Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Durham, NC, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Durham pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Durham or stop by 4901 Hwy 55 for carryout to order the best pizza in Durham, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
3751 Holloway Street – Durham, NC – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Call us for pizza delivery in Durham or stop by 3751 Holloway Street for carryout to order the best pizza in Durham, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
papa johns stores in durham, nc
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Durham, North Carolina to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Pizza in Durham, NC | Papa Johns Holloway Street
Order from Papa Johns Holloway Street for the best pizza in Durham. Order online, call or visit for a selection of pizza and more for delivery or takeout!
Last Updates
Reviews
iiamxshari
I have ordered from this location at least 6–8 times, and there has been a consistent pattern of rushed and poorly prepared food.
Multiple orders have arrived incorrect or severely overcooked. Most recently, I ordered a pizza with a regular bake and it arrived extremely overdone and unevenly cooked. This has happened repeatedly, not just once.
Because these orders were placed through DoorDash, I attempted to resolve the issue there. However, DoorDash has now declined additional refunds due to frequency — even though the ongoing quality issues are coming from this store.
At this point, this reflects a serious lack of quality control and management oversight at this location. I am extremely disappointed, especially as a repeat customer who gave this store multiple chances.
I hope corporate reviews this location’s performance and addresses these recurring issues.
… moreMultiple orders have arrived incorrect or severely overcooked. Most recently, I ordered a pizza with a regular bake and it arrived extremely overdone and unevenly cooked. This has happened repeatedly, not just once.
Because these orders were placed through DoorDash, I attempted to resolve the issue there. However, DoorDash has now declined additional refunds due to frequency — even though the ongoing quality issues are coming from this store.
At this point, this reflects a serious lack of quality control and management oversight at this location. I am extremely disappointed, especially as a repeat customer who gave this store multiple chances.
I hope corporate reviews this location’s performance and addresses these recurring issues.
Steven T.
Ordered pizza for my team at work and what we received was very disappointing. I ordered extra cheese knowing that places these days skimp on toppings to begin with, but there was very little cheese on the pizzas. Also, the crust was far too thin to be the traditional crust. It’s obvious the dough portions have been reduced making the crust thinner. The pizza was not very good at all. Overall, a very poor experience. It’s clear why this location can’t even attain a 3 start rating. Spend your money elsewhere.
… moreFaith Dean
I ordered chicken and Alfredo. The pizza had no chicken, very little sauce and over all was not good. When I called the store a men told me that he “remembered cutting it but he’d just refund it” and then he hung up on me.
I wouldn’t lie about missing toppings. I should had looked at the reviews because ordering from this location and I will not order again. I wasted $30 and a hour of my time. I’m adding a picture to show that there is ZERO chicken since the employee implied I was lying.
… moreI wouldn’t lie about missing toppings. I should had looked at the reviews because ordering from this location and I will not order again. I wasted $30 and a hour of my time. I’m adding a picture to show that there is ZERO chicken since the employee implied I was lying.
Elliott Bentley
ordered a small pizza and a drink. said the order was going to be delivered by door dash when i ordered it through the stores website. After an hour of nothing showing up i saw that the tracker showed that my order had been cancelled by the door dash driver. When i called the store the told me the pizza is on the way so i waited another 20-30 minutes and nothing. I am currently on the phone while they just let it ring over and over. This papah johns is the absolute worst and I dont even think the owner cares because it has always been bad.
… moreShauna Pearsall
I truly can’t understand why this place has such a low rating. My family and I have ordered from this location at least 15 times now, and each time everything we ordered has been absolutely delicious.
… moreMeloy Williams
I usually order pizza online but when I tried doing so today, it says that delivery to my address was not available. I drove to the location and there was a sign on the door that I needed to use the drive through. I waited in tge line for over 15 minutes. I got to the window, the guy stated that they are not taking any orders at the moment. He commented and said that he was the only one who was working all morning and the other just got there so they are not taking any orders. I asked him why wasnt there a sign posted which would have prevented me from wasting my time. He began to argue with me and close the windows in my face. This level of service is so unsatisfactory and I will never go back there to spend my money.
… moreKenneth Young
This is absolutely the very worse pizza I have ever had. Normally papa johns is good and hot, normally. I am detains disappointed and will never order from this location. We ordered the pizza at 745 it arrived at 915. The pizza wasn’t even warm, the Pepsi was hotter than the pizza and we asked for crush red pepper and wasn’t given a single pack. I tried to call the manager but he never picked up. I was left on hold for over 20 minutes.
… moreDeric Boston
Ordered a Large Garlic 5-Cheese pizza with no toppings—it arrived with pepperoni. Called the store; the manager insisted, “I guarantee the pizza was made correctly because I made it,” refusing to acknowledge the mistake while I am looking at the mistake. Went to the store—he blamed “someone” else, offered no apology, and only reluctantly replaced it. Worst, most absurd customer service I’ve ever experienced.
… moreFiras Saleh
Location is always hit and miss. Sometimes it’s amazing and other times it’s sh*t. Today it was beyond sh*t.
Original order was for two pan pizzas. Pizzas tasted like raw dough, as seen by the photos. Called them and the manager was in denial. Requested 2 thin pizzas and still tasted like raw dough.
… moreOriginal order was for two pan pizzas. Pizzas tasted like raw dough, as seen by the photos. Called them and the manager was in denial. Requested 2 thin pizzas and still tasted like raw dough.
Shalondra Hughley
This Papa John has the worst customer service in the world!!!! This is the second and the last time I will ever order from this location. I really thought I was ordering from the Hope Valley location. So this evening I ordered my 3yr old grandson a cheese pizza. I sat here patiently waiting for an extra cheese pizza and it never shows up, so I call and I’m told it’s showing as already being delivered. No Sir! My order has not been delivered! The driver claimed he left it at the door because it was a no contact order which it was not like no contact order actually ended up having to call in and speak with a gentleman because I accidentally put that I was paying cash when I wasn’t paying cash. I was paying with my card. Why would somebody want to steal a cheese pizza? I don’t know, but I won’t be ordering from this location anymore because the last time I ordered from this location, I never received my Papa die and now my three old is sitting here hungry and I ordered pizza over an hour ago, but I’m being treated like I stole a cheese pizza
… more