Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 507 Sunset Dr, Hamburg, NY 14075
Phone: (716) 646-6655
Website: https://www.papaspizzaoven.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papas Pizza | ‘Cause Papa Loves Ya
Papas Pizza Hamburg. 507 Sunset Dr Hamburg, New York 14075. (716) 646-6655 … 1537 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224. (716) 671-8555. Order Papas @ Legacy.
Papa’s Pizza Hamburg – Order Online
Papa’s Pizza Oven. Papa’s Pizza Oven. 0. Sign in. Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Papa’s Pizza Hamburg. 507 Sunset Drive, Hamburg, NY. Change location.
Papa’s Pizza Oven in Hamburg, NY review – Facebook
Papa’s Pizza Oven in Hamburg NY. First time trying it. Crust is delicious and was the just the right thickness. It was perfectly cooked too.
Reviews
Nicole Marry
They didn’t have any cucumbers or pickle. Gave me mustard packets instead of putting it on the sandwich bec that was another thing they didn’t have. The meat was extremely thick the tomatoes were sliced extremely thin and didn’t even take up the whole sandwich. They gave me shredded cheese how do they not have sliced cheese for being a pizza and sub shop they are not up to my standards
… moreBert Taylor
Absolutely amazing pizza. Huge slices. Sweet sauce. Crispy crust a ton of cheese. Definitely my go to when I’m in Hamburg .
… moreJack Millson
Very similar style to Bocce Club in the city, but executed upon in a superior way. Three types of red sauce, sweet, standard, and a mix. The sweet is quite sweet so only go for that if you want it, but the mix is a great blend. Excellent cheese caramelization without straying into burned territory. Good use of local cup and char pepperoni. Clear best pizza in the Hamburg/Blasdell area
… moreGin Hostetler
Only go to buffalo once and a while so i like to stop to try new places was craving pizza This place was absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere and the employees were soo good to us! Not to mention the bathrooms were so clean and smelled good! Also you can tell the employees have fun while they are working! This was so refreshing to see. Food was delicious!
… moreM H
No longer a fan. The last 3 or 4 times we ordered a pizza the quality was way down. Hardly any cheese even though we order double cheese. The pies weren’t cooked long enough so no cup and char. And employees smoking right outside the entrance is a turn off. Won’t be back.
… moreDerrick
Ordered from the Hamburg location, Steak and 5 cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, breadsticks, and hot garlic parm wings.
Steak pizza: undercooked dough, very greasy flavor overall that took away from the medley of cheeses, steak and veggies. My wife’s slice had a 6in hair baked into the bottom of the slice. 1/5
Cheese & pep pizza: my kids aren’t that picky I mean they eat school lunch pizza and don’t complain, but they both said this ain’t it. The pep is not cup and char enough. Also if you’re going to make your pizza look like my favorite slice of all time (Picasso’s) you better bring your A game and this was the D game. 1/5
Hot garlic parm wings: very good sauce and saucy. Peppercorn ranch??? grrr. I busted out my emergency tub of Rooties to save the day. The wing size was a bit inconsistent. 2.5/5 (with standard Kens blue cheese would’ve been a 4/5)
Breadsticks: look special and fluffy, but this wasn’t pizza dough we don’t believe but besides the point it was notably very greasy somehow. 0/5
Experience: The woman running it were nice but when I ordered after scouting out the menu I asked for half mushroom on the steak pizza and they said we have to add that and I was a little confused because I remember there being “light mushroom” on the menu so either way I accepted adding mushrooms to half. When I arrived on their sign it states light mushrooms lol not the biggest deal but maybe look up at the menu when someone questions the menu. They said 35mins and I arrived maybe in 40-45mins and the pizza was not done but only waited a few short minutes, this was convenient enough for me. The 1 worker stepped out to smoke out front which isn’t…terrible but…idk? When you’re thinking of eating food hand served by somehow you just hope your foods touch by saints and angels! (Satire) but when we discovered a hair baked into the bottom of our slice it was a bit extra disturbing is all I can say. Even with all of that I still would give the service a 4 out of 5 because I’m a blue collar worker and don’t need angels and saints to prepare my food lol. Lastly the atmosphere is a 3 out of 5 due to circumstances of the place being the size of a closet and not the prettiest place inside and out.
… moreSteak pizza: undercooked dough, very greasy flavor overall that took away from the medley of cheeses, steak and veggies. My wife’s slice had a 6in hair baked into the bottom of the slice. 1/5
Cheese & pep pizza: my kids aren’t that picky I mean they eat school lunch pizza and don’t complain, but they both said this ain’t it. The pep is not cup and char enough. Also if you’re going to make your pizza look like my favorite slice of all time (Picasso’s) you better bring your A game and this was the D game. 1/5
Hot garlic parm wings: very good sauce and saucy. Peppercorn ranch??? grrr. I busted out my emergency tub of Rooties to save the day. The wing size was a bit inconsistent. 2.5/5 (with standard Kens blue cheese would’ve been a 4/5)
Breadsticks: look special and fluffy, but this wasn’t pizza dough we don’t believe but besides the point it was notably very greasy somehow. 0/5
Experience: The woman running it were nice but when I ordered after scouting out the menu I asked for half mushroom on the steak pizza and they said we have to add that and I was a little confused because I remember there being “light mushroom” on the menu so either way I accepted adding mushrooms to half. When I arrived on their sign it states light mushrooms lol not the biggest deal but maybe look up at the menu when someone questions the menu. They said 35mins and I arrived maybe in 40-45mins and the pizza was not done but only waited a few short minutes, this was convenient enough for me. The 1 worker stepped out to smoke out front which isn’t…terrible but…idk? When you’re thinking of eating food hand served by somehow you just hope your foods touch by saints and angels! (Satire) but when we discovered a hair baked into the bottom of our slice it was a bit extra disturbing is all I can say. Even with all of that I still would give the service a 4 out of 5 because I’m a blue collar worker and don’t need angels and saints to prepare my food lol. Lastly the atmosphere is a 3 out of 5 due to circumstances of the place being the size of a closet and not the prettiest place inside and out.
Michelle Strong
I drove 20 minutes to Papa’s in Hamburg due to the support they give to special needs families. The food was ready, hot and delicious!
… morePaul DeLuca
I was interested in trying this place because I heard they used sweeter sauce. They was about the only thing I liked… The wings came with RANCH, and no celery or carrots. I had requested saucy wings and got the exact opposite! Pizza kind of reminded me of Imperial which I love, but to me this wasn’t worth the drive here.
… moreNoor M
Amazing service. We had to take a break from Toronto to Maryland and tried their Pizza. Pizza was very delicious and it was more than enough for the whole family of 7. We asked for their Sheet Pizza with cheese only. Their customer service was amazing. Though the wait time was usual but still they apologized and gave us 2 complementary drinks. Due to the delicious Pizza and extremely nice staff, We stopped on our way back to Toronto again. Definitely recommend this place!!!
… moreTony Fiala
Good wings! The pizza looked stunning. Square pie, quality toppings. Pepperoni looked fresh cut. Sauce was simple but tasty as hell. In my opinion it could have stayed in the oven longer. The cheese was crusted over the edges, but the undercarriage was soft as a sponge. All I can say is, it felt like a letdown and unfinished, but my family devoured it because it was still tasty as hell.
… more