Austin Kolomichuk
Stayed in Valpo over the weekend, and ate here. For it being a pizza place I didn’t think the pizza was very good. Not enough sauce for my liking maybe next time order it with extra sauce and I’d like it better. Also tried the onion rings, nothing special but they weren’t bad.
We also ordered the Chicago sandwich, it was poorly cut so it fell apart and we weren’t given silverware so I had to kinda eat it with my hands and was very messy but it was good.
Overall I’d comeback but there’s plenty of other options I’d go to first.
… moreMichael Powell
Excellent! Highly recommend great service and love the pizza and fried banana rings!
… moreVaughn Schoon
My wife and I attended a special gathering at the Sidebar located within Peddler’s Pizza Pub. This venue for an event was one to be experienced that evening. The food was excellent quickly served buffet style and was replenished as needed by a very watchful staff. The two bar bartenders were terrific and are real assets for Peddler’s Pizza Pub. Everyone at the event were more than pleased with this location. I can recommend Peddler’s Pizza Pub without any reservations. Give it a try and decide for yourself if you haven’t been there.
… moreRicardo SN
Review:
The pizza is excellent, with a wide variety of flavors to choose from. You can also create your own pizza by selecting ingredients categorized into dough, sauce, toppings, and cheese type. In addition to pizza, there is a great selection of beers available. Highly recommended!
… moreDavid Williams
I got the fried banana pepper rings and the Philly cheese steak sandwich. The banana peppers where the star of the show! So good I couldn’t even eat much of my sandwich.
The waitress (Riley) did a great job! Very attentive and friendly.
Would definitely recommend everyone give it a try.
… moreChris Smith
Exceptional atmosphere in the downtown historical district of Valparaiso! Featuring live music on Wednesday nights. This place provides high quality pizza at an affordable price. A special place to sit outside during the warmer months. A large bar & family freindly setting make this a great place to share a pizza with family & friends.
… moreTim Dilloway
Great atmosphere. Staff was amazing. It was my friend’s birthday and it was someone else’s birthday and they made it memorable for both of them
… moreRob Berquist
We moved to Valparaiso and tried all pizzerias within delivery distance. Peddlers is solidly the best pizza in Valparaiso. Cracker crust is so good.
After ordering delivery several times, we went in for a drink. Loved the place. Definitely leans towards a more mature crowd. Mostly age 35-50 from our experience and from the music playlist, which is fine. It’s exactly what we were looking for. Great music, but not too loud. Boisterous crowd. Always a fun time. Respectable tap list, but there has been a time or 2 I ordered an IPA that was very obviously old.
… moreMaggie Irwin
First the place was freezing. Second I asked for a small salad and it was huge. Server never came to check on how our food was. Ordered a dessert to go to find out they burnt the first one. Wasn’t told until we asked where it was. Which already 15 minutes since we ordered. Food was okay. Not great. Will not return.
… moreJan Dalton
Food, service and atmosphere was good, not great. Server called me hun and my love. Kinda weird. Valpo downtown was nice.
… more