LEA JAMES
Finally! A local place to get excellent pizza. We had the “hundred pounder”The crust was properly chewy and flavorful- The sauce was not sweet ( I hate sweet sauce)! It was covered in 100 pepperoni,no lie, and the cheese was excellent (a pound of it)
The man who answered the phone was courteous and friendly. The pickup was easy at the window. We felt we got a good value for our money.
… moreSherri Burrows
Omg, my absolute favorite place. First time Saturday, February 20, 2026. Ordered the Hero sub on white bread. It was the best sub I’ve had in years!!! The bread was so soft, and it tasted soooo good, I had to Make myself stop at half of it, so I could save the other half for Sunday. I will definitely be going back again and again. Extremely highly recommended.
… moreRachel Scott
The cheese bread is SO good! Pizza tastes great, they get busy often, so parking can be rough if you are getting out to grab the pizza. They have a drive through, so no need to park every time. There is no seating/dining area.
… moreSue Urban
This was my first visit, but it won’t be my last. Ordered 3 personal pizzas for lunch to visit friends in Blue Ridge. I placed the order before I left Tellico Plains TN and asked to have the ready in 90 minutes. My order was ready, hot, and fresh! Easy drive thru pickup with super friendly service! Sorry no photos as we were all hungry!
… moreKaris Colloton
Papas has our absolute favorite pizza! We’ve ordered a couple pizzas for home, as well as more than a dozen at a time for parties. Excellent quality everytime. If there are every any leftovers,(rarely) its also great cold for breakfast! Highly recommend Papa’s Pizza to go in McCaysville!
… moreRyan Savage
If you’re looking for something to hit the spot late night besides that girl you were out with, this is definitely next in line. Excellent
… moreDavid Black
Papa’s Pizza in McCaysville, its great it is open 7 days a week for take out, where other places in the area are not open every day. Food has always been good here and not very expensive, employee’s have always been friendly, pizza is good but not favorite, subs and garlic bread are real good, chicken wings may be small but tasty real good, highly recommend giving them a try.
… moreZero Lashley
A phenomenal pizza for under $20 in 2026.
Service: …
… moreNicole Wagner
We stayed in Ellijay our last trip and made the 35 minute drive to the McCaysvilles papa’s pizza! It’s the best one! The friendliest staff. Get the 100lb pizza 😉 it’s delicious!
… moreCollene Wester
This was the second time I have visited Papa’s Pizza and it was delicious! We had a Veggie Pizza and the Piggy Sticks both tasted great.
… more