Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Lewisburg, WV, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Lewisburg pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Lewisburg or stop by 237 Gateway Blvd. for carryout to order the best pizza in Lewisburg, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 237 Gateway Blvd Suite 2, Lewisburg, WV 24901
Phone: (304) 645-4442
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Gateway Blvd. | Papa Johns Lewisburg, WV
at (304) 645-4442 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough to use towards any menu item …
Pizza Stores in Lewisburg – WV – Papa Johns Pizza Locations
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Lewisburg, West Virginia to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
Halo
First of all, can y’all see these pictures? That alone is enough but I must go on. When I went in to get my order, the “gentleman” working said NOTHING just grabbed my boxes and handed them to me. I said thank you have a good night and guess what? Not the first word. Whatever. Once I got to the car I realized I didn’t get my 2 liter of soda so go back in and same guy with personality of a rock says: all that’s in the fridge is what we have (ordered mt dew) and all that was in there was root beer. Used to love Papa John’s but this was a 0/5 star experience. Will be contacting corporate considering I spent $34 to feed my family for dinner and lunch the next day just for everything (minus the cookie) go into the trash. Eating out isn’t something can afford often so when we do we expect to get our moneys worth.
… moreK Martinez
Absolutely disgusting. I order an ultimate garlic stuffed crust with cheese well done and a cookie and paid 40 something dollars after leaving a 20% tip. Only to get a sloppy soggy undercooked mess that was completely inedible! As soon as I grabbed the box from the delivery driver I knew something wasn’t right. The box was damp and saggy. Once I opened the lukewarm box I noticed the cheese was suck to the top. The pizza looked like it was flipped upside down; all the sauce and cheese was sloshed to one side pouring into the corners of the box itself. The pizza was doughy, wet and barely warm. It almost felt intentional how far from well done it was. It had black flakes of god knows what in it. Remnants of the dirty pan it was cooked it I’m sure. When I called to inform the manager I was told it would take 3 days for a refund. THIS PIZZA WAS HANDS DOWN THE WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER ATTEMPTED TO EAT!
… moreko2bme101
Used online app for 2 take out and was 8 bucks each. Quick making, quick ready time and we’re staying at Hampton Inn so close by. The check out associate offered plates and napkins which I felt was special considering she didn’t know we live here and happen to be staying at the hotel. Great service with a smile and super kind. Pizza is alright as usual and I believe that following the app messages sent to my cell for the making, baking, almost done and ready with estimate time has been the best yet for being about 2 minutes from here, grabbing the pizza, getting it back it was warm and not manufactured tasting like paste and odd cheese melt like wax when i’ts been delivered. This is how I remember Papa John’s tasting growing up. This would be the way to order too, they are quick and PICK IT UP. Thanks
… moreBryan Nash
Absolute horrible service. Lady asked who my order was for just to make me wait 15 minutes just to tell me after I asked again that she basically wasn’t gonna make my order. Employees immediately began hollering and cussing at me in a very threatening way. Lady I’m charge with the really thick eyebrows was very aggressive and basically refused to put any effort in. Will be contacting corporate manayand whoever else I need to ensure this issue is taken care of.
… moreRachel Doss
Manager has a poor attitude seemed like he was more interested in getting our order to get us out of there.
… moreMichelle Daily (Chel)
Always great pizza & have never had an order go wrong or incorrect. Staff is always very friendly and I do order online for pick-up as we live far outside delivery area but orders are always ready on time. My favorite pizza place always for take out. The Papa rewards plus specials offered are great as well if you sign up for them!
… moreJennifer Robbins
If I could rate this location on service alone, it would be a 0. The staff were rude. They acted like we didn’t exist. They ignored my sister for over 8 minutes when we went inside to pick up. (She was the only person there.) Our order was incorrect and missing our sauce. We would have turned around to have it fixed. Unfortunately, we had been at softball tournaments all day. And we were exhausted. This location was a disappointment.
… moreShannon A.B.
I hate that this is the only Papa Johns in our town. It is so stressful trying to get a pizza from here. If you go on to pick it up, you get ignored, they will look at you but not say a word and then get to you when they feel like it. Worse customer service ever, EVERYTIME. If you get a delivery, you wait for over an hour just to be told there is no order for you even though it was already paid for online. And good luck even getting them to answer the phone, lol it’s crazy. My call was transferred to another state like an answering service and even THEY couldn’t get the local store to pick up the phone. I think this will be the last time I stress myself out over pizza. It’s good but it ain’t THAT GOOD to get treated bad and get stressed out.
… morecindy meadows
I ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas and 1 cheese pizza with 4 cheese cups. They gave me 0 pepperoni pizzas and 0 cheese cups. When I called them back they said they were out of pepperoni and cheese cups, smh. They could have told me that when I ordered but didn’t. They didn’t offer me any money back. They only offered some quality assurance credit. One experience followed by another.
… moreKenNCarrie Jackson
Breadsticks were hard, plain and disgusting! The pizza didn’t have the same flavor of sauce that made me love Papa Johns! I had not ate at this one I guess they must be different but the ones I’ve ate at were the best pizza I’d ever tasted! This place was worse than store bought!
… more