Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 11 AM–10 PM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 554 Locust St, Middletown, IN 47356
Phone: (765) 354-9880
Website: http://www.papapepperonipizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza – Middletown
Join Papa’s VIP Loyalty Rewards. To receive your special gift and become a VIP Member at Papa Pepperoni’s, simply click the link and complete the activation …
PIZZAS – Middletown
PAPA PEPPERONI’S SPECIALTY PIZZAS. Chicken (counts as 2), Bacon, Black Olives, Extra Cheese, Feta Cheese, Fresh Spinach, Green Peppers, Ground Beef, Ham, …
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza | Middletown IN – Facebook
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza, Middletown, Indiana. 2169 likes · 68 talking about this · 350 were here. Small town pizzeria with a big city taste. Great…
Reviews
Alex Sizemore
Great variety of options. We built our own. Our food came out quickly, correctly and served to our table.
… moreWhitney
I can only speak on what we have tried so far but the pizza supper good, ham and cheese sub great, steak n cheese little bit of fatty pieces, nachos excellent, garlic knots stop notch, spaghetti and Meatballs were ok they gave you a large portion but not a lot of taste, also didn’t get a salad with it like we were supose to. The place is so clean inside they have great rewards with the app. And the employees are very nice.
… moreStefanie Miller
Chose delivery as option. Out of all the food the garlic cheese bread was the best even though it had to be brought back because it was left behind when food was first delivered along with cups of cheese. My half of a deluxe sub was horrible!! The bread was so soggy from over abundance of pizza sauce that it fell apart as soon as I picked it up. Hardly any cheese at all. Didn’t have really anything on it but a bunch of sauce and green peppers. Was not even worth eating. Won’t be ordering anything else from there. Not worth the money you fork out. Also it just seemed way to quickly that the order showed up the first time. I ordered a lil after 5:10 pm. Estimated time of arrival was 5:55pm. All of a sudden order shows up a little
… moreAlivia Lehman
We did the order ahead and dine in option on line. It was very convenient for our family with toddlers! The garlic knots and cinnamon sticks are fantastic! The pizza is good, we always get the hand tossed, so I can’t speak to the other types of crusts they offer.
… moreSamantha Harry
I love me some Papa Pepperoni’s pizza! I also love supporting local businesses. I know the owners and they should be very proud of their business and the rapport they have built with our community. P.s. I highly recommend the Santa Fe Chicken pizza on thin crust. Two Thumbs up Papa Pepperoni’s, keep up the good work!
… moreSean “Banks” Bennett
If you’ve never been here then you definitely should. They’re chicken, bacon, ranch pizza is the best I’ve ever had. Make sure you get extra everything also. Everything is better with extra cheese, bacon, chicken, and ranch. I promise you won’t be disappointed.
… moreTina Bowsman
The staff and food are nothing short of amazing!!! The portions are unbelievable and it’s VERY affordable. Nick and his crew do everything in their power to ensure you have an excellent experience each and every time. We recently had a post Christmas get together there and for 6 people the entire bill was $100!!! And all six of us took enough food home for another complete meal because it was impossible to eat it all in one setting!! We eat there as often as possible and will continue to do so. I can’t recommend them highly enough!!
… moreThe Mother of Puppies
Their new location is really nice. The food was amazing as usual! We got 10″ Ranchero, a 10″ Chicken Carbonara, and a Deluxe calzone. And pepperoni bread sticks. I’ve never ordered something here that I didn’t like
… moreJason Bliss
Really like the new location friendly fast and very prompt and courteous service and food was perfection we come all the way from Anderson just to get some of the cinnabites which they placed us and very fast service probably one of the best deals in the restaurant industry as far as I’m concerned right now anymore they have the best deals for real small town home cooked food feel with everything they have very great place very highly recommended and I’ve been going there for years now and always getting the the big papa box which is two medium one topping pizzas a large order of breadsticks and a order of cinebikes for $27 you can’t get that anywhere that’s just like unheard of and the food is to die for really great people really knowledgeable courteous service help great place all the way around very highly recommended I can’t say enough about this place to be honest with you I let him sponsor my race car and probably just do it for some food because it’s so good LOL
… moreMidwest Reviews
We have ordered from here many times for carry out and delivery and have nothing bad to say about them. The employees are always friendly and the food is good. The full meal deal is a great deal and feeds our family of 6 easily for a very fair price. It is also always a bonus when we get the opportunity to support small local businesses!
… more