Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Penn Street Pizza is owned by Alan Miles. Alan owned and operated Fox’s Pizza for over 37 years at the same location at 500 West Penn Street . In February 2017 Alan left the Fox’s franchise and opened Penn Street Pizza ! Alan is no longer associated or affiliated with Fox’s Pizza in any way ! Alan is Butler’s longest running owner/operator in the pizza business. Alan has been serving the Butler area for 44 years since he began in August of 1980 . Penn Street Pizza offers only the best with fresh local produce and fresh ingredients. Our meats and cheeses are hand sliced daily ! The secret to the best Hoagies , Stromboli and Pizza is the oven ! We use the best ovens. Blodgett brick deck gas ovens cook slow unlike conveyor ovens ! Come try
Laid-back chain serving specialty pizzas in varied shapes & sizes, plus sandwiches, salads & sides.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 500 W Penn St, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 285-7200
Website: http://pennstreetpizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Homepage – Penn Street Pizza of Butler, PA
Location Information: · To Order, Call (724) 285-7200 · Operating Hours: Mon – Tues: 3pm – 11pm. Wed – Thurs: 11am – 11pm. Friday …
Penn Street Pizza Butler PA – Facebook
Penn Street Pizza Butler PA, Butler. 282 likes · 1 talking about this · 41 were here. Penn Street Pizza in Butler is owned by Alan Miles . Alan owned…
Penn Street Pizza, 500 W Penn St, Butler, PA 16001, US – MapQuest
Penn Street Pizza in Butler, PA is a beloved local eatery known for serving up delicious pizza, hoagies, strombolis, and other Italian favorites.
Reviews
Supernatural Realm Radio
Ordered a taco salad and a steak hoagie total bill came to $24.68 They were very skimpy on the lettuce , tomatoes, black olives, meat , cheese etc. The steak hoagie was even worse. I basically got a plain bun! It took them 3 hours to deliver my order Worst experience ever and will not be placing an order with them again any time soon.
… moreLeah Tate
If you are local and want something quick and affordable, this would be a great option. Probably a good place to go if you need to feed a bunch of kids. They have solid deals on Fri/Sat.
If you are looking for your favorite new pizza, I don’t know that this will be for you.
The owners and employees are very nice! The amount of toppings is probably unmatched, like totally covered the entire pie! And the price is right.
However, that crust is a crime. I don’t think I’ve ever had dry pizza until now. The bottom is so overdone it becomes dark and hard. There is not fluffy top crust at all. It just feels cheap overall, and I suspect they use a premade crust. I have heard that you need to ask for it “lightly done” to avoid the crust issue, and if we try this place again, I would likely try that!
Overall, worth it for a quick easy meal on budget, but nothing to write home about.
… moreIf you are looking for your favorite new pizza, I don’t know that this will be for you.
The owners and employees are very nice! The amount of toppings is probably unmatched, like totally covered the entire pie! And the price is right.
However, that crust is a crime. I don’t think I’ve ever had dry pizza until now. The bottom is so overdone it becomes dark and hard. There is not fluffy top crust at all. It just feels cheap overall, and I suspect they use a premade crust. I have heard that you need to ask for it “lightly done” to avoid the crust issue, and if we try this place again, I would likely try that!
Overall, worth it for a quick easy meal on budget, but nothing to write home about.
Czar
I just ordered a Philly steak Stromboli… first off the guy whoever took my ordered first sounded arrogant and like he didn’t want to be there. Second it was an hour and half wait(which would be understandable but…) my order gets here and it’s spicy red/orange peppers doesn’t taste like a Philly cheesesteak Stromboli I ever had. I call back to tell them and the person said there’s nothing wrong with it in annoyed manner. Terrible food, terrible customer service. Just terrible
… moretlbxx87
Best wedgies in town! Love the beef, bacon, and cheddar! I’ve always enjoyed all of the many things that I have received from them.
… moreSean Harcar
Local family owned and operated business. Great low cost pizza. When you’re hungry, in a hurry, and eating out on a budget Penn Street Pizza is a fantastic option.
Specials every Monday.
S, M, L, XL (16 cut), and 24 cut options.
S – XL pizza use a premade shell.
The 24 cut pizza uses fresh hand tossed dough.
A 24 cut hand tossed fresh dough pizza here costs less than a 12 cut pizza does elsewhere.
… moreSpecials every Monday.
S, M, L, XL (16 cut), and 24 cut options.
S – XL pizza use a premade shell.
The 24 cut pizza uses fresh hand tossed dough.
A 24 cut hand tossed fresh dough pizza here costs less than a 12 cut pizza does elsewhere.
Shelby Cates
Great pizza, the Buffalo wings were lacking though, a bit dried out. Pizza was delicious!
… moreJohn M
Ordered wings this evening and they were so over cooked I could have saved it for jerky wow and the guy behind the counter was just scolding the other employees do that without a customer in the store but the wings were thrown in the garbage scared the dogs would cut their mouths I did not ask for extra well done why is it so hard to find good food anymore $20 for 1.5 wings upsetting and we try to only support local but when this is the quality you can’t.
… moreDuckSauce
IF you’re wondering why the phone is always busy it is because the pizza is that good! It is worth the wait and make sure to order the fresh doe
… moreFrank Burka
I got a small cheese pizza a turkey bacon and cheddar hoagie and a sirloin bacon and cheddar hoagie and it was all really good. For the price the quality was beyond what I paid. They told me an hour to an hour and 15 minutes and the delivery driver got here in 45. He was super nice and told me the food would be good. The cheese pizza was great the bottom crust was crispy and the pizza for 5 bucks for a 4 cut was really good. I’ll be eating here again for sure.
… moreAmanllc Amanllc
It is a step below little caesars. I have a one piece of large pizza and threw the rest out.It was the most disgusting thing i’ve ever had.Although it was only ten dollars for a large pizza.So if you’re looking for cheap, I guess the value’s there.
… more