Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 130 S State St, Hagerman, ID 83332
Phone: (208) 837-6680
Website: http://www.papakelseysofhagerman.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Kelseys of Hagerman Online Ordering
Large Pizzas ; Large Firehouse Chicken$21.99 ; Large Papa Kelsey’s$21.99 ; Large BBQ Chicken Pizza$21.99 ; Large Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza$20.39 ; Large Vegetarian …
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza
Burley, ID 83318 (208) 678-5030. MON-SAT: 9:30am-9pm. SUN: Closed. Order Online. HAGERMAN. 460 S State St, Hagerman, ID 83332 (208) 837-6680. JEROME. 1466 S …
Papa Kelsey’s of Hagerman – Facebook
Papa Kelsey’s of Hagerman. A pleasant family-friendly restaurant which offers delicious pizza and subs on famous bread and crus.
Reviews
Cindi Wall
Had a pepperoni & sausage pizza. Dough was just right, not to thin or to thick. Lots of meat and cheese. Sausage had a little spice to it, not bland and the sauce was very good. Service friendly and the restaurant clean. Will be stopping again on our way to Arizona.
… moreP E
Fantastic pizza, it just seemed to lose heat really fast, or wasn’t kept under a heat lamp. Nothing throwing it in the oven for a few minutes couldn’t fix. It’s still order again in a heartbeat!
… moreErick Bostrom
This is a favorite stop of the family every time we go to Miracle Hot Springs.
They moved in recent months that have kept up the good food and prices.
The kids really like the big scoops of ice cream one is plenty for a child and maybe even to share.
The pizza is pretty good the crust can be a little bit thinner.
The staff is always friendly and very helpful the new location looks very good and kept with the theme of the business we enjoy this stop each time we go to Hagerman for the hot springs in the area.
… moreThey moved in recent months that have kept up the good food and prices.
The kids really like the big scoops of ice cream one is plenty for a child and maybe even to share.
The pizza is pretty good the crust can be a little bit thinner.
The staff is always friendly and very helpful the new location looks very good and kept with the theme of the business we enjoy this stop each time we go to Hagerman for the hot springs in the area.
Dennis Burnaman
My turkey sandwich was sad. Looked like it had been stepped on. Hardly any meat, one tomato slice. The pizza was just not good. Taste like frozen pizza. I have actually had better pizza at chuck e cheese. The smell when you walk in should have been my clue it’s awful
… moreFrances “Fry” Sutton
Love this place! I stop every time I pass through Hagerman. Their subs are awesome! The place is always clean, fast and courteous service. Save room for some ice cream for sure! Will be back!
… moreMrsEnviro
Good spot for pizza or take out. Staff is helpful when placing to go orders
… moreTurner-m
Very clean and friendly atmosphere. Large menu includes soups, burgers, salads plus subs and pizza. The baked beef steak sub was tasty and the potato soup was so good!
… moreTiffany Stoermer
We ordered an All Meat large pizza…. excited to try because it was our first time. It was doughy, bland and all you could taste was bacon. Very disappointed!!!! Won’t try the pizza again but will give one more shot for sandwiches cause limited here……
… moreFinesse Muse
This is our last time going here.
1st time want impressive and this 2nd time was even worse!
Walked in, place seemed clean. The gal at the counter didn’t make eye contact with me the whole time, just keep messing around with the order screen like she was busy playing a game or something.
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and spicy wings.
I checked both before leaving. The pizza had no pepperoni and she said it was under the cheese.
Got home and the pizza had almost no pepperoni on it. Seemed like a cheep way to cut corners, plus it wasn’t hardly cut up and I had to cut the pizza up myself.
The wings had a hair in em, gross.
The 3 girls in the kitchen weren’t wearing their hair up or wearing nets.
The food was bland and shameful.
Might’ve been better off getting a frozen pizza from the store, especially for the price of the garbage we just paid for.
… more1st time want impressive and this 2nd time was even worse!
Walked in, place seemed clean. The gal at the counter didn’t make eye contact with me the whole time, just keep messing around with the order screen like she was busy playing a game or something.
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and spicy wings.
I checked both before leaving. The pizza had no pepperoni and she said it was under the cheese.
Got home and the pizza had almost no pepperoni on it. Seemed like a cheep way to cut corners, plus it wasn’t hardly cut up and I had to cut the pizza up myself.
The wings had a hair in em, gross.
The 3 girls in the kitchen weren’t wearing their hair up or wearing nets.
The food was bland and shameful.
Might’ve been better off getting a frozen pizza from the store, especially for the price of the garbage we just paid for.
RON SCHAEFER
All employees looked happy and were responsive to our requests. Exceptional food and service. Portions are large! Probably will split a meal next time but definitely will visit every single time we go through
… more