Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Enduring eatery supplying American diner standards, plus all-day breakfast, in old-school digs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7727 W Greenfield Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53214
Phone: (414) 774-4828
Website: https://pegasusrestaurantmke.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Pegasus Restaurant – Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner …
contact us. Pegasus Restaurant 7727 W Greenfield Ave Milwaukee, WI 53214 · (414) 774-4828. hours. Daily 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM. about. Home · Menu · Soups · Specials …
Menu – Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner – Milwaukee, WI
Club sandwiches · Chicken Cordon Bleu $15. A grilled chicken breast topped with deli sliced ham and melted Mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted bun. · Monterey …
Pegasus Restaurant | West Allis WI – Facebook
Pegasus Restaurant, West Allis. 589 likes · 44 talking about this · 1446 were here. Your local Family Diner West Allis, WI Breakfast • Lunch •…
Reviews
Basel Safi
Here we go again—another restaurant, another mission (this time, fueled by hunger and mild indecision). And let me tell you, this place doesn’t do things small. We’re talking massive: acres of seating, a parking lot that could host a small festival, and enough room to lose your group twice before finding them again near the pancake station.
But size isn’t the real story—it’s the people. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I’d stumbled into a hospitality convention. The host greeted me like an old friend, servers zipped by with cheerful check-ins, and even the bussers offered a nod and a smile. I stood there for maybe 90 seconds—just long enough to scan the room for my crew—and two different staff members swooped in to ask if I needed help. That’s not just attentive; that’s next-level “we’ve got your back” energy.
I even had a quick chat with the GM, Yanny—genuine, polished, and clearly proud of his spot (as he should be).
Now, onto the main event: the avocado toast. And not just any avocado toast—this was a revelation. Thick-cut sourdough, toasted to golden perfection, slathered with creamy avocado, crumbled feta, and crowned with two sunny-side-up eggs. (Full disclosure: I’m usually an over-easy loyalist, so I braced myself… but the yolk here? Silky, rich, and it melted right into the mix like it was born to be there.)
The only tweak I’d make next time? Skip the fresh tomatoes—they’re not my thing. If they’d been sun-dried? Maybe we’d be besties. But honestly, that’s a personal quirk, not a flaw in the dish.
What really sent it over the edge was the finishing touch: a generous sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning and a delicate drizzle of balsamic. That combo? Bold, balanced, and borderline addictive. It’s the kind of flavor alchemy that makes you side-eye every other avocado toast you’ve ever had.
And the menu? Huge. Like, “you could bring your entire book club, your yoga instructor, and your skeptical uncle who only eats meat” huge. Whether you’re flying solo or rolling deep, they’ve got space, options, and service that makes you feel seen.
Verdict? This place nails the trifecta: scale without soullessness, flavor with finesse, and service that actually *sees* you. I’ll be back—tomatoes or not.
… moreBut size isn’t the real story—it’s the people. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I’d stumbled into a hospitality convention. The host greeted me like an old friend, servers zipped by with cheerful check-ins, and even the bussers offered a nod and a smile. I stood there for maybe 90 seconds—just long enough to scan the room for my crew—and two different staff members swooped in to ask if I needed help. That’s not just attentive; that’s next-level “we’ve got your back” energy.
I even had a quick chat with the GM, Yanny—genuine, polished, and clearly proud of his spot (as he should be).
Now, onto the main event: the avocado toast. And not just any avocado toast—this was a revelation. Thick-cut sourdough, toasted to golden perfection, slathered with creamy avocado, crumbled feta, and crowned with two sunny-side-up eggs. (Full disclosure: I’m usually an over-easy loyalist, so I braced myself… but the yolk here? Silky, rich, and it melted right into the mix like it was born to be there.)
The only tweak I’d make next time? Skip the fresh tomatoes—they’re not my thing. If they’d been sun-dried? Maybe we’d be besties. But honestly, that’s a personal quirk, not a flaw in the dish.
What really sent it over the edge was the finishing touch: a generous sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning and a delicate drizzle of balsamic. That combo? Bold, balanced, and borderline addictive. It’s the kind of flavor alchemy that makes you side-eye every other avocado toast you’ve ever had.
And the menu? Huge. Like, “you could bring your entire book club, your yoga instructor, and your skeptical uncle who only eats meat” huge. Whether you’re flying solo or rolling deep, they’ve got space, options, and service that makes you feel seen.
Verdict? This place nails the trifecta: scale without soullessness, flavor with finesse, and service that actually *sees* you. I’ll be back—tomatoes or not.
Charles Moisant
I found the way to have to be delightful the management was very fun the atmosphere was very hearty the food was a little salty for my taste but I think that was more for a senior pallet. I tend not to put salt in any of my food the price was very reasonable I had their gumbo which was a little salt in my opinion their French onion soup which was very salty play cranberry juice mixed with seltzer water and a salad with blue cheese dressing I had eaten at more than enough to bring home leftovers add I ended up finishing up at midnight even though it was still salty I drink a lot of water the reason why I still get five stars for the food is that the place was packed people were enjoying themselves and I think the food was made for the local palate again an excellent fun Greek restaurant
… morerandy quantrell
It’s been years since I’ve eaten there and I must say their food was delicious and the portions were good and the price was right. The problem is today I went and I was so looking forward to some Greek spinach cheese pie. I’ve had it there in the past and it was delicious. Tonight was utterly disgusting. It was like eating a hockey puck with something inside. There was no Delicious flaky crust. And if it had feta cheese, it was disguised so well, I couldn’t find any. It was sealed up around the edges and not good at all. Totally unpleasing to the eye! Being that I live in Waukesha now the best part of the whole meal was the water! Good old Milwaukee water delicious. !!!
… moreRaven Sunkiller
Typical “Greek Diner” style restaurant serving a very broad (and overwhelming) menu from classic Greek dishes, to Mexican, to American, and beyond.
We entered with a party of 10 and they had plenty of room for us – service was prompt and friendly. They kitchen was also on point getting the large order out quickly and bonus points for allowing separate checks for our large group!
I had a “bowl” with tender and tasty chicken, avocado, lettuce , etc. everyone else around me seemed to enjoy their food also.
… moreWe entered with a party of 10 and they had plenty of room for us – service was prompt and friendly. They kitchen was also on point getting the large order out quickly and bonus points for allowing separate checks for our large group!
I had a “bowl” with tender and tasty chicken, avocado, lettuce , etc. everyone else around me seemed to enjoy their food also.
Melinda Gladney
Went with my family for our 51st birthday (twin). Had a great time. Service and food was excellent
Food came hot and fast. They gave us a slice of cake for our day. We had the red velvet. Yummy! I had the spinach pie and gyro meat combo with rice and salad.
… moreFood came hot and fast. They gave us a slice of cake for our day. We had the red velvet. Yummy! I had the spinach pie and gyro meat combo with rice and salad.
James Jackson
The food was great. Pancakes big as your head ..Our waitress was fantastic.. They even have slot machines to get your gamble on.
… moreRobin
Yesterday I was in there I talked with the owner’s son and I gave him a vacuum cleaner worth $450 it’s a sanitair . I bought a $15 meal for a guy that said he was broken homeless because they told me he was then I checked him out and he’s on Social security he tells them he can’t talk and then I hear him outside laughing when we’re having a cigarette and I can hear his laugh voice but you can’t talk so he’s a scammer then I told him I wanted the vacuum cleaner back because I made a bad decision there when I came in to pay my bill it was twice as high and they said I authorized it if this was the last place on earth besides the dollar store I’d go get a can of wieners! My bill was $30 so I said hey since I bought a homeless guy a meal how about giving me a cash discount she said no and since they recommended the homeless guy I put a 20 on that thing I said goodbye!
… moreAlex Edmont
Good location and parking.
Friendly fast service. Food portions are good and filling. Good senior choice’s and price.
The only issue was the wait to pay as the cashier was busy on the phone talking orders.
… moreFriendly fast service. Food portions are good and filling. Good senior choice’s and price.
The only issue was the wait to pay as the cashier was busy on the phone talking orders.
Mike Sylvester
Chicken dumpling very good! Grilled chicken sandwich was good ff ok seemed the oil needed to be changed in fryer southwestern burger also good . The cake looked amazing also u can buy whole cake..
… moreLynn B
I ate at Pegasus tonight. I had beef enchiladas and my favorite soup- cream of chicken rice. Had very attentive and friendly service from Wendy as well as the manager Marty who took our payment. It’s hard to find a combination of excellent service and reasonably priced homemade meals.
… more