Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 604 F St, Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: (707) 442-5800
Website: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menus | Paul’s Live From New York Pizza in CA
Paul’s Live from New York Pizza · 14″ Traditional Cheese Pizza. $19.99 · 18″ Traditional Cheese Pizza. $29.99 · XL Traditional Cheese Pizza. (for Dine-In Orders …
Eureka | Hours + Location | Paul’s Live from New York Pizza
Hours & Location. 604 F St, Eureka, CA 95501 · 707-442-5800 · paulslfnypizza.com. On the corner of 6th St. Monday – Thursday 11:30 am – 8:00 pm.
Pizza restaurant in CA: Paul’s Live from New York Pizza
Come in and try the best pizza in CA!
Reviews
Cody Baxter
This is nice little corner pizza place. A nice view of the surrounding buildings, friendly employees that make the atmosphere feel like going to a friends house, and not to mention the large pizza pieces that are as big as your head. A good place to take the kids or even a lunch date. Located near old town at a convinient corner spot. Look for the miniature statue of liberty in front of the building.
… moreMargaret Harrelson
If youre obsessed with new york style thin crust pizza then Paul’s is the place for you!! Super thin crust but with a great bite and crunch, flavorful and fresh tomato sauce and ewwy gewy cheese that makes your mouth water! 1000000/10!!
… moreJames Bates
Tonight I had dinner at Paul’s Live from NY Pizza in Eureka and it was amazing. I love pizza and try to find a new place every week to try it out and this place is among the top. Great food, great staff, and great service. It is a must if you’re ever in Eureka. It’s so good it deserves a bonus star❤️
… moreJames Jacobson
A walkable distance from the pier, we grabbed a pie and ate by the waterfront. A very good pizza that hit the spot. I enjoyed the cut of the sausage.
… moreLisa Radabaugh
We’ve gotten pizza here a few times. First time was great. But by the 2nd or 3rd time it was subpar for the cost. I get it, it can’t be perfect every time.
The last time we went there we ordered pizzas and specifically got one of the pizzas without pesto because my parents don’t like it. I think we got the margherita pizza. When it showed up , both pizzas had pesto on them and looked like a mess. We called and the guy said “what do you want me to do about it- we are out of basil.” Weird response and we were not irritated by the lack of basil just the addition of pesto without our knowledge.
We asked them what they could do to make it right and he said he could write down our info for a free pizza next time we ordered. Not a great option but not the worst.
Fast forward a month or so and we call in for our free pizza. No record of anything related to us and no resolution offered.
It wasn’t the mistake that will keep our business away it is the service and carelessness of the employees. Please do better or train better.
… moreThe last time we went there we ordered pizzas and specifically got one of the pizzas without pesto because my parents don’t like it. I think we got the margherita pizza. When it showed up , both pizzas had pesto on them and looked like a mess. We called and the guy said “what do you want me to do about it- we are out of basil.” Weird response and we were not irritated by the lack of basil just the addition of pesto without our knowledge.
We asked them what they could do to make it right and he said he could write down our info for a free pizza next time we ordered. Not a great option but not the worst.
Fast forward a month or so and we call in for our free pizza. No record of anything related to us and no resolution offered.
It wasn’t the mistake that will keep our business away it is the service and carelessness of the employees. Please do better or train better.
Saalav C
Huge slices of pizza. The BEST I’ve had in a long time. Good old fashion NY pizza and the different varieties make it hard to decide which. I got the godfather it was SO DELICIOUS… FULL OF FLAVOR, SO FRESH all around YUMMY! I ordered 2 and had to bring home most of the 2nd. Highly recommend this place. Beers, DELICIOUS Salads Large Drink choices. 7 tvs with something different on each one. A must go to if in Eureka. Stop by & enjoy the hospitality Coast Side in Humboldt! ❤️ ❤️
… moreShon and Jess Thornburg
Easily the best pizza in town. Probably the best pizza in the region! Wings are amazing too!!
… moreDavid Wolins
I’m a pizza snob and get arguably the best pizza dough from my local pizzeria Napoli’s in Vallejo.
Completely different pizza being NY style. Very thin crust made with excellent ingredients. Dough seemed a little bland needing a little more salt.
Toppings were generous. Pesto was bland
Marinara was good but coul have used some herbs to raise the flavor.
Service was outstanding and friendly.
… moreCompletely different pizza being NY style. Very thin crust made with excellent ingredients. Dough seemed a little bland needing a little more salt.
Toppings were generous. Pesto was bland
Marinara was good but coul have used some herbs to raise the flavor.
Service was outstanding and friendly.
James Hughes
We ordered a pepperoni pizza for to go. It was ready rather quickly which was impressive for how good it was. They have huge slices of pizza, thin and cooked well. Sauce tastes great. The price wasn’t bad at all for what we got. We will definitely be back when we are back in the area.
… moreChris Dellis
Love the large pieces of pizza. I really dig the sauce and ample cheese. I could have used a little more pepperoni though. The vibe is chill but bustling with busyness. Lots too do in immediate area. Quick walk to anywhere in old town!
… more