Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Fairborn, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Fairborn pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Fairborn or stop by 44 S CENTRAL AVE for carryout to order the best pizza in Fairborn, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns S Central Ave | Papa Johns Fairborn, OH
Call Papa Johns S Central Ave at (937) 879-7272 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough to …
papa johns stores in fairborn, oh
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Fairborn, Ohio to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
Luis Rodriguez
I’ve been coming here for years never had a problem until today 11/28/26. Ordered 1 large pizza half sausage half pepperoni. When we opened the box it looked like they had half a pepperoni laying around and added to our sausage pizza. The crust size and taste were completely off i even asked for extra sauce and cheese and appeared to have less then normal !!!!
… moreSarah A.
Been ordering here for years and the food is normally good however I recently ordered an order for delivery from the restaurant and it was switched to being picked up and delivered from DoorDash without my permission which I am NOT okay with. If I was okay with literally any random person handling my food I would’ve just ordered from DoorDash in the first place. I understand this is to reduce customer wait times but I do not want my food handled by someone who’s not an employee. In the future I think you should be able to opt out of your order being deliver via DoorDash, I would have been absolutely okay with a long wait time if it was coming from an employee and not DoorDash.
… moreJackie Hatley
Ordered my pizza online and it was really easy. The pizza was ready when I got there. Ordered a medium with a couple toppings. And one of the toppings was extra mushrooms. Which of course I’m sure that was extra since I asked for more than the usual amount. Not seeing any extra mushrooms and not really seeing that many to begin with. Will the say the pizza taste good and the price wasn’t bad. But when you order extra of something you expect extra not even less of the topping.
Update decided to give Papa John’s another chance on 6/30/25. Placed the order on the phone this time. Stated we’d like extra mushrooms and told them last time there was no extra mushrooms. He’s like I’ll make sure. Get the pizza and get home there’s no mushrooms. Go back to the store. Speak with the manager and he’s like we are out of mushrooms. The call center wouldn’t know that. When I paid for my pizza the manager is the one who rang me up. All he had to do was tell me I’m sorry but we’re out of mushrooms but that didn’t happen. Apparently I’m supposed to have a credit for another pizza but not for sure because he took off running to the dough station and went running to the back of the store to get something and back to the dough station.. just a little bothered that the manager rang up the pizza seeing that extra mushrooms was on the ticket and didn’t say anything
… moreUpdate decided to give Papa John’s another chance on 6/30/25. Placed the order on the phone this time. Stated we’d like extra mushrooms and told them last time there was no extra mushrooms. He’s like I’ll make sure. Get the pizza and get home there’s no mushrooms. Go back to the store. Speak with the manager and he’s like we are out of mushrooms. The call center wouldn’t know that. When I paid for my pizza the manager is the one who rang me up. All he had to do was tell me I’m sorry but we’re out of mushrooms but that didn’t happen. Apparently I’m supposed to have a credit for another pizza but not for sure because he took off running to the dough station and went running to the back of the store to get something and back to the dough station.. just a little bothered that the manager rang up the pizza seeing that extra mushrooms was on the ticket and didn’t say anything
caitlin brackett
I usually don’t complain that much but last night’s experience was really disappointing. I ordered three pizzas, garlic parmesan bread sticks and extra sauce on the side because were a family that loves sauce, the garlic stuffed crust hardly had any garlic, and the bread sticks were normal but we ate them anyway, we were missing some of our sauces, and that’s fine, mistakes happen and I can imagine they were busy with peak dinner hours, the thing that really bothered me though was our doordash driver. Of the bat he was extremely rude, I was using a gift card I got for Christmas and some cash to pay for the food. I left a couple bucks there for him, I noticed some of our sauces were missing and I pointed it out and he said he wasn’t going to go back because I didn’t tip well enough… His service wasn’t that great so I tipped pretty fairly, even if I didn’t, that was completely uncalled for. /:
… moreGeoffrey Hinish
These people can’t seem to get an order right even when the sticker on the box literally tells you what should be on it then when you call in to get what you actually order the manager gets and attitude with you cause they can’t do their job right I’ll never order from these miserable people ever again…decided to give them another chance and get a pizza that was supposed to be extra cheese and instead get extra crust the size of LeBron James for head
… moreRobert Knasel
Not all Pizza slices had the toppings specified. Very light on toppings. Did not have extra cheese as well. Understanding why location has 3.3 stars.
… moreBailey Close
If I could give zero stars I would, I ordered on DoorDash and spent almost $40 for pizza that was mainly crust, I don’t understand the lack of care for the quality of food that they send out, it seems as though they do not care about keeping up with the quality of Papa John’s.
I did eat three pieces because I wasn’t wasting the food, but as stated I mainly was eating just crust.
… moreI did eat three pieces because I wasn’t wasting the food, but as stated I mainly was eating just crust.
TheEdub123
Been coming to this Papa Johns for 23 years, I’ve never had any issues with the staff, they’ve always been very nice. I will always recommend this location for some good pizza.
… moreAngie Smith
Never ever again will I order anything from this location. The manager of this location needs to take a lesson in customer service considering she called me a b**** for complaining about my pizza that obviously was not done along with the very lightly cooked breadsticks. I called another location that I am familiar with and the DM was there. I want to give huge appreciation to this DM. She personally made my pizzas and delivered them to me although I was short of their delivery for this location. She was very kind and handled the situation immediately.
… moreJoshua Kramer
Delivered 2 pizzas that looked like this when opened. I called and they refused a refund. When I asked to speak to the GM they stated he was not in. I asked for a return call from the GM and they said they would not do that either. I asked when the GM would be in next and they said it was “illegal to give employee schedules and to call back at a later time” lol. What a top notch establishment.
… more