Jason S
Great pizza, and the spinnies are excellent!
The pizza has a semi-thin but dense crust. It’s a little more chewy in consistency than say a typical NY-style pizza. The toppings were fresh and tasty. The place is a little out of the way for us, but whenever it’s convenient, Penny’s will be a go-to pizza spot for us. Definitely one of the better pizza options in Salem!
… moretrent worden
Got some pizza delivered for me, and totally real and not made up at all, smoking hot girlfriend. This pizza slaps. The sauce is super good, and the bread is delicious. They have all the toppings you could want. Would highly recommend giving this spot a try.
… moreLarisa
Really great pizza made with premium ingredients, you can truly taste the quality in every bite. The chocolate chip cookies are amazing too. Everything feels thoughtfully made. Can’t wait to come back when the spinnys are back!
… moreAndrew Marshall
Cafeteria pizza at best. I ordered a plain cheese, and a Hawaiin pizza for another person, both were awful. If you like pizza that has less taste than a Digorno frozen pizza, along with dough that is barely flavorful and not cooked this is your place. Not worth $5. Terrible.
… moreAlejandro Saravia
Just found this place this week. Went for the spinnys and they were so delicious I had to go back and try the pizza. And I can absolutely say this is my new favorite pizza. Everything is so flavorful from the crust to the toppings. And the ranch is amazing. All topped off by the very friendly and welcoming service from the owner himself. All around satisfied.
… moreBrittany VanWinkle
This pizza is absolutely amazing. Super fresh. Soft, buttery crust that’s just slightly sweet. Zesty sauce, fresh toppings. Definitely ordering again. Put less stars for atmosphere, because it isn’t a sit down restaurant. Still gave it some love though, because it is always cool to see an industrial-looking commercial kitchen with all the equipment. Neat picking up, because you get a peek behind the scenes. Also, the SPINNY is a must-try. Thank, Brian!
… moreKira Martin
Best pizza in Salem, just incredible. Gotta try it!
The crust was so soft and delicious, a thicker style crust loaded with great quality pepperoni. This is a style of pizza Salem desperately needs! Absolutely loved the uniqueness of the spinnies, so tasty. The owner Brian is so friendly and cool, great service. Will 100% be back.
… moreTrevor Bednarz
Brian is a great guy, and his pizza is excellent. The cookie is the best in Salem too! Highly recommended.
… moreJaskaran S
I had the Pepperoni Spinny and it was insane. Perfectly crispy, loaded with cheese, and the ranch? Bomb. This ain’t no regular pizza roll.
I’ll definitely be back!
… moreKate Johnson
So good!! Sauce is incredible and the dough is light and fluffy. New local favorite!!
… more