
**Penny Lick Ice Cream’s location in Ossining is closed for the season! We look forward to welcoming you back in the spring.** Penny Lick Ice Cream Company was founded in 2013 with the mission of bringing back old-fashioned, custard-based ice cream. We believe that the best ice cream is the simplest. That means dairy from local cows treated ethically, sustainable whole food ingredients, no artificial flavors or colors. Plus, we never use peanuts, tree nuts or sesame, so everyone can enjoy our ice cream.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1A Westerly Rd, Ossining, NY 10562
Phone: (914) 374-3698
Website: https://www.pennylickicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Penny Lick Ice Cream | Old-Fashioned, Nut-Free Ice Cream
Find Penny Lick Ice Cream | Locations & Hours
Penny Lick Ice Cream (@pennylickicecream) – Instagram
Reviews
I really loved the vegan blueberry maple (oat milk). The base was really good and streaks of blueberries were delicious.
The strawberry ice cream clearly showed that their ice cream was homemade as it was a light pink (no artificial color) and had actual frozen bits of strawberries and strawberry seeds. However, it like the vanilla and cookies and cream weren’t amazing.
We love going here around 6:30/7pm to watch the sunset, get our ice cream (with of course the coolest sprinkles!) and to enjoy the beautiful view!
Bring a blanket to hang out on the grass! We are so lucky to have Bigfoot Creamery in our community!
Overall, this is a wonderful spot and the staff are beyond the nicest ladies. If you can’t think of what to try, just ask them for a recommendation.
FYI: not too many flavors available
Dog friendly
Free parking during the weekends!!
They pride themselves on using all-natural, fresh ingredients, which does mean they often run out quickly as they don’t keep a large surplus of products in the back.
During my visit, I tried the Blueberry Jam and White Chocolate Cherry flavors. The Blueberry Jam was very subtle, and I could barely taste the blueberry in it. However, the White Chocolate Cherry was exceptionally sweet and savory, making it a delightful treat.
Overall, Penny Lick Ice Cream is a great addition to the area and definitely worth a visit for their fresh, high-quality offerings.