Ryan Johnson
We are traveling from out of state, staying at the Bomoseen KOA. We had ordered at seven pm, said it’d be ready between 745-8 pm.
Their website said they closed at 8, and so we arrived at 750. We were told it would be about 10 more minutes. Ended up being almost 25 minutes.
Staff was friendly, restaurant looked nice and inviting.
Pizza was a little dough in the middle, under cooked. When you picked up a slice it would fall apart.
We ordered 2 large pizzas, antipasto salad and a fried calzone.
Calzone was great, pizza and small let down to what we are used to. It might be a regional thing, not sure.
… moreChristopher Priest
The pizza is fantastic. The mozzarella sticks or mozzarella logs are one of a kind! Very friendly staff appears to be family owned, and they are very kind. They do get busy, but there is a good reason for that and it is certainly worth the wait…you’re welcome!
… moreDanielle Hazen
I’ve given them enough chances I’m tired of getting hard over cooked pizza. They send salads without all its ingredients and everything else has really sucked.
I get busy nights and staff training but every other order has been absolutely terrible . this order we waited over an hour for and got burnt pizza and now waiting for a new order after calling and complain. This isn’t the first time I’ve had to ask for better food.
I will not be using Paul’s pizza again.
… moreSteve Tessier
I was hungry for a pizza and this restaurant was recommended by The Marble Mansion Inn where was staying. The first thing I noticed was the tidiness and cleanliness of the building.
The pizza is unique, in that the crust reminds you of a fresh piece of baked bread. It is golden brown with just the right crunch. The sauce and toppings are perfect.
The restaurant is family run and the sauce is home made so the crust must be secret too because I have never experienced a crust like it. I see the reviews are high and no wonder.
You got to try this Pizza place!
… morebrad
The pepperoni pizza was phenomenal, and the mozzarella sticks were huge and tasty. Definitely worth the trip from New York
… moremark bessette
Stopped in for lunch on Sunday 9/8
Another reviewer said the pepperoni pizza was great. We agree it was one of the best we have had, the cheesy breadsticks were also great.
Entire place was very clean. Wish they would open one in Colchester!
Will definitely eat there again when in the area
… moreTammie
My boyfriend and I went and had dinner, appetizers were amazing wings and poppers we got calzones, well their anchovies are the absolute worst, i have ever had!! I love anchovies, but I don’t advise those unless you want to eat straight salt, literally we also asked for extra sauce, the waiter asked if she could charge us for them, which wasn’t a problem at all! When we first ordered we both asked for extra sauce and received just 1 small container a peace.. I can still taste the damn anchovies, the brand, quality, I really don’t know but they were awful!!
… moreSusan Brown
Update: after they saw my review the next day. They took a look at my ticket the saw that I was overcharged by mistake (person was new and made a mistake). The owner called and then credited my bank card I used the amount overcharged. This has changed my opinion of going back. Like I said the food was very good.
Although the pizza was good and the turkey sub was pretty good. A large 3 topping pizza and the sub came to $43. This is the reason I won’t be coming back. I’ve never paid so much before anywhere else.
… moreDan Bennett
Staying at Lake Bomoseen Lodge and wanted a quick lunch. Really happy with Paul’s. Got a large pepperoni and large bacon with pineapple. Totally worth it. A lot of pizza places leave the crust as an afterthought but this place nailed it. So good, crunchy and a nice saltiness but not overdone. The sauce was perfect, not too sweet. And the toppings were great. Pepperoni had some nice heat. Bacon and pineapple prepared in nice even portions…not big lazy chunks. Great cheese. If I come back this way I’d definitely grab pizza here again. Just note that Google shows an old menu, so be sure to find the updated one.
… moreLucia Foley
So disappointed with our pizza tonight!! We have always loved Paul’s pizza and never have we had disappointing food from there before; however, tonight was different and we were so shocked to see the condition in which our pizza was delivered – it was very overcooked, dried out and hard as a rock. Thinking positive and hoping the cook was just having a bad night.
… more