even come with dressing ♀️
… moreMarco’s Italian Restaurant
I tried out Pepperonis today for lunch. Decided to try…you guessed it! Pepperoni pizza. I grabbed two slices and a can of coke. Coke is always the best from the can. The pizza was very good. The crust was so crispy and airy. Usually I don’t eat all of the crust but it was so good I asked for a side of ranch so I could dip it. I’d eat here again. The aesthetics could use a lift. Even if there was some music playing in the back to break up the silence and fridge motors running. None of this detracts from the delicious pizza though.
… moreEvan Robert
Good food, but doesn’t use gloves or wash hands ever. Cross contamination is a huge concern. Unfortunate. I wish the FVHD would be on top of things much more than they are.
… more