Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 923 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Phone: (330) 343-0506
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Penso’s Pizza – New Philadelphia, OH – 923 E High Ave – Hours …
Get 10% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Penso’s Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH. Order online for delivery or …
Penso’s Pizza – 923 E High Ave, New Philadelphia, OH 44663 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New Philadelphia, OH! Penso’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Pizza By Penso – New Phila | New Philadelphia OH – Facebook
Pizza By Penso – New Phila · Details · Links · Contact info. . (330) 343-0506. . [email protected]. Photos. See all. Posts. Pizza By Penso …
Last Updates
Reviews
Steve Johnson
Best Pizza I’ve ever tasted in all my years on this earth! Carly Simon’s song “Nobody does it better” comes to mind! Been to dozens of states… tasted hundreds of pizzas… nobody comes close! Top rating…5 Stars!!!! Absolutely the best!
… moreKim Contini
The crust was like shoe leather dried out nothing like it use to be for 17.00
… moreAmanda Putnam
Order off the app and it sucked said order was approved and paid for , showed up and pizza was never ordered.. The pizza was good ( lil chewy) and could of use more cheese since we paid for extra…
… moreVickie Hixson
Haven’t had pizza from here for 20 years, sorry to say but we couldn’t even eat it. Crust was so rubbery , hard to chew. I ask for bacon but not even sure if that’s what was on it. Something looked like chunks of ham that you seriously could not chew. Sorry but it’s off the list for us.
… moremankey on yt
oh my gos! Where do I start first the service was AMAZING but you know what’s even better the SALAD it is delightful I’ve never had anything better if I had to choose one thing to eat for the the rest of my life it would be THAT SALAD there was this teenage boy named Zayden he was the best and nicest worker I’ve ever met service was a 5/5 his salad was a 5/5 I love this place will definitely be recommending to ALL my friends
… moreJeremy Marcum
I love the one in Strasburg! I don’t know if they are different owners. (Cash only) I went here one time over 10 years ago. It is good to see it is still the same.
… moreDarryl Lamonica
One of the best pizzas in Tusc County
Price per person: …
… morePrice per person: …
Kelly Lehigh
Best. Pizza in Phila!!! Tonight we got the thin crust for the first time and it was killer! The toppings were perfect, and the sauce ratio was on point! So many people skimp out on the best part of the pizza Thanks for making a quality pizza, making it as if you were going to be eating it. People don’t do that anymore. Thanks for a great experience. You guys are the best!
… moreKeith Gamble
Delicious pizza. The best around. Service is tip top as well.
… moreCarol Ruszin
We have been eating Penso’s Pizza at least once a week for the past 45 years. Great crust, delicious sauce, lots of toppings to choose from. Their chef salads and spaghetti are wonderful. We call so often they don’t even ask for our name anymore. They are on the second generation of pizza makers and the third generation is in the wings. The three brothers each have their own shop in different cities and each one has a little different taste from the others but all are delicious. My children, grandchildren, and now my great grandson have all cut teeth on Penso’s Pizza crust. The family is so friendly and warm, it feels like home. You’ll love it!!
… more