For Papa Johns Pizza in Fairfield, OH, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (513) 858-7272 for delivery or stop by Dixie Hwy for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!
This location has went down hill. Our deliveries are always late and now our orders are consistently wrong. Last time we had Papa J’s, we received a pizza with the wrong toppings so my husband called the store. We were told they would make the correct pizza but we had to come pick it up? Not how that should go but whatever. My husband goes to pick it up and they made the pizza with the correct toppings but it was the wrong size (made a medium and he ordered a large). Today we ordered two pizzas and there was zero sauce on either pizza.
I’m a huge fan of pizza in almost any variety. Papa John’s has been a staple for our pizza night for the last decade. There are many locations that are close to our location and we have tried them all. This particular location is more consistent with their quality than the other locations in our area. I prefer to pickup and they are very consistent in having the pizza ready on time. Of course, the staff has been a bit overwhelmed during the last couple years but they haven’t allowed that to affect the quality of their pizza. Some nights it takes a bit longer for the pizza’s to be ready but they are worth the wait.
Pizza is not the size the box is stated. Bad place, I heard from other customers complain this place don’t support Bengal 50% off after win.
A month ago, I ordered a large pizza from the Fairfield OH Papa Johns. I wanted it cut in squares, so online, I marked that I wanted it in squares. When the pizza arrived, it was cut in slices. Not what I wanted, but whatever. Doesn’t affect much.
What a horrible experience…..
Ordered pizza at 13:15 and now is 14:43. Called the manager and he just said sorry and hung up. My food is cold! I was 1.2miles away..
Very rude manager called because I always never get my sauces that I order and called about it finally after it happed once again and she didn’t even say sorry and wasn’t responding to me and just hung up. Won’t order from this location again! Also just went to eat my cheese sticks and this was underneath them!!
The orders have been perfect every time with friendly quick delivery
Typically, the pizza is good and the staff is friendly. However, they refused to honor online deals because the website was supposed to reflect updated deals ( but it didn’t). To top it off, our Philly cheese steak pizza was nearly meatless, see photo.
Nikki Rae Rae
I hadn’t ordered in awhile but I had a good coupon so I gave it another try. The order was correct and hot, came earlier than expected and the driver was pleasant, will definitely order from again!