Vanessa F.
Overdue review but my family’s first time trying Papa Murphy’s was a couple of months ago. We had Mike’s Honey Hot Pepperoni and Papa’s Favorite (both large). These are so much better than store bought frozen pizza! Depending on what you like I recommend trying either one or both. Btw they load up the toppings! I love the fresh ingredients. Great quality for the cost!
Instructions were straight forward and simple to follow and as you can tell from my pictures and videos they baked great!!
Overall the taste was good! However I like my pizza to be a little more flavorful such as adding oregano, garlic powder, etc. but that wasn’t a problem or deal breaker because I can easily add those at home before bake them.
I also wanted to note since our first experience we’ve tried the XLNY Giant Pepperoni (not pictured).
PRO: It’s pretty large for sure!!
CONS: I baked according to the instructions but it didn’t bake as I expected and lacked the foldability. In addition because it was quite thin it made it a little more challenging to eat than the first two we tried.
Side note…I’m from NY…no shade (my tone is friendly) but it can’t compare to the original, not just Papa Murphy’s but any pizza in Georgia I’ve tried thus far even the restaurant that has “New York” in it’s name IYKYK lol!
All in all, my experience with Papa Murphy’s was good and will purchase from here again and is worth the try!!
… moreShayla White
Went here today round 11am. This was my first time here, I found out about this pizza place on the back of a Kroger’s receipt. Haha, who would have ever guessed that!! I ordered the medium create your own pizza..with ground beef, mozzarella cheese and creamy garlic sauce..which the cashier had suggested when I ask how it is. When I got home, follow the instructions and the pizza was soo good and delicious . If you are in the Fayetteville area definitely check them out. Also, they even have special days where… there’s pizza deals
… moreAlisa Lybbert
Soooo excited to finally have a Papa Murphy’s close by! Their take and bake pizzas are fabulous. We especially love the gourmet vegetarian and the Mediterranean flavors! We have some gluten free eaters, and they’re very happy with the GF crust! I’ve also now tried the dairy-free cheese, and I’m very happy with it. The staff went above and beyond to make sure I avoided both dairy and gluten allergens in one of my pizzas.
Our kids like the classic pepperoni pizza. We get large or family sized for our large family, and eat the leftovers for days!
… moreCorro K
I was excited to come here, we loved this place when we were in North Carolina. The owner & his family were such nice people. We will be visiting a lot more often.
… moreW P
First time trying Papa Murphy’s Pizza. It was well made and fresh and delicious. I will be coming back. Thank you.
… moreSarah Piper
The tuscan chicken & sausage & gourmet vegetarian thin crust is amazing. I love the fresh ingredients & the quality of the food. You need to try this place. None of the other pizza places around here are a fraction as good as their pizza’s.
… moreHeather Heitz
My son and I love this place. The prices are affordable the food is delicious and the owners are amazing! You don’t find many restaurants anymore with the customer service this restaurant provides. We are in love with the five dollar pizzas on Friday’s ❤️
… moreCrissy Boo
When I tell yall this pizza was SO GOOD!! They recently opened up and my boyfriend and I went in. We missed the opening party and were not able to order but they still gave us a FREE pizza to take home. It was a Chicken and Bacon Ranch. We had to bake it at home but no biggie. Came with very easy instructions. Only 10-12 minutes. It was DELICIOUS! They were really kind people. Super great atmosphere. Perfect food addition in Fayetteville. Highly recommend! 10/10! Can’t wait to try more items on the menu.
… moreDaniel Andrews
My experience was excellent. The both pizza’s we ordered were great and the uber driver was great and on time. Thanks for an incredible experience.
… moreMichael Hirsch
As a self-proclaimed NY pizza snob, I can easily say that PM’s giant NY style take-n-bake is the closest I’ve come to a Brooklyn slice south of Jersey. I want to buy pizza from my local NY pizza joints but the consistency is always hit and miss. With PM, I get to control the cook time, and their product is the nearly identical every time I order. If you have $12 and an oven, this is the best pizza you’re going to find.
… more