Paul Martinka
Pepperboy truely has some of the best pizza in the area, best in New Ulm by far. Had their pizza last night 11/15/25. Pepperboy is in the old but newly renovated Ben Franklin building in New Ulm on Minnesota street. The entrance is on the side of the building on 2nd St N. Pepperboy and Benny’s bar (ben frainkin) are 1 in the same. Same servers, nice bar with a good selection. With awesome pizza and other goodies. I highly suggest checking them out.
… moreEvelyn Hinkel
Pizza was absolutely delicious place was so clean and welcoming and warm,service was absolutely amazing! I recommend!
… moreHeath Dobberpuhl
Good new bar. Same great pizza.
Price per person: …
… moreZach Thomas
By far, the best pizza place in town! The food is amazing for a great price! The staff are very polite, and punctual. I would highly recommend if you’re looking for good service.
… moreEric Severson
Excellent pizza!! I ordered onsite and the team made me a spectacular pizza. I came back to pick it up and it was delivered directly to to my vehicle. What a tasty pizza and had some left over for the next day.
… moreEvan Meeker
Their pizza is absolutely incredible. I feel like this place is such a hidden gem.
They also do ribs on Saturdays which are just as good as the pizza!
… moreIan Furness
Not open. No signs showing it was closed for a private party until we got to the door.
… moreAmy Sherwood
The Hawaiian is the best I have ever had.
… moreAndrew Turner
Visiting from out of town and we were surprised to find this place tucked back in an alley. Fantastic pizza, amazing experience, and a memorable adventure!
… moreJeremy Ryder
Not sure what’s going on with this place they have great reviews like it’s open but when I call to see if they are open today the message says it’s not going to be open for a couple of weeks very confusing and feels like the reviews are fake.
… more