Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 554 Locust St, Middletown, IN 47356
Phone: (765) 354-9880
Website: http://www.papapepperonipizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza
Join Papa’s VIP Loyalty Rewards. To receive your special gift and become a VIP Member at Papa Pepperoni’s, simply click the link and complete the activation …
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza | Middletown IN – Facebook
Pizza by the slice is now available! Your choice of plain cheese or pepperoni only $2.99 for 1/6 of a 16″ pizza. Available all day, every day. No photo …
Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza, 554 Locust St, Middletown, IN 47356, US
Get more information for Papa Pepperoni’s Pizza in Middletown, IN. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Daniel
My wife and I just had a wonderful and delicious meal here. This is our 2nd time in. Everything was great. We had a single slice of pizza each, garlic knots and BBQ wings. I am adding new copies of their menu in this review. Please come and enjoy great food. Many others things you can order.
… moreMelissa Brinduse
Amazing pizza and garlic bread! The most beautiful Calzone I have ever seen! We had the Italian Cheesy Bread as well, but we ate that before I could take a pic. The staff is so friendly and nice!
… moreCourtney Elam
Personal opinion of course… But I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE!! THE PIZZA AND GARLIC KNOTS ARE SPECTACULAR!! AND VERY AFFORDABLE.. YHE SERVICE HAS ALWAYS BEEN TOP NOTCH ALSO!! FAST AND FRIENDLY!! CANT GET ANY BETTER THAN PAPA PEPPERONIS!! JUST SAYING!! ❤️ ❤️
… moreWhitney
I can only speak on what we have tried so far but the pizza supper good, ham and cheese sub great, steak n cheese little bit of fatty pieces, nachos excellent, garlic knots stop notch, spaghetti and Meatballs were ok they gave you a large portion but not a lot of taste, also didn’t get a salad with it like we were supose to. The place is so clean inside they have great rewards with the app. And the employees are very nice.
… moreMichele Pressley
Pepperoni, thin and crispy, extra cheese. That’s, our all-time favourite! Never go wrong with thin and crispy with extra cheese. That aftertaste is just simply unforgettable, it always have you coming back for more!
… moreJeffery Ekstrom
Ordered a 16″ meat lovers and got not a meat lovers… It only had ham and sausage on it for 25 dollars you think I would get what I ordered. Garlic knots where the knot was good bread wise had way to much garlic. Tried this place cause I had a few pieces over a friend’s and the meat lovers was full of meat so I was excited… What a let down. Drive from Anderson but probably won’t do it again spent 55 dollars to be let down.
… moreJoshua Leach
Pizza is good, I really liked the sauce. Breadsticks are good, best part is the cheese sauce though. The sweet tea is excellent. My only negative is one of the guys gave me a to go container with one hand while hold the bathroom cleaning caddy in the other, just after having cleaned both bathrooms. So, yeah they clean the bathrooms but probably should have washed up before touching any food related stuff.
… moreJustin Buck
Everything we have bought from them has been phenomenal! We recommend them all the time to people.
… moreCourtney Elam
I absolutely love this place they have the best garlic knots in the galaxy hands down!! They always have a good staff and their prices are wonderful like definitely affordable for anybody. You Definitely get so so so much more than what you pay for here!!! So thanks for keeping it in budget for me so I can still enjoy my favorite place!!! And the staff is always nice and it’s true.. Papa Pepperoni is absolutely family friendly, within budget and fast. Thanks again
… moreThe Mother of Puppies
Their new location is really nice. The food was amazing as usual! We got 10″ Ranchero, a 10″ Chicken Carbonara, and a Deluxe calzone. And pepperoni bread sticks. I’ve never ordered something here that I didn’t like
… more