Our menu features an array of mouth watering Grilled Penn Station submarine sandwiches, fresh-cut fries and hand-squeezed lemonade. All sandwiches are prepared fresh in full view of the customer using delicious hearth-baked bread, USDA Choice Steak and the finest meats, cheeses and vegetables. The potatoes are hand selected, fresh-cut and flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil. The lemonade is made from scratch every day using hand-squeezed lemons.
Grilled sub sandwiches, fries & fresh-squeezed lemonade star at this counter-serve chain.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1260 US-51, Forsyth, IL 62535
Phone: (217) 330-7210
Website: http://www.penn-station.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Penn Station | Hot Grilled Subs | Fresh-Cut Fries | Fresh-squeezed …
Welcome to Penn Station – home to hot grilled subs, fresh-cut fries and fresh-squeezed lemonade!
Penn Station East Coast Subs Delivery Menu – Forsyth – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Penn Station East Coast Subs in Forsyth! View Penn Station East Coast Subs’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Penn Station – Forsyth, IL Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices] – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Penn Station at 1260 U.S. 51 in Forsyth. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
ꪶꫀiꪶꪖꪀi ꪑiᥴꫝꫀꪶꪶꫀ
Ordered from here for the first and last time on 3/27/2025 at 5pm.
I placed my order online and picked it up. It consisted of two Philly Cheesesteaks, fries, drinks and cheesebread.
As soon as I opened the wrapper to one of the sandwiches it smelled absolutely disgusting. I almost gagged. It smelled like rotten meat.
I immediately called the store and asked if I needed to bring the sandwiches back before I contacted whatever online customer service to get a refund. I was told that I didn’t need to bring them back. The shift leader on the phone was very sweet and apologetic. I immediately threw the entire bag of food away. All of it. Completely lost my appetite. When I started looking for a customer service contact to refund my online order I found that it didn’t exist. There is an email contact for general inquiries but no online way to correct online orders. I had to call back and speak to a local store manager which I did a few days later.
They were supposed to call me back but they didn’t and I had to call again the next day. They assured me they had refunded the order and I asked if there would be an email confirmation. The woman manager told me no. I hang up and let it be. I was then called back a few hours later from a very professional sounding male owner who wanted to confirm that the issue had been resolved. It was only then that I did infact receive an email confirmation that a refund was given. The refund took a full 4 days after this to go back to our card and it was only for the two sandwiches. I didn’t feel like debating it any further bc I already knew I would not be eating there again bc aside from the rotten smell, they didn’t even resemble what they were supposed to look like in their own photos of the Philly cheesesteak (photos included in review)
… moreI placed my order online and picked it up. It consisted of two Philly Cheesesteaks, fries, drinks and cheesebread.
As soon as I opened the wrapper to one of the sandwiches it smelled absolutely disgusting. I almost gagged. It smelled like rotten meat.
I immediately called the store and asked if I needed to bring the sandwiches back before I contacted whatever online customer service to get a refund. I was told that I didn’t need to bring them back. The shift leader on the phone was very sweet and apologetic. I immediately threw the entire bag of food away. All of it. Completely lost my appetite. When I started looking for a customer service contact to refund my online order I found that it didn’t exist. There is an email contact for general inquiries but no online way to correct online orders. I had to call back and speak to a local store manager which I did a few days later.
They were supposed to call me back but they didn’t and I had to call again the next day. They assured me they had refunded the order and I asked if there would be an email confirmation. The woman manager told me no. I hang up and let it be. I was then called back a few hours later from a very professional sounding male owner who wanted to confirm that the issue had been resolved. It was only then that I did infact receive an email confirmation that a refund was given. The refund took a full 4 days after this to go back to our card and it was only for the two sandwiches. I didn’t feel like debating it any further bc I already knew I would not be eating there again bc aside from the rotten smell, they didn’t even resemble what they were supposed to look like in their own photos of the Philly cheesesteak (photos included in review)
Jamie Southall
The service and quality are definitely not worth the price. My husband and I ordered via door dash and received sandwiches with none of the ingredients we ordered besides cheese and meat when we paid nearly $20 per sandwich. Clearly employees were not caring. Horrible service issues and way over priced.
… moreJo Thomas
Food was great! There was a long line and only two girls working. They worked hard and fast but it took a while to get our food. We thought it was odd that the cheese steak sandwich came with pizza sauce on it….it tasted ok, next time I Will order it with out pizza sauce
… moreHaley Wright
Food is always excellent. The staff have always been so helpful and kind. 10/10 recommend as your new sandwich spot! Half a sandwich is still A LOT of food!
… moreTabitha Damery
The cheesesteak sandwich was good and I love the home made fries!! Usually when I go, the workers act bothered when you walk in, but there were 2 employees I’ve never seen before who were very pleasant. The girl was even checking in with the customers to see if everything was tasting good. I thought that was sweet.
… moreKrista Logue
I go in tonight to order some fries when I go in they are doing closing prep. I proceed to order the medium fry. The guys the came up says okay you can head down to other end to pay I start to walk that way and then the girl cleaning off table says ma’am we can make fries we are out for the night.. I should of asked them to open there fry cooler.. super disappointed.
… moregroupee5
Do not come here if you don’t have over 20 minutes to wait for your food…ridiculous wait times at a time that isn’t even that busy.
… moreMaribel Ziga
In the decatur area, there is no pot bellys where you can enjoy a hot sub. This is close. No soups available but they have the sandwiches, wraps, salad option. I love sandwiches. My toddlers don’t like sandwiches as we can eat them at home. They did have the pizza sandwich and loved it. Loved the fries too. The large fries fed my family of 5. The wait can be long if you choose a busy time to go. Our wait was roughly 12 minutes. The food is made fresh to order with exception of bread like most places done before hand. Very good experience and it fed my craving for a hot sub without having to drive 40+ minutes. Picture is of large fries container compared to a water bottle at home. I will be a regular returning customer.
… moreCurious Irish Angel
The service was fantastic….
The lady behind the counter was friendly and made the perfect sub….
The sandwich was fresh and delicious..
The atmosphere was a little dingy as far as the dine in seating area. (It was clean) just needs some newer upgrades…
… moreThe lady behind the counter was friendly and made the perfect sub….
The sandwich was fresh and delicious..
The atmosphere was a little dingy as far as the dine in seating area. (It was clean) just needs some newer upgrades…
Chris Ketchum
Went here last night, pulled up workers outside sitting in their car smoking cigarettes. Spent $20 Ordered a Sandwich and fries, fries were rock solid, cold and no type of seasoning at all not even salt. Sandwich was very unseasoned, onions were cold, and hardly any cheese. Absolutely terrible.
… more