Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 395 Shanley St, Cheektowaga, NY 14206
Phone: (716) 894-0594
Website: https://www.papajspizzany.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Restaurant In Cheektowaga NY – Papa J’s Pizza
The Ultimate Burger Experience ; Appetizers · Eggroll Combo. (1 Each: Chicken, Steak, and Seafood). 17.99 ; Salads · CAESAR CHICKEN SALAD. 13.99 ; Chicken Fingers.
PAPA J’s PIZZA BAR & GRILL | Cheektowaga NY – Facebook
PAPA J’s PIZZA BAR & GRILL, Cheektowaga. 1263 likes · 1 talking about this · 73 were here. Papa J’s Pizza & Grill Open 7 days a week. 395 Shanley St…
PAPA J’s PIZZA BAR & GRILL (@papajspizza) – Instagram
228 followers · 517 posts · Open 7 Days a Week 395 Shanley St Cheektowaga, NY (716) 894-0594 Call/Order Online PICK UP & DELIVERY Happy Hour 4PM-8PM 4 PM …
Last Updates
Reviews
cheryl jessel
First time ordering from here, very disappointed. We ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza, added onions, green olives, black olives and mushrooms. We paid $ 35.00 only to get a skim of sauce, cheese in the center of the pie, no black olives and a small amount of the other ingredients we paid extra for. I don’t know about their other food but, go elsewhere for pizza.
… moreJoycee Williams
Placed a phone order for the Black Restaurant Week promotion and I really got my moneys worth. I ordered a personal cheese and pepperoni pizza and 10 hot wings for $20.24 and the portion size was enormous. The pizza’s cheese to sauce ratio was perfect! This sauce is a bit on the sweeter side but it was so good and seasoned just right! Great crust too!!The wings were the star of the show for me!
I’m an equal opportunist when it comes to flats and drums these wings were mighty. Not scrawny at all, the hot was down right with enough heat. I enjoyed my meal and had leftovers for lunch today!
… moreI’m an equal opportunist when it comes to flats and drums these wings were mighty. Not scrawny at all, the hot was down right with enough heat. I enjoyed my meal and had leftovers for lunch today!
Cristina Leonard
I ordered a honey Cajun chicken finger sub. The fingers were hard overcooked and old. My bread was hard. I will never ordered again. Then when I tried calling back they didn’t answer. They knew what they were making. If you wouldn’t eat, why serve it. I’m spending my money for garbage. Do better;
… moreShawn Stevenson
I’ve ordered from here just 3xs so far and everything time food got better. My only issue would be ask for more sauce.i got wings just once they were pretty good garlic parm and honey mustard. The sauce they use is amazing in my opinion. Have had a issue with customer service. All and all I will continue to support papa js
… moreHeather Wawro
We order from here every so often for delivery. As someone who works nights, I appreciate that they’re open so late. Their fish fries are solid and a great value for the price in my opinion. I also really enjoy their wings. Placed an order tonight and they had it to me within half an hour. Definitely recommend for a late night meal!
… moreDawn Goll
First time ordering from here, the pizza was good. The wings however, were a little overcooked and cold and we picked the food up, which is not acceptable and when we got there, we were told 210 for pick up and had to wait 20 more minutes for our food to be ready. Will give them another try hopefully it will improve also if you have a sieze the deal coupons you do not get special pricing on package
… moreApril
We had the $50 certificate and when I called and placed my order from their parking lot because a worker told us the bar was closed to renovation. When I got on the phone with a young man to order my food, he told me I can only use 1 coupon not both $25 ones and I told him that they clearly say i can use both at one time and he insist I can only use 1 so I told him I would bring them in to show him. I got to the window and I proceeded to try to show him the certificates and he walked away and a older lady came to talk to me and walked up by saying what’s the problem, I told there was no problem and told her what was going on and she looked over the certificates and turned and told the young man that I was allowed to use them and that they aren’t the ones he was thinking of that they are a dif promotion. I got home with my large pizza and dbl wings, the wings tasted like old grease and the blue cheese tasted bad that i couldn’t eat it either the wings or blue cheese that i spit it into my paper towel. I moved on to my pizza and it was actually pretty good!
I am extremely disappointed in the wings! they def need to change their oil and check their blue cheese or the refrigerator temperature. By the way it’s my first time ordering from them and I prob won’t give them another chance just from the experience I had in the beginning and then going home and being disappointed in the food. I do hope they get better!
… moreI am extremely disappointed in the wings! they def need to change their oil and check their blue cheese or the refrigerator temperature. By the way it’s my first time ordering from them and I prob won’t give them another chance just from the experience I had in the beginning and then going home and being disappointed in the food. I do hope they get better!
Braxton Wright
Orders take way to long to be ready. If you call to ask status you will be lied to and them hung up on. Order food elsewhere unless you want to wait hours. Trash
Update: we did receive the food after 2 hours which was then cold or Luke warm. The food was on par with the service. Bad. Wings were hard. Burger was a single preformed patty with no effort. Most of the food was thrown out.
… moreUpdate: we did receive the food after 2 hours which was then cold or Luke warm. The food was on par with the service. Bad. Wings were hard. Burger was a single preformed patty with no effort. Most of the food was thrown out.
Fran Calkins
Truly a hidden gem. Loved the pizza, chicken fingers. I had a gift certificate. Well worth the money. Next time I’ll spend my money there. Delicious!!
… moreLaura Wright
Horrible food. The prices are so high for mediocre quality. We ordered and it took almost 2 hours for it to be delivered. Wings were hard and dry, burger looked like it was frozen and not “XXL” as advertised. “Hot” sub showed up cold. Just don’t eat here
… more