Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pellegrino’s Pizza – Shoreham, NY – 99 NY-25A – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-8:00 PM; Shop address is 99 NY-25A, Shoreham, NY 1178699 NY-25A, Shoreham, NY 11786; (631) 615-7407 · order on the app we prefer.
Pellegrino Pizza – Shoreham, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Pellegrino Specialty Pizza · Italian Salad Pizza · $30.99 · Buffalo Chicken Pizza · $32.99 · Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza · $32.99 · Sauteed Vegetable Pizza.
Pellegrino’s Pizza (@pellegrinospizza) · Shoreham, NY – Instagram
Established 1992. Eastern Suffolk’s finest gourmet pizza. We guarantee it. · Fresh, hot and ready for the dinner rush. Let us cook tonight, you’ll love it, we …
Reviews
Lisa Lichelle
⚡Lisa – UPDATE- 10 ⭐ The box, the pizza, the box, the pizza, THE BOX, THE PIZZA!!! OMG They got a new Holiday Box! Bravo! The Sicilian pizza slice OMG! Heaven in my mouth! You know, That’s how it’s Done! Pelligrino’s Pelligrino’s ✨ The Best! – Lisa Lichelle ✨
⚡ Lisa – Update! Pellegrino’s has set the new standard in excellence. I just had the best Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice on the East Coast. Yeah yeah, I have had pizza up and down the East Coast from Canada, NY to FL. It was the best pizza ever. I had to pull over, look at it and take pictures of it What! Mannnn Bravo to The Pizza Makers there. WOW! They have set the new 5 Star standard. I might take some other places stars back one, after That lol. frfr And Awesome service too. I got my slice while they were finishing up my Delivery order.
Bravo, Bravo and Bravissimo
10 Star ⭐
– Lisa Lichelle ✨
⚡ Lisa – Ahhh Pellegrino’s ! Great Service. The friendliest staff. Their customers love them. Quick, efficient, always hot, right off the press. Way to Be!
– Lisa Lichelle
… more⚡ Lisa – Update! Pellegrino’s has set the new standard in excellence. I just had the best Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice on the East Coast. Yeah yeah, I have had pizza up and down the East Coast from Canada, NY to FL. It was the best pizza ever. I had to pull over, look at it and take pictures of it What! Mannnn Bravo to The Pizza Makers there. WOW! They have set the new 5 Star standard. I might take some other places stars back one, after That lol. frfr And Awesome service too. I got my slice while they were finishing up my Delivery order.
Bravo, Bravo and Bravissimo
10 Star ⭐
– Lisa Lichelle ✨
⚡ Lisa – Ahhh Pellegrino’s ! Great Service. The friendliest staff. Their customers love them. Quick, efficient, always hot, right off the press. Way to Be!
– Lisa Lichelle
Matthew Danowski
I recently had my Army Reserve unit relocated out east and thought I wouldn’t find decent pizza here—turns out, I was completely wrong. The pizza is a solid 10/10.
I stopped in wearing my uniform with three other soldiers, and to our surprise, the owner or manager generously picked up our entire check. He didn’t have to do that, but it truly meant a lot. Hats off to you, sir!
The next day, I came back and ordered the same thing—because when the food and service are that good, you can’t stay away. Highly recommend this place!
… moreI stopped in wearing my uniform with three other soldiers, and to our surprise, the owner or manager generously picked up our entire check. He didn’t have to do that, but it truly meant a lot. Hats off to you, sir!
The next day, I came back and ordered the same thing—because when the food and service are that good, you can’t stay away. Highly recommend this place!
Ilayna Kootz
Me and my family have been long-term customers and I was quite upset at the customer service and the quality one specific day. I had called, and spoke with David. I explained to him what was going on not only did he make it right but his customer service was excellent. Because of him me and my family will continue to go to the place that we love. Great food great customer service. I would recommend this pizza place.
… moreColin
Pellegrino’s Pizza is a culinary delight that stands out for its commitment to quality and flavor. From the perfectly crisp crust to the rich, savory sauce and the generous toppings, every bite is a testament to their dedication. Beyond pizza, their menu boasts an array of delicious dishes, each crafted with the same variety of flavors. On top of that the workers there are the best people you will ever meet! Pellegrino’s consistently delivers a satisfying and memorable dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
… moreAnenst
I ordered a pie from there it came very floppy and thin the whole pie was falling apart, I called back to report the problem and the lady was very rude after giving them a great tip. Do not order from here it’s the worst place around.
… moreAbbe Shapiro
I tried the MVP slice today, and it was the best pizza I’ve ever had!
… moreJoseph
Staff were amazing, food was spectacular. It was everything and more you could ask for out of a pizza place. Definitely recommend the margarita slice, it was amazing
… moreCassidy Schultz
First and foremost. The service, which has me convinced that I will be making this my designated pizza shop moving forward. Cynthia delivered THE BEST service ever. Greeted me with kindness and was an absolute sweetheart. Everyone else is so great and nice. Couldn’t have asked for a better team to serve food and make customers feel welcomed.
Second. The food is 10/10. Love their pizza, deserts, especially their fried Oreos!!!
And finally the overall atmosphere of the place is so welcoming and gives off this “mom and pop pizza place” vibe.
Just overall the best pizza place in the area!
… moreSecond. The food is 10/10. Love their pizza, deserts, especially their fried Oreos!!!
And finally the overall atmosphere of the place is so welcoming and gives off this “mom and pop pizza place” vibe.
Just overall the best pizza place in the area!
Matty Stallone
This pizza is amazing the Sicilian is outstanding and has the perfect amount of cheese and sauce. If your in shoreham for fun and are hungry I highly recommend pellegrinos pizza.
… moreSophia Jarvis
Grandma pie is delicious! Sweet tomatoes & bigger size than most pizza places!
Edit: BEST GRANDMA SICILIAN ON THE ISLAND
… moreEdit: BEST GRANDMA SICILIAN ON THE ISLAND