Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Orange Park, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Orange Park pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Orange Park or stop by 38C BLANDING BLVD for carryout to order the best pizza in Orange Park, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 38C Blanding Blvd C, Orange Park, FL 32073
Phone: (904) 276-7272
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Blanding Blvd | Papa Johns Orange Park, FL
Call us for pizza delivery in Orange Park or stop by 950 BLANDING BLVD for carryout to order the best pizza in Orange Park, along with breadsticks, wings, and …
4315 US HIGHWAY 17 – Orange Park – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
At Papa Johns Pizza in Orange Park, FL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, …
papa johns stores in orange park, fl
PAPA JOHNS STORES IN ORANGE PARK, FL · Blanding Blvd. 950 BLANDING BLVD. Open Closes at 11:00 PM · Blanding Blvd. 38C BLANDING BLVD. Open Closes at 12:00 AM · Us …
Last Updates
Reviews
Glen Miley Collier
Last night I ordered the Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites, Spicy Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust with extra meatballs, Doritos Cool Ranch Steak Papadia, and a Mtn Dew. What a treat and a delight! It was like a celebration in my mouth with each tasty bite.
The delivery driver, Ryan, was spectacular. Big smile on his face showing he enjoys doing his job well.
… moreThe delivery driver, Ryan, was spectacular. Big smile on his face showing he enjoys doing his job well.
Kid Rivera
Today I went in and ordered a large pizza, and the gentleman in the picture is the one that made it. I’m assuming he was the manager on duty given there was no one else in the store. OK service but he did not wash his hands before making my pizza after touching the counters phones and everything else in the store. No gloves, or anything. I won’t be coming back
… moreThanos Prime
So my wife asked for a Phily cheesesteak pizza as a surprise for my birthday, but surprise, I got a cheese pizza. $17.11 I will never go back. Sam’s cheese pizza $9.99
… moreB Reilly
Worst Papa John’s pizza I have ever had. I wish I could post a picture of what it looks like. Completely flat including the crust. It looks like a thin crust but it’s an original crust. Not to mention it was supposed to have extra sauce but it’s almost bone dry. Absolute trash. Papa John’s locations are usually pretty consistent but this one obviously has some issues. Shame on management for letting this pizza go out to a customer.
… moresimplesandy
I just called to have this pizza delivered..
It literally took from the time I hung up to delivery time 17 min..and it is piping hot and delicious..I tipped the guy 5.00 dollars..
Thank you papa johns..I will be calling you again..
… moreIt literally took from the time I hung up to delivery time 17 min..and it is piping hot and delicious..I tipped the guy 5.00 dollars..
Thank you papa johns..I will be calling you again..
Rachel Carlin
I’d actually never had Papa John’s before, but wanted to get the jack-o’-lantern pizza on Halloween for my kids. I was very impressed with the speed and efficiency this location had on a busy holiday, and I was even more impressed with how cute and tasty the pizza was!
… moreJason Adams
The wings were the size of a cotton swab (metaphorically), still the smallest i have ever seen. I guess you get what you pay for but considering they were still over $1 a wing, I still feel cheated. The reason they got 2 stars is because the hot sauce was pretty good. The problem with the sauce is that it was poured over the wings and not tossed with them. And to think it was harder to get lower than the mediocre pizza.
… moreAngel Brooks
Review for Papa John’s
I was really disappointed with my recent experience at Papa John’s. The pizza arrived seriously cold, even though the tracking app showed it had been picked up 30 minutes earlier. To make matters worse, it still took another 30 minutes to travel just 2.8 miles to my house. By the time it finally got here, it wasn’t even remotely fresh or enjoyable.
This isn’t the quality or service I expect when I order from Papa John’s. If they’re going to offer delivery tracking, it needs to reflect accurate times, and the delivery process needs to be way more efficient. Sadly, this experience left a bad taste in my mouth—literally and figuratively.
Rating:
… moreI was really disappointed with my recent experience at Papa John’s. The pizza arrived seriously cold, even though the tracking app showed it had been picked up 30 minutes earlier. To make matters worse, it still took another 30 minutes to travel just 2.8 miles to my house. By the time it finally got here, it wasn’t even remotely fresh or enjoyable.
This isn’t the quality or service I expect when I order from Papa John’s. If they’re going to offer delivery tracking, it needs to reflect accurate times, and the delivery process needs to be way more efficient. Sadly, this experience left a bad taste in my mouth—literally and figuratively.
Rating:
Rach K
Great pizza. And arrived at scheduled delivery time.
Service: …
… moreService: …
Audrey Pomares
TERRIBLE MANAGEMENT AND SERVICE.
Specifically leaving this review for the general manager HAILEY SHEPHERD. Ordered my pizza at 9:00pm and pizza barely got to my house at 12am sitting on THE FLOOR OUTSIDE ON A DIRTY FLOOR MAT NEXT TO MY TRASH.
My pizza was delivered to the wrong address when I called to see the status of my delivery. After finding out it was sent to the wrong address, Hailey said it’d be free of charge, (she meant free delivery, which i already paid for initially, so absolutely nothing was free)
After the pizza was sent to the correct address no one ever knocked at my door upon arrival and mind you I live 5 MINUTES from this location. Was initially told it’d take 30-45 minutes. I asked Hailey for a refund since my pizza was cold and was tired of calling and them doing their job wrong, she said “I cant do that” so I asked for a discount on my next order (since it took 2 hours to get here and was just left on the floor outside), Hailey said “I can’t do that”. Just such disgusting behavior, you are supposed to show compassion to your customers in that kind of position.
Didn’t even get my 2 liter since she put the new order in for just a pizza.
Love being stuck with a cold pizza that was sitting outside with the bugs next to my trash, so yummy!! also love the fact my husband has to go to the store for soda when we just bought one from papa john’s and was supposed to be delivered to me. AT 12AM!!
it’s sad when you can’t do one of the most basic jobs and aren’t willing to provide for your customers and fulfill their order and what they paid for.
definitely feel robbed. will be calling corporate. very bad service and disgusting immature attitude from this manager that is supposed to be representing this company. very embarrassing for papa john’s. I have never been treated this way at this location and will go back to Dominoes. please do better
… moreSpecifically leaving this review for the general manager HAILEY SHEPHERD. Ordered my pizza at 9:00pm and pizza barely got to my house at 12am sitting on THE FLOOR OUTSIDE ON A DIRTY FLOOR MAT NEXT TO MY TRASH.
My pizza was delivered to the wrong address when I called to see the status of my delivery. After finding out it was sent to the wrong address, Hailey said it’d be free of charge, (she meant free delivery, which i already paid for initially, so absolutely nothing was free)
After the pizza was sent to the correct address no one ever knocked at my door upon arrival and mind you I live 5 MINUTES from this location. Was initially told it’d take 30-45 minutes. I asked Hailey for a refund since my pizza was cold and was tired of calling and them doing their job wrong, she said “I cant do that” so I asked for a discount on my next order (since it took 2 hours to get here and was just left on the floor outside), Hailey said “I can’t do that”. Just such disgusting behavior, you are supposed to show compassion to your customers in that kind of position.
Didn’t even get my 2 liter since she put the new order in for just a pizza.
Love being stuck with a cold pizza that was sitting outside with the bugs next to my trash, so yummy!! also love the fact my husband has to go to the store for soda when we just bought one from papa john’s and was supposed to be delivered to me. AT 12AM!!
it’s sad when you can’t do one of the most basic jobs and aren’t willing to provide for your customers and fulfill their order and what they paid for.
definitely feel robbed. will be calling corporate. very bad service and disgusting immature attitude from this manager that is supposed to be representing this company. very embarrassing for papa john’s. I have never been treated this way at this location and will go back to Dominoes. please do better