Chris Blaylock
WOW! Felt like we were in New York! We were in town for a swim meet for 3 days…and ate here twice because we could not get enough of the sauce that came with the calzone and stromboli!!! Absolutely the best sauce we’ve ever had, hands down! Then we had the cheesecake and a lobster tail…made the meal even more amazing. But what put them over the top was how we felt like family here! Love these guys!
… moreAna R
I have been eating here since they opened, always had great food but not today.
Ordered a love and artichoke whole pie, like I always do…but today they pureed the olives and placed piles of pureed olives in gloopy masses . It makes the pizza extremely salty. It’s inedible. My husband had to drive a whole hour to get it and we spent $79 on two whole pies. I can no longer recommend Pasquale’s.
… moreClarissa Rice
Excited to share a Rochester favorite with out-of-town friends. Pizza did not disappoint! Service was top notch. After a minor mix up with our order, we called in to pick up the missing item. There was some confusion, but once Rafael stepped in, we were taken care of wonderfully! He went above and beyond and sent our guests with fresh bread, too! Highly recommend the cannoli!! Made a lasting impression on all of us and we’re excited to return:)
… moreKirby Way
Ordered a slice of dine in pizza, sauce and cheese were good but the bottom and crust was quite burnt and cracker-like. The biggest disappointment was the to-go dessert I purchased from them. I opened it up the next day and the top was moldy. Very disappointed.
… moreSusan Lundberg
The best pizza, hands down, I’ve ever had. We each did a slice of “salad pizza” for lunch and took a piece home because we underestimated how much food we would get. Service was awesome, and we did some shopping afterwards in their food store. This will now be my go-to pizza when I’m in Rochester. ❤️
… moreLinda Blaskowski
Top notch restaurant! Friendly, helpful as well as best Italian food I’ve had in a long time! Definitely will be back next time I’m in Rochester! Highly recommend this restaurant
… moreJill Fontaine
BEST pizza in Rochester, hands down. We’ve been there 3 times now and each time the food is consistently good and service is 10/10. Love that you can get a slice, a to-go salad or a full fresh made pizza. Oh and there’s ice cream and desserts too! The marketplace has a ton of great staples for your pantry if you’re looking for some specific items. We’ve never been disappointed. Highly recommend.
… moreRobert Kolbe
The pizza was great The service was friendly and the atmosphere was very relaxed. If I lived in Rochester I’d eat there way too often!
… moreEmanuela Santoro
As an Italian living here in Rochester, I can honestly say this place made me feel at home. The food is authentic, fresh, and full of the flavors I grew up with. Every bite reminded me of Italy – from the quality of the ingredients to the way they are prepared. A wonderful spot for anyone looking for real Italian pizza, and more!
… moreJames Pike
For me, a NY transplant from an Italian family, this is the best pizza I’ve had in my 11 years in Minnesota. We found this place about 6 months ago and were blown away. The traditional NY slices taste exactly like they do back home. I stopped back Tuesday on my way down to LaCrosse and it was the same experience. This time I ordered a slice of Sicilian and a NY-style. Both were delicious! I liked the crispiness of the Sicilian especially. If you’re tired of Midwestern pizza and are looking for authentic East Coast pizza, Pasquale’s is worth drive from just about anywhere in the state. I also had a sfogliatelle (not pictured), which Imd never had before, that was very good even though citrus isn’t my favorite. I particularly like the crunch of the pastry.
My only critiques are that I found the price for slices a little high ($7 for the Sicilian if I remember) and I would like the NY to be maybe a little crispier, but it’s still delicious and highly recommended.
… more