Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Paradise Pizza, serving the best pizza in Cape Coral for over 23 years! We craft mouthwatering pizzas with fresh, high-quality ingredients and authentic Italian recipes. From classic Margherita to bold custom creations, every bite is a slice of paradise. Enjoy our family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for gatherings, or opt for convenient takeout and delivery. We also offer the best Italian catering for your special events. Located in the heart of Cape Coral, we’re proud to serve our community with passion. Savor delicious appetizers, salads, and pastas alongside our signature pizzas. Visit Paradise Pizza today for an unforgettable dining experience that’s been a local favorite since 2002! Craving the best? Call or order online
Low-key, sit-down pizza parlor boasting NYC-style pies plus pasta dishes, salads & sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 842 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL 33904
Phone: (239) 945-1555
Website: https://paradisepizzafl.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spotapps.co
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Paradise Pizza – Cape Coral, FL
Serving Cape Coral for over 23 years, Paradise Pizza in Cape Coral, Florida serves the highest quality Italian Specialties around!
Paradise Pizza – Cape Coral, FL – 842 Lafayette St – Hours, Menu …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Paradise Pizza in Cape Coral, FL. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Paradise Pizza 842 Lafayette St – Order Online
Paradise Pizza 842 Lafayette St. 842 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 842 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL. Schedule your order for later.
Reviews
Joel Sanchez
By far one of the best pizzas I’ve had. Couple of weeks ago I went in to dine with the family but was not able to. I bought a slice on the way out which I was excited about because not many places will sell by the slice. Two slices is all it took for me to go back and try a whole pizza. We were not disappointed and we are excited to try the rest of the menu items. If you are in the area or not stop by you will not be disappointed
… moreMelissa
The antipasto salad fed two of us and we had the 20 inch pizza half pepperoni and have vegi it was perfect. The place was very busy but we sat and relaxed and chat. Pizza crust was delicious and thin like a NY/ NJ style. Sauce perfect. It’s a casual atmosphere, great for a simple night out or quick bite. Next visit I am definitely trying the chicken Parm or Eggplant. Portions were huge from what I saw being served to others. We will be back! Staff works very hard. Take care of them. 🙂
… moreJacki
The best rigatoni alla vodka I’ve ever had. The pizza was perfectly cooked and the espresso martini was top notch! Definitely will be back.
… moreBruce InCharlotte
Mom and I popped into Paradise Pizza around 5:30, when the restaurant was only half full, and were immediately greeted by the warm smell of garlic knots baking in the oven. By 6:15, nearly every table had filled, a clear sign of how popular this spot is with locals. Our waitress welcomed us warmly, and service started off on the right foot with my beer arriving quickly.
Mom, true to form, customized her meal extensively, and when it came out, every detail was exactly as she had requested. Truly perfection, and a testament to the kitchen’s attention to detail.
I chose the antipasto salad as my main dish, and it was far beyond the usual token lettuce with a few toppings. This was a hearty plate, about 80% “stuff” and only 20% fresh lettuce base. Sliced meats, provolone, pickled carrots, pickled cauliflower, pepperoncini, and plenty of cheese made it a flavorful, satisfying meal. Simply delicious.
We also noticed they offer lunch specials, which is a nice touch. Mom already has plans to return with her friend this week for the two slices lunch. And someone ordered a large pie that went past us – oh my goodness, that looked tremendous!
Paradise Pizza delivered on atmosphere, service, and food quality, making it a place worth revisiting whether you’re in the mood for a customized dinner, a hearty salad, or a classic pizza.
… moreMom, true to form, customized her meal extensively, and when it came out, every detail was exactly as she had requested. Truly perfection, and a testament to the kitchen’s attention to detail.
I chose the antipasto salad as my main dish, and it was far beyond the usual token lettuce with a few toppings. This was a hearty plate, about 80% “stuff” and only 20% fresh lettuce base. Sliced meats, provolone, pickled carrots, pickled cauliflower, pepperoncini, and plenty of cheese made it a flavorful, satisfying meal. Simply delicious.
We also noticed they offer lunch specials, which is a nice touch. Mom already has plans to return with her friend this week for the two slices lunch. And someone ordered a large pie that went past us – oh my goodness, that looked tremendous!
Paradise Pizza delivered on atmosphere, service, and food quality, making it a place worth revisiting whether you’re in the mood for a customized dinner, a hearty salad, or a classic pizza.
Jorge Salinas
Any other Pizza I eat late will leave my stomach hurting the next day.. this pizza is wonderful and you can tell that it is made fresh!! with great ingredients.. I warn you they are busy 35 to 45 min wait depending on the time if day.. never sat down and ate to crowded for my scene.. but I’m just an introvert by nature… with that being said they are doing their best and you can tell that they are doing their best such wonderful Pizza!! Everyone is smiling except for the one slinging those pies!! But still attentive and thoughtful to people waiting to order.. I warn you!! it’s very greasy!! it just drips off!! some people dislike that I say it adds to the authenticity!!! And not leave you bubble gut the next day!!! Wonderful! Some may find the price somewhat high in price but an 18 dollar large pizza does are family justice filling us up compare to dominos 25$ or more! sure you get the cinnamon bread stick but this is way better for your health! and still very filling! truly a miracle. Love you guys keep up the hard work!
… morethomas vanglahn
Being a local dasher I have had the opportunity to try most if not all the different pizza places around the Cape, and there sure are a lot. Out of all of them those Paradise has the best overall experience. The food is incredible, from the pizza, which you can get by the slice, to the sandwiches and plate dinners. Everything hits the mark. The pricing is very fair especially the lunch menu items. Service is out of this world, everyone in that building is so nice and inviting you get nothing but good vibes. Brooke making pizzas, Emanuel and David in the kitchen and Jaime and Heather in the front. No matter how busy it is they are. They always make the time to say hi and always greet with smiles. Bottom line if you want great food at a good prices with an amazing atmosphere and all around good vibes. Make this place your go to, it’s worth it.
… moreChandra Williams
Amazing food. We are from out of town and we have never had pasta this good before. We ordered a large cheese pizza for the kids and we got the Cajun chicken pasta and spaghetti for my husband and I. Portions were top notch. Pasta was so good. Can’t say enough! Service was excellent as well!
… moreJenn Rae
Back to being a 5 star pizza joint. They went out of their way to search for our information after this review. They called, apologized and credited our account. It wasn’t necessary but greatly appreciated. We have been eating there for many years, both inside and take out. We’ve had everything from garlic knots, to broasted chicken to penne ala vodka and their best pizza sweet meats. Thank you Paradise for going out of your way to correct this mistake.
Paradise Pizza is normally a 5 star pizza joint. What happened to my meatball hero? Where is the paper to protect the cheese? Have you ever tried pulling cheese off tinfoil? I even paid for extra cheese on top. The calzone my partner had was delicious, this hero was a soggy mess.
… moreParadise Pizza is normally a 5 star pizza joint. What happened to my meatball hero? Where is the paper to protect the cheese? Have you ever tried pulling cheese off tinfoil? I even paid for extra cheese on top. The calzone my partner had was delicious, this hero was a soggy mess.
Aaron
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️First time trying Paradise Pizza and I was impressed. The pizza slices were hot, fresh, and full of flavor, with a perfectly crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The slices were generous in size and very filling. The staff was friendly and made the experience even better. Definitely a great first impression I’ll be back for more slices!
… moreGreg Longfield
First time ordering from Paradise Pizza today. We got 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage and some garlic rolls. The pizza and the rolls were great. Rolls were not drenched in butter like some other places. New York style pizza was good. Ordering was easy on their app. Set a reminder on my phone referencing traffic so knew when to leave. Will be back
… more