Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 6 AM–7 PM |
| Tuesday | 6 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1466 S Lincoln Ave, Jerome, ID 83338
Phone: (208) 420-9819
Website: http://papakelseyssubs.toast.site/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Kelsey’s: Home
Papa Kelsey’s restaurant prepares the best, freshest dough daily … Papa Kelsey’s currently has locations in Idaho, Colorado & Arizona.
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza
Papa Kelsey’s Pizza. … JEROME. 1466 S Lincoln Ave. Jerome, ID 83332 (208) 420-9819 · Order Online. IDAHO FALLS. 2285 E 17th St, Idaho Falls, ID 83404
Papa Kelsey’s
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Twin Falls, ID, Twin Falls, ID, Buhl, ID.
Reviews
Daniel Shepherd
Got a pizza a few days ago. Can’t remember which one it was. It had ham, sausage black olives and mushrooms. I added jalapeños on it. Man that pizza was bomb!!! Highly recommend this pizza joint. 10/10 would visit here again!!!
… moreBelle Monroe
They seem to never be open anymore and now have changed the hours to even less. You’d think they’d be open for meal times and wanting to make $ but dang… for not the best (but only limited options here in jerome) sure would be nice if they actually did business there. We’re now done even attempting. Sucks we’ve even drove to Wendell for pickup orders when they’ve been closed but yeah I believe they’ve had their last chance.
… moreTenToezDowN Movement Prez Coop
I go see my main man Kaden Working The Morning Shift i did chef choice, and he prepared a burrito that was absolutely phenomenal. I went down the street about a couple of miles. I immediately called Kaden then I came back for 2 more excellent burritos and customer service manager material – Coop #TenToezDowN #Movement #highlyrecommended
… moreJoe Cheney
We ordered 4 sandwiches and 1 personal pan pizza last night for delivery. We have all been sick and it was the only thing that sounded like a good idea for our house. We ordered a wrangler, a bacon ranch, a firehouse, and a BLT added pickles. This is where this order goes off the rails we received a whole sub with cheese and just bacon. No lettuce. No tomato and no pickle. I called and the young man who answered the phone met my issues with a lot of silence and ums and uhs His first response was well we don’t sell pickles. Then why is it on the menu as an add on?! He continues to say you ”Well you can bring the sandwich back and we can add lettuce and tomato to it” I then proceeded to lean on him about remaking it and just gave up after my wife said to not worry about it she would just eat what they sent. Papa Kelsey’s has been one of my favorite go tos and have been ecstatic they came to Jerome. Step up the game people and maybe train some of your employees on how to have some customer service skills. Highly disappointed this go round
… moreKevin Emery
If you want a soggy $10+ sandwich this is place to be!
… moreAmber S
Good pizza, salad, and bread. Wait time isn’t too long after ordering. It’s nice to have something in Jerome that isn’t Domino’s or Pizza Hut.
… moreRandy Reed
They charge $8 for this sad this pathetic so called sub.
… moreJake P
Owner hid my review about him dropping a cookie on the ground and putting it back with the others It’s kind of sad, cheap owner and just plain disgusting. People deserve to know, do not recommend.
… moreJustin Kolsen
Paid 11 dollars for a sandwich with 4 slices of meet and 2 slices of bread and the bread was dry I will not eat at Papa Kelsey in Jerome ever again
… moreKyle Hotchkiss
The hot sandwiches here are phenomenal!! It might be weird to say but the bread is the best part.
… more